New Mars Forums

For a structure with a 200 m (656 ft) diameter and 120 m (394 ft) tall parabolic dome, standard High-Volume, Low-Speed (HVLS) ceiling fans, typically with diameters up to 7.3 meters (24 feet), would be used in a calculated array to provide effective air circulation. Multiple fans, rather than a single massive fan, are required due to the immense size of the space. 

Step 1: Calculate the Floor Area and Assess Fan Coverage The floor area of the dome is a circle with a radius of 100 m:\(\text{Area}=\pi \times \text{radius}^{2}=\pi \times 100^{2}\approx 31,416\,\text{m}^{2}\,(338,166\,\text{ft}^{2})\)A single large HVLS fan (e.g., 7.3 m diameter) typically covers between 900 and 1,500 square meters. For cooling purposes, the coverage area is roughly five times the fan's diameter for large-blade fans, but for destratification (air mixing in very high spaces), it can be up to ten times. 

Step 2: Determine the Number and Placement of Fans Given the vast area, an array of fans is necessary. The general guideline is to space fans a distance equal to at least one fan diameter apart, or up to three times the diameter depending on the manufacturer and application. For consistent coverage, a grid pattern is ideal. For such a massive, open space, consulting with an HVLS expert for a custom layout drawing is crucial. The number of 7.3-meter (24-foot) fans could range from 21 to over 30 to cover the entire area effectively, depending on specific airflow requirements and building obstructions. 

Step 3: Consider Ceiling Height and Fan Mounting The 120 m (394 ft) ceiling is extremely high. While fans perform well when mounted between 6 and 12 meters (20 to 40 feet) above the floor, longer downrods might be needed to position the fans within the occupied zone for optimal air movement. The fans must also maintain safe clearance from the floor (at least 3 m or 10 ft) and other structural elements. 

Answer: For a parabolic dome ceiling with a 200 m diameter and 120 m height, multiple HVLS fans with diameters typically ranging from 6.1 meters to 7.3 meters (20 to 24 feet) would be required. The exact number and strategic placement of fans, likely exceeding two dozen units, should be determined through a professional airflow study to ensure uniform air circulation and temperature control

Commercial 7m (7-meter) fans refer to large industrial fans, often HVLS (High-Volume, Low-Speed) ceiling fans, used for cooling vast spaces like warehouses, factories, malls, and arenas, providing massive airflow (measured in CFM) for comfort and energy efficiency in huge commercial areas. You'll find them as massive ceiling units or powerful pedestal/wall-mounted fans designed for serious air movement, not typical home use, with high CFM ratings (thousands) for effective cooling.
Key Characteristics:
Size & Type: Look for HVLS fans (often 7 feet or more in diameter) or large pedestal/wall fans, not standard residential ceiling fans.
Airflow (CFM): Measured in Cubic Feet per Minute; higher CFM means more air moved, crucial for large spaces (e.g., 7000+ CFM is common).
Applications: Warehouses, factories, gyms, shopping centers, agricultural buildings, and large event spaces.
Benefits: Better air circulation, reduced heat, improved comfort, and energy savings over traditional AC in large buildings.
Where to Find Them:
Home Improvement Stores: The Home Depot offers large industrial ceiling fans.
Online Marketplaces: Alibaba.com has many manufacturers for 7m industrial fans.
Specialty Retailers: Amazon.com (for large pedestal/wall fans) and industrial fan suppliers.
When searching, use terms like "HVLS fan," "industrial ceiling fan," "large commercial fan," or specify CFM and diameter (like 7ft or 7m) for best results

A thermosyphon cooling system uses natural convection (hot fluid rises, cold fluid sinks) to circulate a coolant (like water or oil) for passive, pump-free heat removal, relying on gravity and density changes to create a continuous flow from a heat source to a radiator or heat sink and back. Common in early cars (Ford Model T), modern electronics, and solar water heaters, it's simple, reliable, and energy-efficient but best for lower heat loads where the radiator sits above the heat source.

How it Works (Engine Example)
Heat Absorption: Water in the engine's water jacket absorbs heat from the cylinders.
Rising Hot Water: The heated water becomes less dense and rises through an upper hose to the radiator's top tank.
Cooling in Radiator: Air passing over the radiator fins (often aided by a fan) cools the water as it flows down through the tubes.
Sinking Cold Water: The now cooler, denser water sinks to the radiator's bottom tank and returns to the engine via a lower hose, completing the cycle.
Key Principles & Components
Natural Convection: Relies on the difference in density between hot and cold fluids.
Gravity: The radiator must be positioned higher than the heat source for gravity to assist flow.
No Pump: Eliminates the need for a mechanical water pump, saving energy and reducing complexity.
Heat Exchanger: A radiator or cooling coils dissipate heat into the surrounding air or another cooling medium.
Applications
Automotive: Older cars (e.g., Ford Model T) and some small engines.
Electronics: Cooling CPUs and power modules in servers, telecom base stations, and control panels.
Solar: Solar water heaters use thermosiphons to circulate water.
Industrial: Cooling mechanical seals in pumps.

Advantages & Limitations
Pros: Simple, reliable, low maintenance, no extra energy input needed.
Cons: Less efficient for high heat loads; requires specific vertical positioning (radiator above engine/heat source)

However, the team found that the main experiment yielded fewer fruits than expected. Palmer says that this is due to the challenges of getting the light, temperature and irrigation just right in larger growing spaces.

Designing a Martian menu involves creating a sustainable food system that provides nutritious, tasty, and varied meals with minimal resources for years, focusing on lightweight, shelf-stable items (like freeze-dried foods) and on-site crop growth (e.g., potatoes, spirulina, lettuce) to combat menu fatigue, ensure health, and support crew morale far from Earth, addressing major challenges like water usage, waste, energy, and microgravity cooking.
Key Components of a Martian Food System:
Pre-Packaged & Processed Foods:
Freeze-dried/Dehydrated: Water is removed to reduce weight and extend shelf life, requiring rehydration with water. Examples: fruits, vegetables, meats.
Thermostabilized: Similar to Earth canned/pouch foods, sealed for preservation.
Natural/Semi-Dried: Ready-to-eat items.
Condiments: Sauces, spices to add flavor variety.
On-Site Production ( Hydroponics/Aeroponics): Growing crops like potatoes, tomatoes, soybeans, wheat, spinach, lettuce, and nutrient-rich spirulina (algae).
Cellular Agriculture: Culturing meat or other proteins (future potential).
Menu Design Principles:
Nutrition: Meet daily caloric needs, maintain nutrient density over years, support bone/muscle health in low gravity.
Palatability & Variety: Combat menu fatigue with diverse flavors, textures, and easy preparation to keep astronauts eating well.
Resource Efficiency: Minimize mass, volume, energy, and water use; reduce waste.
Safety: Rigorous testing for contaminants in closed-loop systems.
Simplicity: Quick, easy meal prep for busy schedules in microgravity.
Sample "Martian" Meal Ideas:
Breakfast: Freeze-dried berries with rehydrated yogurt, wheat porridge with spirulina boost, or omelets with hydroponic spinach.
Lunch: Tomato soup (from dried tomatoes) with soy-based protein, sandwiches on Martian-grown wheat bread, or spirulina-enriched pasta.
Dinner: Rehydrated chicken/beef with freeze-dried veggies, potato-based dishes, or "Martian" pizza using grown ingredients.
Key Challenges Addressed by the Menu:
Transportation Costs: Freeze-drying reduces weight, making food cheaper to launch.
Psychological Support: Familiar, tasty food improves crew well-being.
Sustainability: Growing food on Mars creates a closed-loop system, reducing Earth reliance

The Nutrition paper, authored by NASA scientists Douglas, Sara Zwart, and Scott Smith, highlights the general criteria for a potential Mars or other space exploration mission food system, including: 

Safety: The space station’s food system is tested and processed on Earth to ensure the food is safe for astronauts to eat. Food grown aboard the spacecraft and in microgravity could interact with microbes that float and mix with the spacecraft’s atmosphere until removed by air and water filters. Thus, resources will be required for cleaning and testing to reduce the risk of crews succumbing to foodborne illnesses.

Stability: Crews will not have the luxury of phoning home to resupply food on a multi-year, round-trip mission to Mars, meaning the food that the crew members bring with them or grow must last for years. Consequently, the nutrition and quality of the Mars food system must be stable for the length of the mission. 

Palatability: Equally important is ensuring the food on a Mars mission is enjoyable to consume. Otherwise, astronauts may not consume enough food to support their health and well-being.

Nutrition: The Mars food system must provide food that is as nutritious as it is delicious. To function, the human body requires a handful of essential nutrients that must be absorbed from food. Failing to fulfill any one of these nutritional requirements can result in a deficiency that leads to a variety of health problems.

Resource minimization: Resources such as water, power, and volume are limited in a spacecraft. The Mars food system needs to provide safe, nutritious, palatable food while keeping resource consumption and waste production to a minimum. “You can have a food system that provides everything you need, but if it doesn’t fit within the resources, you cannot take it with you,” Douglas said.

Variety: The Mars food system must provide a variety of food so that astronauts don’t grow tired of consuming the same thing. “Menu fatigue” can dampen crew morale and cause astronauts to eat less, which can lead to health issues.

Reliability: “One of the big concerns with growing food is that if it doesn’t grow and you were depending on it, now you have insufficient food, which can be a very, very big concern when you’re going on these missions,” Douglas said. As a result, an exploration mission food system has to be dependable.

Usability: The Mars food system must allow crews to prepare meals with ease, providing them the time to focus on mission-critical tasks. “Prepackaged foods are a great candidate because they are easy to prepare, easy to consume. They already have a safe and long history in spaceflight, but there are some challenges with them—that nutrition and quality degrade over time,” Douglas said. “So, on longer missions, it would be nice to get a fresh component.”

Space-ready appliances: Astronauts aboard the space station prepare meals with heat or by adding water. The Mars food system will require new food preparation equipment that satisfies safety and spaceflight requirements.

The main Biosphere 2 crew size for its primary two-year mission (1991-1993) was eight people (four men, four women) in a sealed, self-sustaining ecosystem, with a smaller, seven-person crew for a shorter, second mission in 1994. These crews studied closed-system living, a precursor to space colonization, managing complex biomes and food production within the massive glass structure.

seven biome areas were a 1,900-square-meter (20,000 sq ft) rainforest, an 850-square-meter (9,100 sq ft) ocean with a coral reef, a 450-square-meter (4,800 sq ft) mangrove wetlands, a 1,300-square-metre (14,000 sq ft) savannah grassland, a 1,400-square-meter (15,000 sq ft) fog desert, and two anthropogenic biomes: a 2,500-square-meter (27,000 sq ft) agricultural system and a human habitat with living spaces, laboratories and workshops.

The oxygen inside the facility, which began at 20.9%, fell at a steady pace and after 16 months was down to 14.5%. This is equivalent to the oxygen availability at an elevation of 4,080 meters (13,390 ft

tahanson43206 wrote:

For SpaceNut ...

Nice image in https://newmars.com/forums/viewtopic.ph … 86#p236186

Please see if your AI Friend is capable of doing more than just offering hand waving and high level overviews.

We need specific equipment recommendations for Calliban's Dome.

GW Johnson is (currently) thinking about cooling air and removing water by creating an opening from the dome for passage of air to outside radiators. I am worried that precious thermal energy would be lost to the dome interior if that were done.

I think  your illustration of a mechanism inside the dome has the opportunity to avoid loss of thermal energy to Mars.

Please see if your AI friend can recommend specific off-the-shelf products to handle the air inside Calliban's Dome.

Also... please consider going back to Calliban's original sketch of what the floor plan might look like. I think we've allowed ourselves to be distracted by the ideas of tiers of layers of housing.  I know that Calliban introduced that idea, but I don't think we should give up on the Italian Plaza vision that Calliban showed us early on.

If we return to the Italian Plaza vision, then we are creating something that wealthy Martians can inhabit, and working Martians can visit for special occasions.

(th)

When calculating the relationship between LED bulbs, the volume of a space (cubic meters), and the mounting height, you are primarily looking at how much light (lumens) is needed to fill a specific 3D volume effectively. 1. Calculating Volume in Cubic Meters (\(m^{3}\)) To find the volume of your room, multiply the length, width, and height in meters. Formula: \(\text{Volume}(m^{3})=\text{Length}(m)\times \text{Width}(m)\times \text{Height}(m)\).Example: A room that is 5m long, 4m wide, and 3m high has a volume of \(60m^{3}\). 2. Determining Light Requirements (Lumens) Lighting is typically calculated based on floor area (square meters), but for high ceilings, you must adjust for volume or height. Residential standard: Aim for roughly 300–500 lumens per square meter for bright areas like kitchens or offices.Height Adjustment: As the ceiling height increases, you need more lumens because light intensity decreases over distance. For ceilings over 3 meters (approx. 10 feet), it is recommended to increase your total lumen count by 25-30% for every additional meter of height to maintain the same brightness at floor level. 3. LED Wattage vs. Installation Height If you are using high-output LED bulbs (High Bay lights), the mounting height dictates the required wattage to ensure the light reaches the ground effectively: Installation Height Recommended LED WattageIdeal Environment0 – 3 meters (0-9 ft)60W (Standard/Low)Residential, Small Garages4 – 6 meters (13-20 ft)100W – 150WWorkshops, Low-rise Warehouses6 – 8 meters (20-26 ft)200W – 250WManufacturing Halls, Medium Warehouses8 – 12 meters (26-39 ft)300W – 400WLarge Logistics Centers12+ meters (39+ ft)500W+Stadiums, Hangars4. How Many Bulbs Do You Need? Once you have determined the total lumens required for your cubic space, divide that by the output of a single LED bulb. Formula: \(\frac{\text{Total\ Lumens\ Needed}}{\text{Lumens\ per\ Bulb}}=\text{Number\ of\ Bulbs}\).A standard 10W LED bulb typically produces 800–1,000 lumens.

Determining the output of an LED bulb relative to a room's volume (\(m^{3}\)) and height (\(m\)) involves calculating the total lumens required to achieve a specific light intensity (Lux). Core Calculation Formulas Total Lumens (lm): Multiply the room's surface area by the target Lux.\(\text{Lumens}=\text{Area\ }(m^{2})\times \text{Lux}\)Area (\(m^{2}\)): Derived from volume and height.\(\text{Area}=\text{Volume\ }(m^{3})\div \text{Height\ }(m)\)Target Lux Levels: Standard guidelines suggest:Ambient (Living areas): 100–300 Lux.Task (Kitchens/Offices): 300–500 Lux.Bright (Bathrooms/Workspaces): 700–800 Lux. BBCode Output for Forums/Calculators The following BBCode block presents these calculations in a structured format suitable for message boards: bbcode[center][size=4]LED Lighting Output Requirements[/size][/center]

• Room Volume: {Volume} m³

• Ceiling Height: {Height} m

• Target Intensity: 300 Lux (Standard Task Lighting)

[hr]

Step 1: Calculate Floor Area
[indent]Area = Volume / Height[/indent]
[indent]{Volume} m³ / {Height} m = {Area} m²[/indent]

Step 2: Total Lumens Required
[indent]Lumens = Area × Lux[/indent]
[indent]{Area} m² × 300 Lux = {Total_Lumens} lm[/indent]

Step 3: Recommended Bulb Count (Based on 800lm LED)
[indent]Bulbs = Total Lumens / 800[/indent]
[indent]{Total_Lumens} / 800 = {Bulb_Count} Bulbs[/indent]

Note: Higher ceilings (above 3m) may require 20-50% more lumens to account for light scattering before reaching the floor.

Height Adjustment Considerations Light Scattering: For every meter increase in height above standard levels (approx. 2.4m), light intensity drops. High ceilings may require additional lumens to ensure effective illumination at ground level.Mounting Height: A general rule for high-bay lighting is that a light mounted at 15 feet (4.5m) can effectively brighten about 12 feet (3.6m) of space.Logarithmic Scaling: Some advanced calculations use logarithmic formulas for "ceiling height adjustment" because the increase in required lumens is not linear as height grows

The diameters of each of the 26 floors in the parabolic dome range from 200.00 meters at the base to 39.22 meters at the top floor, as detailed below. Step 1: Define the parabolic equation and floor heights The dome is modeled as a paraboloid of revolution. With the base at \(y=0\) m and the vertex at the top, \(y=120\) m, the equation of the parabola can be defined as \(x^{2}=4p(y-120)\). The base radius is \(100\) m (half of the \(200\) m diameter), so we solve for \(4p\): \(100^{2}=4p(0-120)\)\(10000=-120(4p)\)\(4p=-\frac{10000}{120}=-\frac{250}{3}\)The equation is \(x^{2}=-\frac{250}{3}(y-120)\). The floor heights are evenly spaced by a distance of \(120\text{\ m}/26\approx 4.62\) m. Step 2: Calculate each floor's diameter The radius \(r\) at any given height \(y\) is \(x\), so \(r^{2}=-\frac{250}{3}(y-120)\), and the diameter \(D=2r=2\sqrt{-\frac{250}{3}(y-120)}\). The following table lists the height and
corresponding diameter for each floor: Floor Number Height (m)Diameter

To determine the diameter of each floor in a parabolic dome that is 120 meters tall with a 200-meter base diameter, we use the standard parabolic equation for a cross-section. Geometric Parameters Total Height (\(H\)): 120 mBase Diameter (\(D\)): 200 m (Base Radius \(R=100\) m)Number of Floors: 26Average Floor Height: ~4.615 m (assuming uniform distribution: \(120\text{\ m}/26\) floors) Parabolic Equation The radius \(r\) at any given height \(h\) from the ground for a downward-opening parabola is given by the formula:\(r=R\sqrt{1-\frac{h}{H}}\)The diameter at that height is simply \(2r\). 

Floor Diameter Table (BBCode) 

[table][tr][th]Floor[/th][th]Height (m)[/th][th]Diameter (m)[/th][/tr][tr][td]Ground (1)[/td][td]0.00[/td][td]200.00[/td][/tr][tr][td]2[/td][td]4.62[/td][td]196.11[/td][/tr][tr][td]3[/td][td]9.23[/td][td]192.15[/td][/tr][tr][td]4[/td][td]13.85[/td][td]188.10[/td][/tr][tr][td]5[/td][td]18.46[/td][td]183.95[/td][/tr][tr][td]6[/td][td]23.08[/td][td]179.70[/td][/tr][tr][td]7[/td][td]27.69[/td][td]175.34[/td][/tr][tr][td]8[/td][td]32.31[/td][td]170.86[/td][/tr][tr][td]9[/td][td]36.92[/td][td]166.25[/td][/tr][tr][td]10[/td][td]41.54[/td][td]161.49[/td][/tr][tr][td]11[/td][td]46.15[/td][td]156.59[/td][/tr][tr][td]12[/td][td]50.77[/td][td]151.53[/td][/tr][tr][td]13[/td][td]55.38[/td][td]146.28[/td][/tr][tr][td]14[/td][td]60.00[/td][td]141.42[/td][/tr][tr][td]15[/td][td]64.62[/td][td]135.53[/td][/tr][tr][td]16[/td][td]69.23[/td][td]130.05[/td][/tr][tr][td]17[/td][td]73.85[/td][td]124.30[/td][/tr][tr][td]18[/td][td]78.46[/td][td]118.25[/td][/tr][tr][td]19[/td][td]83.08[/td][td]111.87[/td][/tr][tr][td]20[/td][td]87.69[/td][td]105.11[/td][/tr][tr][td]21[/td][td]92.31[/td][td]97.90[/td][/tr][tr][td]22[/td][td]96.92[/td][td]90.14[/td][/tr][tr][td]23[/td][td]101.54[/td][td]81.69[/td][/tr][tr][td]24[/td][td]106.15[/td][td]72.28[/td][/tr][tr][td]25[/td][td]110.77[/td][td]61.42[/td][/tr][tr][td]26[/td][td]115.38[/td][td]48.35[/td][/tr][/table]

 Usage Notes Floor 1 starts at ground level (0m height), representing the maximum 200m base.Floor Heights assume a standard vertical spacing of approximately 4.62 meters per floor, which is within the range for high-ceiling commercial or mixed-use structures.The top floor (26) is located at 115.38m, leaving approximately 4.62m of clearance to the 120m apex

Dehumidification systems remove excess moisture from the air to improve comfort, health, and building integrity by preventing mold, allergens, and structural damage, using methods like refrigeration (cooling coils to condense water) or desiccants (absorbing moisture). These systems range from portable units for basements to whole-house integrated systems or large industrial setups, often connecting to HVAC or operating independently for precise humidity control (aiming for 40-60% RH).
Types of Systems
Refrigerant Dehumidifiers: Use a chilled coil to cool air below its dew point, condensing water into a collection pan or drain, similar to an air conditioner but focused on moisture removal.
Desiccant Dehumidifiers: Employ moisture-absorbing materials (desiccants) to pull water from the air, offering precise control in varied temperatures, ideal for industrial or low-humidity needs.
Whole-House Systems: Integrated with your HVAC, these handle humidity for the entire home, often using a dedicated dehumidifier to reduce the AC's load.
Portable Units: Standalone devices for specific rooms, basements, or crawl spaces.
Ventilation Preconditioning: Systems that dehumidify incoming outdoor air before it enters the building, reducing load on main systems.
Key Benefits
Health: Reduces mold, mildew, dust mites, and allergens, improving respiratory health.
Comfort: Eliminates that "sticky" feeling, making indoor air feel cooler.
Property Protection: Prevents warping, rot, musty odors, and pest issues in homes and structures.
HVAC Efficiency: Allows air conditioners to focus on temperature (sensible load) rather than moisture (latent load).
Common Applications
Residential: Basements, crawl spaces, whole homes, especially in tight, energy-efficient houses.
Commercial/Industrial: Warehouses, manufacturing, data centers, hospitals, pools, and ice rinks requiring specific low humidity levels