Announcement

Announcement: This forum is accepting new registrations via email. Please see Recruiting Topic for additional information. Write newmarsmember[at_symbol]gmail.com.
  1. Index
  2. » Search
  3. » Posts by Byron

#501 Re: Mars Society International » I WANT - MARS » 2003-08-27 06:16:01

All Australian state budgets are now so dependent upon speeding fines for revenue, it's unthinkable to raise speed limits anywhere because it would reduce state income. More speed cameras are being installed every month in Queensland and next year's budget has already factored in a major increase in speeding fine revenue! They simply can't afford to raise limits, ever ... even if common sense dictated it and even if they wanted to.

So you have the Gestapo in Australia, too  ???

It seems that the "greed disease" has spread its tenacles throughout the governments of the world, who seem hell-bent on squeezing every last penny from the financially-deprived masses.  At least we don't have speed cameras here in Fl...at least not yet...although speed enforcement is becoming more strict than it used to, especially in local districts.  And the fines are going higher...much higher - what used to be a $50 ticket is now starts at $150 and goes up...and Florida is pretty average in this respect.

Granted, out on the open interstates (here in Fl,) the cops will generally let you run 10 mph (actually up to 13 over, according to "inside" sources) over the posted speed limit, which means I can roll at 80 and feel pretty safe (and most people do as well,) but I notice that some other states, like North Carolina, are rather strict, even on the rural stretches of interstate...75 mph is about all you can get away with there.

In my opinion, high speeds are not the primary cause of traffic accidents - bad drivers are.  If this country would simply mandate German-style driver training (the best and safest drivers in the world), we would save 1000's of lives each and every year.  Also, by making it difficult, expensive and time-consuming to get a driver's license, it would help take some of the cars off the road over time, as people choose not to bother, which would help open up the clogged roads for the rest of us "good" drivers...

Itll never happen, of course, but I can't help but to dream on occasion...lol..

B

#502 Re: Not So Free Chat » Apropos of Nothing » 2003-08-26 10:36:01

They really have a Space Camp in Turkey?

B

#503 Re: Not So Free Chat » Apropos of Nothing » 2003-08-26 10:01:37

Why should they side with the islamic fundamentalists?

Why should they side with any of us?

It would be logical to think that any alien race (who would probably be millions of years ahead of us) that did happen to make a pit stop on this planet would view us as a bunch of underdeveloped primates killing each other for...what? 

Perhaps they will be kind to us and leave us alone, except perhaps for something like disabling every single nuclear weapon on Earth simply as an "insurance policy" against the potential destruction of Earth from ourselves.

In any case, I'm with the camp that think we just need to bring our boys home, not just from Iraq, but from everywhere else as well.  Surely it's become obvious by now that our meddling has only made things worse, not better.  As for the oil, gas prices have never been higher, and it's high time for us to start looking / developing other sources of energy...before we get into a real mess...

B

#504 Re: Mars Society International » I WANT - MARS » 2003-08-26 07:32:01

At least you be assured that you're not alone...my parents have said the same thing...at least until they've started reading my book...lol (they still wouldn't dream of going to that 'horrible' place though... yikes  )  If only people could understand....if only, if only....

Anyhow, I've been checking the left-hand column of the M.S. website, it seems the past conferences have been held in: (in order of appearance) Boulder, Boulder, Toronto, Stanford, Boulder, Eugene.   The 3rd European M.S. conference is being held next month in Bremen. 

If anyone in the decision-making body of the M.S. is reading this, here's a proposed list of places that I think would be ideal for future conferences:  Orlando / Cocoa Beach, FL (near NASA / Space Center), In or near Pasadena Calif., (JPL Labs), Boston, Mass. (major locus of universities), Chapel Hill, NC (open-minded setting, adjacent to many universities), Madison, Wisconsin (b/c it's a danged cool town), and of course, Washington, D.C., so the pols will take notice of us, and my sister lives there too, so I don't have to get a hotel...   big_smile  tongue

B

#505 Re: Not So Free Chat » Apropos of Nothing » 2003-08-26 07:17:53

In that case, they'll set off world-wide EMP bursts, and send us pitiful humans back to the Stone Age....

B

#506 Re: Not So Free Chat » Apropos of Nothing » 2003-08-26 06:45:39

If the aliens landed today in the middle of Iraq and said "Hi," what do you think will happen?

B

#507 Re: Mars Society International » I WANT - MARS » 2003-08-26 06:37:14

I guess I was just trying to help get you to the next Mars conference - I haven't forgotten who's supposed to be buying the donuts ...

Actually, you don't have to worry about the doughnuts -or- the coffee, as they provide all of that each morning for all the attendees...   big_smile

It would be cool to get some of us from this board together at a conference...any conference, really...lol  smile

B

#508 Re: Mars Society International » I WANT - MARS » 2003-08-26 06:31:07

That's too bad, Cindy, to hear that you may never make it to a M.S. conference.  Would you be able to go if it was, let's say, a half-day's drive of your location (somewhere in NM, right?)  Does your husband's condition prohibit him going on long trips, or he just doesn't want to be in the same room with other Mars nuts? lol...

As for me, I'll go to the one next year if they choose to have it in the Southeast (which they really need to do, as it's been heavily biased towards the western states ever since the founding conference.)  It'd make great sense to have it in Orlando or near the Space Center (!)...but I'm not getting my hopes up.  Hopefully they'll decide soon, just so we'll know.

The website says it will return to Boulder for 2005...I might end up going back there if I don't go in '04...I have to admit that was a spectacular place to visit... :;):

B

#509 Re: Mars Society International » I WANT - MARS » 2003-08-25 05:42:47

This reminds me...did anyone on this board attend this year's Mars Society Conference in Eugene, Oregon? 

If so, how was it?  Learn anything new, etc?

Let's hope the next M.S. conference will be in my neck of the woods, like Florida...  :;):

B

#510 Re: Not So Free Chat » American Moon Base prediction... - tell me what you think » 2003-08-24 06:35:12

Yes, although it didn't make a big splash on the news, the rocket Brazil was about to launch exploded last Friday, killing over 20 technicians and support personnel.

Truely a sad time for Brazil and their effort to develop a space infrastructure....

B

#511 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Something interesting... - A website I came across. » 2003-08-23 14:35:54

That's only the tip of the ice berg though. The real problem occurs when those children grow up.

All of those who look to the stars and say, "I want to go there. I want to live there." You are making a personal choice for yourself. A life choice. Nothing wrong with that, I applaude you.

The same conditions you so willingly accept though may also be just as quickly rejected by your children. Imagine the situation then, where now you populate an enclosed environment with people who may not really want to be there. Anf for a variety of reasons, they may be trapped there, with no real means to change their environment, ever.

Bingo, clark...you've hit on one of the themes in my novel-in-progress..lol. 

The initial stages of exploring and settling Mars will be centered around science, as well overcoming the tremendous obstacles to living in an alien environment.  There won't be enough people early on to require anything more than informal councils and the like, with "Momma Earth" pretty much running the show (as they're the ones to be paying for these early missions / settlements...lol)

It's much later on down the line, when the Martian population gets into the thousands and tens of thousands, with a generation of Martian-born children coming of age, when some form of Martian self-government will probably come into existence, and the biggest problems, as clark has suggested, will between the "first generation" settlers and their offspring, who will surely have ideas of their own of how to run things  smile   They may be much more socialist in their thinking compared to their libertarian parents, for example.  Or they may chafe at the restrictive ways of their elders (think: don't touch that, don't go here, no going outside without a buddy, etc, etc.)

"War" as we see it today probably won't happen on Mars, simply because of the expense....is expensive as war is here on Earth, it would be astronomically (excuse the pun) more so on Mars.  Instead, you might see economic / trade conflicts between competing settlements (like the two major Martian population centers portrayed in my novel,) or terrorist-style sabotage attacks by the disenfranchised (which would be pretty easy...just punch a hole in the dome, cut off the heat to the crops, that sort of thing.)

For the above reasons, it would behoove future settlers to ensure that everyone enjoys more or less an equal standard of living, based on mutual respect for one another, and individual settlements should have as much self-autonomy as possible, like KSR's diverse spectrum of various settlers in his Mars trio.

But who knows...perhaps the momentous act of settling a whole new world will cause people to cast off their old, primative ways for something better...otherwise, as Cindy mentioned, why even bother going, if we're just going to bring all of our problems with us? 

I guess you could say that Mars will be the ultimate test of "Can we really do better?"

B

#512 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Two Unrelated Questions » 2003-08-23 07:58:14

I was extraordinarily fortunate to attend a particularly good school in England. It was government, not private, but you had to show some degree of academic inclination to get in .. i.e. pass an exam. (Again, more luck than judgment in my case! ) The teachers were all specialists in their subject and the great majority were dedicated teachers. I had enormous respect for all of them and a genuine affection for several. I still think about them from time to time and hope they're OK.

Very interesting, Shaun.  Exactly what kind of "public" school that you had the fortune to attend?  Are there still these types of "merit" schools left in the U.K.?  Here in the U.S. we have "magnet" schools for gifted students, where they take advanced classes, etc, but these schools are usually open to regular students as well. 

The main problem with U.S. schools really has to do with race and poverty, although few people will openly admit it as such. (PC-ness and all of that.)  In many areas of the country, there are schools where African-American students are the majority, while other schools are lily-white.  This is not because of any deliberate attempt to re-segregate the public schools; rather it's because people with means (usu. the white ones, although this includes a lot of immigrants as well) move to areas with "white" schools, while the black families are stuck in poorer areas with predominately "black" schools.  Guess which schools have higher performing students?  For the most part, money is not the issue, as public officials like to make sure all public schools in their respective districts have more or less equal funding (although you have rich and poor school districts, with vast differences in per-pupil spending.)  When it comes down to the brass tacks, however, the differences in our educational system is a cultural one.  Families with a strong work/educational ethic strive very hard to live in neighborhoods with like-minded families, who all go to the same schools, which help promote a "pro-learning" culture; where learning is "cool."  These are the schools that send very high percentages of their students to colleges, have consistently high test scores, etc.

Sadly, when you look at the traditional African-American neighborhoods, many of which are mired in proverty, a huge proportion of students in these schools come from dysfunctional families, often strung-out single mothers (who might have to work 2 jobs just to pay the bills) or worse.  And because you have so many of these kids together in one place, there is a general lack of a "learning ethic," and the students that do show promise are often shuttled off to the "magnet" schools I mentioned earlier, as officials are desperate to keep the "numbers" up in these higher-level schools.  So you have this constant brain-drain out of the "crummy" schools (call your local Realtor to find out what they are in your city), and furthermore, novice and under-performing teachers are often sent to these least-desirable schools, which only makes things even more difficult.

Here in the state of Florida, we have a thing called the "no Child Left Behind Act," which effectively ends "social promotion," with benchmark exams every student must pass to advance to the next grade level.  This coming year, 13% percent of 3rd graders will have to repeat the 3rd grade, and it's plainly evident what schools the vast majority of these students came from.  Now the parents of many of these children claim they're being unfairly treated because of their race, etc.  I guess the point is that state officials still haven't found a way to actually keep children from "being left behind."

I guess that sums up the great educational dilemma in this country - how to implement equal education in a land of "unequal learners" (and teachers) and vast cultural differences.  My own personal educational situation was quite fortunate, I should say, as I went to excellent public schools in a city that operated under a mandated federal integration scheme, which stipulated that every school in the entire county-wide district have the exact racial proportion as the county overall (something like 66% white, 32% black, 2% other.)  This was pretty cool, except many of the black children had to endure long bus rides out to the "country" schools, and vice-versa.  The particular school I went to (b/c of my district) was a magent school, with excellent teachers and curricula, but even here, there was this thing called "in-school segregation," a term that was never spoken, only whispered.  The brighter, college-bound kids were put in higher level classes, while the others were placed in lower level classes.  Except for homeroom and P.E., almost all of my classmates were white, while the lower level classes had huge proportions of African-Americans and poorer whites. 

Weird, huh?  How to rectify this problem?  For one thing, I think you would have to eliminate proverty....as this has proven to be one of the largest impediments to getting a good education, as well as promoting a good learning ethic in traditionally underperforming schools (believe me, the pols are trying hard, but not hard enough, imho.)  Another idea I support is school choice - allowing kids to pick whatever schools they would like to attend, which would help even things out (the problem you would have then is that the "good" schools would be busting at the seams, while the poor ones would be sitting empty...oh well, what can you do?)

O.K., O.K., I'll step off the soapbox for now..lol   big_smile

B

#513 Re: Water on Mars » H20, where'd it go? - What happened to Marsian water? » 2003-08-21 08:39:12

I love your sig, Spider-Man...great logo...

In regards to your statements about Mars suddenly losing most of its atmosphere in a cataclysmic impact, I suppose that could be possible, although big impacts have a tendency to release a lot of volitiles onto the surface, which would increase the atmosphere rather than strip it away.

Personally, I side with the idea of the lack of a planetary magnetic field on Mars, which allowed the solar wind to strip away the atmosphere over time, leaving what little atmosphere we see today.  But the end result is still the same: what was once likely a wet and warm(er) world became what it is today, although there are probably oceans of water ice embedded in the regolith across vast areas of the planet.

But you're undeniably right about one thing:  Yes, we do need to go to Mars soon to find out...

B

#514 Re: Not So Free Chat » Apropos of Nothing » 2003-08-21 08:10:21

P.S.:  I miss Byron and Phobos too; I see Byron here occasionally...haven't seen hide nor hair of Phobos since April or thereabouts.  Come back you guys!  sad

big_smile  I'm back....  Sorry I haven't kept up with the board lately, as I've been busy with my novel. (Getting close now, I'm delighted to say.) I miss you guys too...and it's cool to see some new faces around here too :;):

With Mars now almost right on top of us, those of you with telescopes - what details have you been able to pick out in recent days?  I have a old, beat-up Astroscan (the funny bulb-looking thing) and I was able to discern Syrtis Major the night before last (or maybe I was just imagining it...lol).  Can any of you pick out the southern ice cap?  I'm going to a public viewing at the local observatory on the 27th, so hopefully I'll be able to catch a glimpse of Mars through a "real" telescope.  If I do, I'll report back to let you know what I was able see.

For me, it's pretty dang cool to see Mars glowing bright in the night sky as I draw closer to completing my SF novel set on Mars. Pretty amazing coincidence, as I had no idea that I'd actually be writing a novel until fairly recently.

It's been a pretty intense experience lately - but it's nice to come back to Earth to check out the view every now and then... big_smile

Cindy, Shaun, et al - I'll probably be around on here a lot more once my ms. has been boxed up and mailed to certain addresses in NYC...  tongue   

B

#515 Re: Mars Society International » I WANT - MARS » 2003-05-13 11:39:27

Build yourself a rocket that will take you there  big_smile  tongue  :laugh:  tongue

B

#516 Re: Not So Free Chat » slavery - why does it still exist? » 2003-04-09 11:26:24

The fact is, wealth -does- create more wealth.

Cindy, I agree with this statement in its entirity.  That's why it's imperative that we distribute the national wealth of this country throughout the population, instead of concentrating it among a few super-rich.  It is the middle class that has brought this country to where it is today....and this middle class was created due to the progressive policies spawned during the Great Depression, a time when the government was forced to tax the rich in order to get the country back on its feet again. 

If we allow the rich class to have their way...i.e., pay an ever-decreasing share of taxes, allow them to pay workers sub-par wages, etc, then we will be going the way of countries such as Mexico and Brazil, where you have a few super-rich, and most of the rest being quite poor.  Any respectable economist will tell you the best way to generate economic growth is to put as much money in the hands as many people as possible.  Rich people simply cannot spend enough of their wealth to make any appreciable difference in the economy, as there is only so much to what people can buy and do with their money...once you reach a certain point of personal wealth, you basically hit a wall as far as personal consumption goes.  Sure, you can invest that money, but who is the most likely recipient of that money?  Other wealthy people, most likely.

Anyway - on to the question at hand - in my opinion an economy is strong when feedback loops are created which allow flows of wealth through commerce and (in my opinion) the middle classes are the most productive sources to balance consumer spending and capital investment. In the late 1940s, the GI Bill and government backed 30 year mortgage programs fueled the creation of a massive middle class.

Bill, you couldn't have said this better...thank you...

B

#517 Re: Civilization and Culture » Violence - Case studies. » 2003-04-09 09:43:17

We have a responsibility to help and care for every human being born into this world. Yet we have very few limits, as a society, on an individuals right to bring people into this world.

This has been a universal "right" since the beginning of human history.  The one-child rule in China notwithstanding, the idea of child limits is gonna be a mighty tough sell in your typical democratic society.  Probably the best approach to this is to educate our young that having childen is a burden upon the rest of society, and there are tremendous advantages to having just one child, etc.  Also, I think our tax structure could perhaps be restructured to give a big tax break for having one child, a much smaller one for child No. 2, and a regressive tax structure for child No. 3 and above.  These two things could very well do the trick of getting our population down over the long haul.

I will be the first to say that the punishment really dosen't fit the crime, but that's based on my world view, and I don't live in Singapore. You talk about universal rights and such, how exactyl can we have such a thing without trampling on indiviudal groups who may wish to do things differently?

Is a homogenous system of rights and rules really in our best interest? Wouldn't this decrease diversity and/or new ways of thinking/doing things?

I think this sort of thing has to be looked at a per-nation basis.  We decide what's best for us in the US, Singapore decides what's best for them, and we all try and get along the best we can...   big_smile

As for the incest thing, I think it's wrong because of health reasons...a child born of incest has a very high potential to be a burden upon the rest of society.  Granted, siblings can use birth control and the like, but still...

I can agree, yet the problem I see is you rely on a democratic system to establish what is acceptable and unacceptable, and the punishment associated with it. So the majority decides what is acceptable, and what the punishments are- dosen't this open up a door for the minority to be at the mercy of any populous movement?

That's one of the risks of living in a democratic society.  I mean, if the majority of people wanted to, they could take away the wealth of every millionaire in the country.  (all you rich people...you'd better be watching over your shoulder!  big_smile )  I just hope that we have enough common sense as a society not to infringe upon the rights of the majority.  That's why the Bill of Rights is such a scared document in our society...

Would like to talk more, but I gotta run for now....

B

#518 Re: Not So Free Chat » slavery - why does it still exist? » 2003-04-09 08:57:11

Shaun: Every "self-made" rich person I ever met was penny-pinching, low-tipping, stingy and avaricious ... which of course over the years leads to becoming rich.... Inventors are always poor, no matter how much their income. Herman's scheme stinks! Otherwise, we'd be on Mars by now, mate.

Thank you, thank you so much.  I've also never met a rich person who is truly happy either..they're too busy worrying about to make more money! 

There's way more poor and middle class people then the rich.  I say it's time that WE start running the show...  big_smile  tongue

B

#519 Re: Not So Free Chat » slavery - why does it still exist? » 2003-04-09 08:53:51

Sorry, Shaun, I have to firmly disagree with you on that one... ???

A world filled with a few trillionaires would definately NOT be a better place.  For one thing, the hyper-rich would have so much money that they would be able to seize whatever power they wanted...a single trillionaire in a nation such as Australia would essentialy be able to put the national government in his or her pocket, which would lead to...what, slavery, maybe?  No way, Jose...  ???

I think it's time to start going in the other direction, especially here in this great United States.  We need to figure out a way to raise the standard of living for the lower and middle classes, and allowing a handful of folks to become hyper-wealthy is NOT the way to go about this.  We need to go back to a more progressive tax structure that would effectively limit super-high levels of income (let's say, over $10 million a year.)  The minimum wage needs to be increased to a level so that working people don't need food stamps and other government assistance, and the labor laws need to be restructered so that the workers have the upper hand, not the employers.

The United States is a democratic society, which means everyone deserves to share in the resources of this country, as well has having equal opportunity to better one's self.  Having a feudal-type society in which you have a few Bill Gates squared is NOT democratic at all....all these people would do is to subjugate everyone else to fulfill their limitless need for greed. 

Anyone who thinks greed is an admirable trait is off their rocker, IMO, and for society to progress forward in the future, we'd better find a way to make greed a less integeral part of our society.  The Mr. Herman dude is WAYYY off base, and I'm glad there's not too many people like him, otherwise, the Earth would just be better off going into an ice age or something...

#520 Re: Civilization and Culture » Violence - Case studies. » 2003-04-09 08:16:20

What behaviour leads to more people than jobs available?

Good question....the person that is able to figure this one out deserves a Nobel Prize, imo... big_smile

You are juding people on a set of exhibited behaviour patterns. Who decides what is and isn't acceptable? How is it decided? How is it changed? How long before simple infractions, like jay walking, are considered to be cause for treatment?

You've got a point there...one only has to look at such things as the harsh sentencing guidelines for things such as mere possession of small amounts of marijuana.  In any democratic society, it is the responsibility of the populace (which means apathy is most certainly NOT a good thing) to determine what laws are just and which ones are not...and adjust them accordingly.  The jaywalker deserves nothing more than a ticket, if even that.  People who kill in cold blood need to be put away, preferably for life.  There should also be some sort of national, universal standard of justice and a clear defination of what is acceptable behavior and what is not (i.e. consensual sex between two adults is O.K., but forced sex or incest is not.)

Humanity IS capable of a moderate approach. However, it is far from certain wether or not we engage in a moderate approach, with anything. The history of Man is written in his blood.

Glad you think that humanity is capable of a moderate, rational approach, because we live in an era in which we really can extinct ourselves without too much difficulty.  That's why I think it's imperative that we indentify the next Hilter or Stalin before they assume a position of power - and do something about them. (Don't ask me how, but it needs to be done nonetheless.) The world was almost destroyed in WWII.  We probably won't be so lucky next time. 

In short, I think it's more imperative than ever that we, as a race, figure out a way to mitigate those who are predisposed to carry out acts of violence against others, and to do it in a democratic, fair manner.  For example, imagine if the doctor in the story that Cindy mentioned earlier was a top-level researcher in a Class IV bio-lab.  Imagine the harm she would be capable of in a stituation like that...

What do you feel is an appropriate punishment for the individuals involved with this crime?

If it can be proved that the actions of these hoodlums really did result in the death of that man, then they should be charged - and punished for murder (following whatever sentencing guidelines currently in place).

B

#521 Re: Civilization and Culture » Violence - Case studies. » 2003-04-08 14:31:30

Excellent start, now, let me give you the next monket wrench to contend with: You increase the potential for opportunity for all individuals. Now, everyone has all these choices becuase they have received an excellent education. One, the value of that education decreases as each person learns what you have learned. CAse in point: the economic value of a high school diploma is low. Most people have it, so you're nothing special. Opprtunity hasn't changed much in this regard- in terms of competing against one another.

The real problem though is having all of these highly educated people with little or no real opportunity to USE these skills.

Case in point, the Middle East. What do we see? A large portion of the population receiving a great deal of education, but with little opportunity to employ this education. This leads to disenfranchisement, social instability, and crime. Urban cities have a notorious reputation for disenfranchisement becuase the children are told "graduate, and then you can get a job, and start your life." Kids graduate and find out that this isn't true.

Guess we need to figure out a way to create more jobs than there are people, i.e., create a labor shortage.  The problem today is that there are more people than there are jobs, which limits opportunity for everyone.  If a way could be found to perpetuate a permanent labor shortage, than the workers of the world would be able to call the shots, opportunities would be legion, wages would soar.  If only this was true....  Anyone up for a Nobel Prize?    big_smile

Quote 
Socially maladjusted people have no place in the schools, or anywhere else for that matter....if giving them drugs is the only way to cure people of this problem (after other reasonable measures have been tried), so be it...if we have the tools to solve this sort of thing, we need to use them.


They said the same thing about the Jews right before they gassed them.

Unfair, unfair, unfair....I am judging people by their behavior, not who they are.  A reformed bully has the same rights as everyone else...but people who commit acts of aggression against others have no rights, so long as they continue that kind of behavior.  I, myself, have the right to live in a society that is free from people that are a threat to me, from schoolyard bullies to the cold-blooded killer.  We, as a society, are obligated to ensure that these types of people do not infringe upon our rights...and if it means taking away their rights as sovereign individuals, so be it.  Isn't that what jailing criminals is all about?  If you've been following the news lately, laws are being passed all over the country that specifically target schoolyard bullies....which is about time, imo.  You gotta go after these people in their formative stages, not after they've grown up and become full-fledged criminals.

You and I can be sensible (hey, it is possible for me) and take a moderate approach. That's how it starts though.

If you're thinking that that humanity is incapable of taking the moderate approach, I think you're mistaken.  If this was true, we as humans would have been extinct a long time ago.  Collectively deciding what is right and what is not is what civilization is all about, and if we're not capable of doing that, well, I guess we're doomed.  What a bummer...

In all seriousness, however, as long as people are able to speak out freely (The Emperer has no clothes!), as long as enough people practice common sense and intelligence, as long as most people take the high road in terms of interacting with others, I think we'll be alright as a society.  After all, we've gotten this far, haven't we?  (pitfalls along the way notwithstanding) ....

#522 Re: Civilization and Culture » Violence - Case studies. » 2003-04-08 13:06:07

However, the situation you describe is a comprehensive approach to improving the person's disposition and situation. The drug itself should not be approached as the cure-all.

O.K., I can agree with you there...I would hope that the medical community would adhere to this premise as well.  As long as people are taking these type of drugs under the supervision of a physician who has a stake in the patient's well-being, this should greatly limit the potential abuse by the user...the same thing would apply to weight-control drugs...no sane doctor would prescribe a powerful metabolism booster to someone who only has 1% body fat...at least I hope not!  Like everything else in life, we have to be reasonable about these things....

Yet a majority of people would benefit from having more opportunity. If you have positive options from which to choose, your outlook tends to improve.

Boy, I certainly agree with you on that one.  I have some great solutions for ya too....take the 10 ten secondary schools in the country, analyse them as far as the level of education, money spent per pupil, the quality of the teachers goes,...and then immediately implement a program to ensure that every single public school in the country matches the quality of the "top 10"...money being no object whatsoever.  That will give us a good start right there.  The next thing we need to do is to overhaul our labor laws so that they greatly favor employees, rather than the employers...this means a high minimum wage, mandated training opportunities, a min of a month's vacation, strict enforcement to ensure ideal workplace environments, and so on and so forth...  Lastly, to ensure that everyone truly has the same opportunity as everyone else, place a maximum limit on personal and corporate wealth, so that everyone pretty much enjoys the same standard of living as everyone else.  Perhaps then, we would see the end of many of the social problems we experience today.  What's that, again?...you're calling this socialism??  Oh, shucks, I thought I was doing good here...lol...

Perhaps an environment that encourages a less sedantry lifestyle and discourages fast food is a more robust and healthier solution.

Another excellent point, clark, couldn't agree with you more.  If we truly care about the health of our children, then we need to pack the halls of every school board in the country to remove soda machines in the schools and fast food outlets in the school cafeteria, as well as making sure that every student gets a minimum of one half hour of actual physical activity a day.  As they say, good habits developed as a child often last a lifetime...

But when it comes to the school bully, all of us really need to draw the line in the sand...as these are the people that turn out to be the true baddies in our society (as well as making life difficult for the rest of us).  Socially maladjusted people have no place in the schools, or anywhere else for that matter....if giving them drugs is the only way to cure people of this problem (after other reasonable measures have been tried), so be it...if we have the tools to solve this sort of thing, we need to use them.

As for the part of removing parts of the brain...that's a LONG ways from merely giving various forms of medicine...we, as a society, really should know where to draw the line with this sort of thing...if we don't, then we've got some major problems...

Cindy, interesting post about the mentally ill...I'd have to admit I didn't think too much about those who have an illness but think nothing's wrong with them.  From this standpoint, the problem lies with the people that are close to the ones that are suffering mental illness....surely they know that something's up, after all, these conditions don't develop overnight...my thing is, why don't they seek help??  This Debra Green was obviously crazy as a loon, and yet her husband just let it ride, as if it was no big deal?  <shakes head>  Dr. Green really should've had his head examined too...that's all I can say.... ???   We, as a society, need to do way, way more to help those that really need help...

B

#523 Re: Not So Free Chat » slavery - why does it still exist? » 2003-04-08 09:04:31

I can see the headlines now:  Robots Stage Revolt - Demand Same Working Conditions As Humans

tongue

B

#524 Re: Civilization and Culture » Violence - Case studies. » 2003-04-08 08:30:38

A persons persepctive. Their reality- the environment that contributes towards their depression, all of that is ignored. A little pill suddenly makes your lot in life much easier to bare. Is the person helped in this situation? If they have little options to improve their life, if it is difficult to improve their environment, then the pill is a perfect solution. It makes what you are stuck with tolerable. However, what if it were within this persons power to improve their environment? Say change a job, or move to some place sunny? This option might be overlooked becuase the 'simple" fix precludes it.

Well, I've known people that have done everything possible to change their enviroment, such as moving to another location, getting another job, etc...and guess what...no matter where you go, there you are...  What I HAVE seen, when they have undertaken treatment for their condition, their lives have improved by 100%.  Now they can enjoy what they do, enjoy each day as it comes, and not have to be running here and there in a desperate attempt to flee the demons that reside inside their brain.  Their lives are *better* now with their treatment...is that so wrong? 

Besides, most people really don't have the option of changing their enviroment...new jobs are hard to come by, uprooting one's family to move to Florida is really not an option for the majority of folks (believe me...there are way too many people down here already!!), and one-on-one counseling is out of financial reach for many people.

The Romans had their vomatorium's, why shouldn't we have an updated equivilant?

Haven't we practically reached this point already?  Ever heard of bulimia and other eating disorders?   People who are overweight and have tried everything possible to lose weight clearly deserve a method to prevent them from over-eating, as well as a way to artificially increase their too-low metabolism.  What's so bad about having a drug that makes one feel full after eating a lean, healthy meal?  Perhaps then we wouldn't see so many people scarfing down one Big Mac after another.

You name dependancies. Why accept another one?

Face it, we humans are the most dependent animals on this planet. If it wasn't for modern technology, the vast majority of us wouldn't even be around.  I, for one, would have been long dead had I been born in the 19th Century, rather than the 20th (asthma).  Just look at the case of Steven Hawking...an example of man wedded to technology if there ever was one...but because he was fortunate to live in THIS age, it has been possible for him not only to live, but to become one of the greatest thinkers of all time. 

Like it or not, we will *always* be dependent on our own technology...especially if we go to Mars...lol..  :;):

As for self-control...yes, that is one of the most admirable traits...and also one of the most elusive.  A great number of criminal acts are committed precisely due to this lack of self-control.  With drugs that would give those who lack this important social quality the self-control most of us have, I think the people that have been raped, or have lost loved ones to homicide, would give a huge "thanks" for this technology.

B

#525 Re: Civilization and Culture » Violence - Case studies. » 2003-04-08 07:57:45

B
*Well, here's my best answer:  Back home, a guy named Aaron and his family attended my parents' church; Aaron is a year older than me.  He was always in trouble, but then his home life was a bit odd (mother had mental and emotional problems, older sister was diagnosed with schizophrenia in her early 20s).  Aaron was habitually into trouble in his preteen and teenage years.  Unlike his 3 siblings, he was in and out of trouble, shuttled through foster homes, went to a detention school at least once, and continued to hang around with other troubled boys.  The last crime I knew of he and his friends committing was breaking and entering an art studio and supply shop in my hometown.  Aaron and his friends were given one last warning:  Next time, it's prison.  They were taken on a "tour" of a prison there in Iowa, inmates spoke to them to try and wise them up.  Aaron said what had scared him was the straightforward sexual "come-ons" of some of the inmates.  Regardless, Aaron did change his ways -- abruptly and, nearing 39 years old, apparently permanently.  He's been married for over a decade, has a daughter, and works (ironically?) as a prison guard.  I last saw him roughly 13 years ago; he was a totally different person.  He's got his act together, is responsible, etc.  This is the guy who everyone was certain (including yours truly) would likely spend time in prison -- and probably a lot of it.  But nope...he turned over a new leaf, has been "on the straight and narrow" for years and years now.

I'm not overly fond of the notion of messing around in peoples' brains -- literally.  It's an ethical morass, a huge can of worms...with much potential for abuse. 

--Cindy

Yes, that's a good story...but I'm afraid that's the exception, rather than the rule for this kind of situation.

How about this story?:  A woman had 3 children, 2 of whom turned out to be "good," while one grew up a thief and drug addict who could not control his impulses, not matter how much therapy they went through and geniune effort to impose self-control upon his own behavior.  He went to jail as well, for stealing a car.  He got out with a burning desire never to commit a criminal act again.  Well, that was fine and dandy, but that still didn't solve his problem of doing illegal drugs and drinking excessive amounts of alcohol, as well as getting into fights in bars and the like.  Now he is dead because of this (driving while impaired while attemting to flee people he had been in a fight with).  Get it...the guy's DEAD because of his inablity to control his own behavior; someone who was really a "good" person inside.  If there had been drugs that could have controlled this sort of thing, he would most likely be alive today, married with children and enjoying life like most of us. 

Like anything else, if something is broken, and a means is made available to fix it, I think it's wrong to deny that...after all, everyone deserves a chance to live a "normal" life, right? 

B

  1. Index
  2. » Search
  3. » Posts by Byron

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB