New Mars Forums

Official discussion forum of The Mars Society and MarsNews.com

You are not logged in.

Announcement

Announcement: As a reader of NewMars forum, we have opportunities for you to assist with technical discussions in several initiatives underway. NewMars needs volunteers with appropriate education, skills, talent, motivation and generosity of spirit as a highly valued member. Write to newmarsmember * gmail.com to tell us about your ability's to help contribute to NewMars and become a registered member.

#1 Re: Not So Free Chat » Corporal Punishment on Mars - Should it be Permitted or Not? » 2005-02-16 01:02:42

Laree Slack, 12, was beaten with an electrical cable in accordance with the Biblical prescription "40 lashes minus 1, times three."  This did beat the living daylights out of her -- she died.  See the details at http://www.ffrf.org/fttoday/2001/dec01/ … other.html

The JWs didn't know their Bible (big surprise there), the reporters didn't, and you don't. There's no "prescription" like that in the Bible, nothing resembling such a prescription, and, if you can follow basic grammer, not even a description of it. The description is actually forty minus 1 five times:

23Are they ministers of Christ? (I speak as a fool) I am more; in labours more abundant, in stripes above measure, in prisons more frequent, in deaths oft.

   24Of the Jews five times received I forty stripes save one.

   25Thrice was I beaten with rods, once was I stoned, thrice I suffered shipwreck, a night and a day I have been in the deep;

   26In journeyings often, in perils of waters, in perils of robbers, in perils by mine own countrymen, in perils by the heathen, in perils in the city, in perils in the wilderness, in perils in the sea, in perils among false brethren;

   27In weariness and painfulness, in watchings often, in hunger and thirst, in fastings often, in cold and nakedness.

I underlined the part they mistakenly read together so you don't miss it.

None of this has anything whatsoever to do with parental discipline. Furthermore, the "forty stripes" is a Mosaic reference. For GROWN MEN, the limit was forty. But the rabbis were worried the person administering it might forget to count one, so the maximum was set at 39 so that if it went over by one, it was still inside the Law. These were five separate occasions, of course, because doing five of them at once is well beyond what Moses permitted.

Just setting the record straight.

#2 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Role of Religion in the Martian frontier » 2004-10-29 12:40:03

If the power of the state, under certain circumstances, to kill a person means that we have no rights, why doesn't the same logic apply to the power to put people in cages? It's kind of hard to pursue happiness while imprisoned, at least as most people understand happiness.

But anyway, for Morris --

1) Does this oath apply to secular ideologies, or not? After all, more people have been killed in the name of the Workers' Paradise than in the name of Jesus, in spite of Christians having a huge head start.

2) If not, how can you justify requiring religious people to falsely accuse themselves by implication of being uniquely dangerous, to the point of requiring special laws and oaths and penalties before they can be permitted to live?

3) If so, how do you deal with the fact that ANY state must have an account of why it can legitimately use force to imprison or execute or otherwise punish offenders and to collect taxes, and that this is the definition of an ideology -- thus consistuting a secular (or religious) ideology which justifies violence against "unbelievers"? And it doesn't help to suggest the state could merely require adherence to the laws and payment of taxes without adhering to any particular justification for this, because the same logic could justify a church demanding tithes from all while not requiring anyone to confess the Creed.

4) What about denominations that forbid oaths?

5) And what about Orthodox Jews who say that when the Messiah comes they will execute idolaters, or Reconstructionist Postmillenialists who say that when the Millenium starts most of humanity will be regenerated, and then they will execute idolaters? They're not an immediate threat to you (or any kind of threat at all unless they're right -- and if they're right, the thing to do is join them), yet you seem to think you have a right to go past their noses into their mouths and their very minds. Why? Do you own them? Would you like to?

6) What is the exact wording if this oath?

#3 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » The New Frontier - About Mars, settlement, and space law » 2004-09-03 13:49:47

Socrates:

1) The World Health Organization has zip to do with Mars.

2) The only mention of Bush that I see is a call for him to adopt the policy favored by the authors. Concidering that we Americans have a two-term limit for our President, and that even if tomorrow we started going all-out to get to Mars it would have longer than 4 years and a few months, there's no chance Bush will still be in office when the first landing happens, let alone the arrival of the first settlers.

#4 Re: Civilization and Culture » A ProtoMartian Curriculum - Lessons from Cobb Hill » 2004-07-30 17:11:49

The fascist in me sees much potential in this, though the libertarian is reaching for the rifle.

The rifle, man, go for the rifle! Kill the sucker!

(BTW, why do you quote the BoM? Are you a Mormon or something?)

#5 Re: Not So Free Chat » You're a 1st Marsian Settler » 2004-06-17 15:39:59

Settlement of the Brethren

Monday, Aphelion, Leo 24

Work began today sealing the last caved-in portion of the tubes with a glass covering. A site for the Sanctuary has been chosen, as have the sites of the farms. We have heard radio broadcasts by the earlier settlers. It seems in their madness they have gone after a false prophet, fitly named Cobra, that is, a serpent. And they drink to excess, not with one glass, but many.

He has spoken of us (he claims to have heard from the Most High; whether he was informed by the U.N., by spies, or by his demons, I know not), and, in the fashion of ranting false prophets, disclaimed the "task of retribution" against us, and then said he would not "suffer their heathenism", thus threatening us. The Council of Elders ordained that the robots, which have grenade launchers for use against the soldiers of the Adversary, be put on patrol around the base of our Mount Pavonis, and also that the Fabricator be used to make more such robots for a perpetual guard, and also to make a Great Battery atop the mountain, to break out with missles against any evil ones who draw near.

#6 Re: Not So Free Chat » You're a 1st Marsian Settler » 2004-06-17 11:51:34

Settlement of the Brethren

Lord's Day, Leo 23

This, the first entry, is entered four days after our arrival. We have entered the lava tubes of Pavonis Mons, and are making good progress toward sealing them from all leakage. The work seems likely, Lord willing, to be done by next Lord's Day. Afterward, we will pressurize the tubes and begin to build each man his house.

On the Earth, the heathens at the U.N. persecuted us for our plans, and attempted to prevent us, but they failed. They warned us, and told us of Chinese settlers to come (we rejoice at having heathens to proselytize), and of how the Lord smote the original settlers for their obstinate heathenism with strong madness. We do not fear them, and will make contact so that we can evangelize as soon as the city is properly founded within the tubes.

On a personal note, some of the more buxum sistren have sore tempted me to forsake the path of righteousness.

Tomorrow is Aphelion.

#7 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » A Politically Correct Development Plan - Communism & Socialism & Capitalism » 2004-06-08 22:28:44

Scotty;

Your “No plan” strategy for colonizing Mars will not work.  The difficulty of getting to Mars and surviving there requires extensive planning and huge capital investments.

You're essentially committing the fallacy of equivocation. It obviously requires *technical* planning, but, your fantasies notwithstanding, you can't (and shouldn't) engineer culture. The LAST sort of planning anyone needs is a wannabe Lycurgus imposing weird social structures on him.

#8 Re: Civilization and Culture » Marsian Status Symbols? » 2004-05-04 15:08:22

Sand? The real status item will be water from Mecca, from the well of Zamzam.

But maybe Earth-dirt will be a keepsake in the form of "native soil". That is, people might bring dirt from their back yards and pass it on to their children. After a few generations it might be highly valued.

#10 Re: Civilization and Culture » Militarization -Before- Colonization? » 2004-04-15 01:02:34

Rather than risk a war on Mars spilling over to the Earth, Mars will be settled by two teams, each drawn from all Earth nations: the Blues and the Greens.

The children of both will, of course, be raised from birth to hate the other.

#11 Re: Civilization and Culture » Permanent residents of Mars - what would they be like physically? » 2004-04-03 18:18:54

Cobra;

Of course, an army implies someone to fight against, which means you need at least two interplanetary empires/federations/whatever. (US vs. China?) And then they might get out of hand and actually go to war.

#12 Re: Civilization and Culture » Mars Design & Architecture - ...(how do you visualize it?) » 2004-04-02 13:09:07

What makes you think fung shui and Clean Lines will still be "ultra-contemporary"?

#13 Re: Civilization and Culture » Booze of the Red Planet - An account » 2004-03-23 20:45:14

Oh, I don't know... I think "don't drink possibly tainted water" is a pretty good life lesson, personally.

#14 Re: Civilization and Culture » Booze of the Red Planet - An account » 2004-03-22 15:01:52

Don't be dissin my boys the Puritans.

Every town in colonial Mass. was required by law to have at least one tavern. The reason they stopped so far north instead of going to Virginia like intended is that they ran out of beer and needed to land so they could brew more. Earlier, in Europe, John Calvin's salary included several hundred gallons of wine a year.

#17 Re: Civilization and Culture » Booze of the Red Planet - An account » 2004-03-12 23:50:04

I just looked it up myself. Interesting.

Drink: the Double Impact.

First Impact: 1 shot Thuj

Second Impact: 2 parts Noctis, 1 part Soju, 3 parts lemon juice. Drink immediately after First Impact.

[http://landofsoju.netfirms.com/soju.htm]Another view of soju.

#19 Re: Civilization and Culture » Booze of the Red Planet - An account » 2004-03-12 22:16:27

Aquavit: This vodka-like hard liquor was the first distinctively Martian drink. Less than a year after the first crew of settlers arrived, they ran out of the bourbon and vodka they had brought along, forcing them to improvise fermenting kitchen scraps and agricultural byproducts. They called the rather vile result of their first efforts pruno (see below). The heroic pioneers, undaunted, built a still and began producing a vodka-like distillate at around 80% alcohol. Cut with water to about 30%, it was named aquavit, the word used for hard liquor in Europe in the period following the introduction of distillation, from aqua vita, water of life. Various favored variations.

Noctis: Coffee beans are just the seeds inside the berries. The berries themselves are known as coffee cherries and also contain caffeine. In traditional Terran forms of coffee-growing, the cherries are discarded. On Mars, beginning with a religious settlement near Noctis Labyrinthus (the Neogathrist Pilgrims, who strongly emphasised frugality), uses were sought for the cherries by growers (some early examples still in use include Kophie Kola), but the most popular proved to be the wine-like Noctis. Named after its region of origin, it was originally required to be produced there to bear the name, like bourbon and champaign. Recently this convention has been abandoned, since the main advocates of it, the Neogathrists, died out following the High Prophet's endorsement of lifelong celibacy.

Pruno: Originally used as the first step in producing aquavit (see above), the arrival of Trey Webb, an experienced homebrewer, in M.Y. 8 lead to great advances in fermenting technique, eventually leading to a drinkable pruno. Still primarily produced from kitchen scraps and agricultural byproducts, which are sold to prunists rather than wasted, it was named pruno by the earliest settlers after the alcoholic beverage illicitly produced by American prisoners using primitive techniques akin to those initially used on Mars.


Thuj: High-proof distillate, as in uncut proto-aquavit, is steeped in wormwood (as in the Terran drink absinthe, but absinthe contains anise and other herbs not included in thuj), as well as Blue Lotus, guarana, valerian, peppermint, and others, and then distilled once again. This foul-tasting psychoactive liqueur is especially popular among students, artists, writers, and social dropouts, who form a subculture which began referring to itself by the old Terran word "bohemian" about ten years ago (causing a short-lived controversy with Czechan settlers). Banned after it first came into use, and was only allowed again after a wave of students went blind from a bad batch of black market thuj, and still retains an outlaw image. Named for thujone, a chemical found in wormwood.

#20 Re: Not So Free Chat » Foreign-Born Presidents? - ...(another can of worms?) » 2004-02-23 22:48:18

I'd like to observe here that clark objects to the Constitutional provision as going against values we should take as higher -- and mentions four (on my count) which are incompatible with each other if taken as normative. These being meritocracy, democracy, equality of opportunity, and efficiancy. If meritocracy is normative, we should fill offices by test results (only), like they used to do in China. If you take democracy as normative, why have age limits? Why, for that matter, have a Bill of Rights? After all, if the people suddenly decide they like unreasonable searches and seizures, what's a piece of paper written on by slaveowners to stop them? And if we really want equality of opportunity, officeholders should be chosen by a lottery. Why deny talentless or unpopular candidates an equal shot? And if we take efficiency as normative, it's an empirical question and in principle we might get a dictatorship. Trains on time, ect. (No doubt, my comments on democracy and efficiency got clark all excited. "Dictators! Trains! Searches and seizures! Woooooo!")

If an immigrant is upset that "you may never lead the way", they're coming here for the wrong reason anyway.

#21 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » The Care and Repair of Public Myth - Martians Need Myths Too » 2004-02-23 19:28:55

Apparently healthy, normal individuals get off on advocating the destruction of whole cities by asphyxiation.

#22 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » The Care and Repair of Public Myth - Martians Need Myths Too » 2004-02-22 21:27:42

Scott;

Considering that no one will ever take you seriously, you wasted all the time you spent "creating" an "aesthetic tradition".

Furthermore, every idea of yours I've ever seen is unspeakably stupid.

Gennaro;

:laugh:

Don't get out much, do you?

#23 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2004-01-27 22:03:58

Well, just a quick thought on Holidays.

Martian Holidays will likely include...

1.  Some sort of Holiday to Commemorate the first human landing on Mars.  Happy First Landing all!


2.  Days named in Honour of Mars probes.
For instance:  Today is the first Viking Day!  (Where we all dress up like vikings, drink beer and wrestle!-Think a St. Patrick's Day that had a train wreck with a Renaissance faire or three)
On Pathfinder day, we all run about.  On the day of Spirit, we do extreme sports in commemoration of that first bouncy re-entry.
3.  Other national holidays as needed.

Why in the world would they celebrate probes? It's like Zubrin's idea to put the Martian epoch several decades ago so that all the probe dates will be in positive numbers. Who cares? 100 years from now they'll barely register as historical curiosities.

(On the other hand, holidays based on failed probes where you smash into stuff and fall over might be fun.)

Holidays are more likely to be on the solstices and equinoxes and on perihelion and aphelion.

#24 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » govt that can further martian sucess » 2004-01-23 23:35:56

clark

It used to be moral to own slaves. It used to be moral to beat your wife. It used to be moral to lynch the black man. It used to be moral to stop 'lesser' humans from reproducing.

I suspect you mean all that literally. That those who lynched blacks ect. did nothing wrong.

#25 Re: Civilization and Culture » Let's lay out a hypothetical colonization plan - Nuts and bolts » 2004-01-23 21:00:01

Your scenario looks like a fairly typical Mars-settlement scenario, which, frankly, you can read at all kinds of places.

What gets interesting is when you consider the effect space elevators would have on all this.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB