Debug: Database connection successful
You are not logged in.
The shielding problem can be mitigated (partially) by distance. Unshielded dose follows the inverse square law. The USS Discovery in 2001: A Space Odyssey captured that quite accurately. The propulsion section was seperated from the habitation section by a long pylon. Waste heat radiators are a more difficult problem. One way of making them smaller is to dump heat at higher temperatures. The heat flux from a radiator scales with the fourth power of temperature. But that causes problems as well if the heat produced by a reactor is needed to run some sort of heat engine. Dumping heat at higher temperature then negatively impacts efficiency.
I cannot really comment on your 10B-P fusion engine design.
"Plan and prepare for every possibility, and you will never act. It is nobler to have courage as we stumble into half the things we fear than to analyse every possible obstacle and begin nothing. Great things are achieved by embracing great dangers."
Offline
Like button can go here
I might be intruding in ignorance, not sure why radiators are needed, if it is nuclear thermal. Yes you do need if Nuclear-Electric>Plasma.
The Pylon idea is interesting. What about thethers?
If you had a slow spinning spider web of Carbon-Unicorn materials, then you could put nuclear, cargo, and habitation structure at a distance very favorable to radiation protection.
If Nuclear Thermal, then you have to bring Hydrogen with you to Mars in order to get your ride back to Earth. Or you have to use Starships to bring Hydrogen off of Mars.
I am wondering about Nuclear>Thermal>Other Fluids.
What about Nuclear>Thermal>Water? I recall that that is about as good as chemical. But water is able to help shield from radiation, and is relatively passive in containers, not having so much problem from boil-off.
And water might be brought up from Mars. You could clean the ice water and bring it up with a Starship.
So, you only have to cook up Methane and Oxygen to run the Starship which is a water tanker. You also have to melt and clean the Mars ice water, but as I have said, water in tanks may help to protect from radiation of a nuclear reactor.

So, you might have water cooled Nuclear>Thermal>Water reactors
The rotation rate for the web to keep it inflated could be rather small, so the tensile force the web has to deal with would be miniimized.
So, with that as well, you might have some residual water after the initial thrusting event(s). So that may serve as radiation protection as well.
At first perhaps water would be lifted to Earth-LEO and Mars-Low Orbit, but later on when things are better developed perhaps Oxygen for Water may come from our Moon or Phobos or Deimos. In that case Hydrogen would have to be lifted from Earth or Mars and converted to be part of water as soon as possible.
What do you think?
Ending
Last edited by Void (2026-11-11 13:50:52)
Be careful what you wish for.
Offline
Like button can go here
I would like to add to the previous post.
If a web structure was used: 
I suggest a two stage nuclear propulsion system.
1) Booster as Nuclear>Thermal>Hydrogen
2) Interplanetary Stage as Nuclear>Thermal>Water.
So, you could use Hydrogen to do the push Earth Orbit>Interplanetary Space then you would detach the #1) Nuclear>Therma>Hydrogen booster and discard it or retrieve it in any practical way available.
The 2) Nuclear>Thermal>Water 2nd stage with a web structure would then navigate to Mars orbit using additional water propulsion.
Then at Mars, Starships would refill it with water, and it would return to Earth/Moon without a Hydrogen booster.
This gives the wonderful thrust of #1 without the need for prolonged boiloff protection on route to Mars and back.
But you do then have a easy propellant that you can extract from Mars to bring to Mars orbit.
On the return trip the exit from the Mars gravity well may require less thrust, and you may not be carrying as much cargo as you might have to move from Earth to Mars. So, the lower performance may not matter.
To deliver crew back to Earth perhaps you could use an Aerobraking capsule. The Nuclear Water web might fly by Earth and drop the crewed capsule to do the aero burn, and then go into a solar orbit or perhaps it would go into a very high elliptical orbit of the Earth and be serviced and refilled.
If this could be done then Starship's role would be to bring cargo and water and Hydrogen up from Earth. At Mars, it would only bring water and perhaps just a little cargo as rock samples to return to Earth.
The amount of Metha-Lox that would be required at Mars might be significantly reduced.
Ending
Last edited by Void (2026-11-13 10:39:12)
Be careful what you wish for.
Offline
Like button can go here
I feel a bit like an intruder in this section, but I do have material from (th) to respond to: https://newmars.com/forums/viewtopic.ph … 69#p242769
Yes, I agree with your materials (th).
From post #28, quote:
I would like to add to the previous post.
If a web structure was used:I suggest a two stage nuclear propulsion system.
1) Booster as Nuclear>Thermal>Hydrogen
2) Interplanetary Stage as Nuclear>Thermal>Water.So, you could use Hydrogen to do the push Earth Orbit>Interplanetary Space then you would detach the #1) Nuclear>Therma>Hydrogen booster and discard it or retrieve it in any practical way available.
I used a convenient polygon to suggest a web similar to a spider's web. Certainly, other geometries may be possible or preferable.
You might use the version where the nuclear reactors were at the extremities, as suggested by the drawing version on the right.
Some of those could be Nuclear>Thermal>Water, and some could be Nuclear>Electric>Plasma.
The web, being of Carbon-Whatever-high-tensile-strength, can be inflated by spin, but it does not have to be severely powerful. Small amounts may be sufficient. Of course, you need enough spin so that when your Nuclear>Therma>Water devices are thrusting hard, the web will be able to tolerate the bending of the web from acceleration forces.
If ew modify this, Quote:
1) Booster as Nuclear>Thermal>Hydrogen
2) Interplanetary Stage as Nuclear>Thermal>Water.
We might add 3) Nuclear>Electric>Plasma
#1 would not travel with the web, except to give it an initial boost.
#2 and #3 could travel with the web, and be refuellable/refillable at a destination.
At rustic undeveloped destinations, #1 would not exist at first and so #2 and #3 could be used for return trips.
But when a location for Mars, or Ceres or further out places might be developed then #1 could be installed and maintained.
Having #3 also provides life support electricity on the trip.
The web being centrifugally inflated, may allow for distance from reactors to protect humans and other things from produced radiation.
The web will need redundancy and repair provisions in case in impactor might sever a portion of it.
Water also may be of benefit to some degree even after the main thrusting events.
I do not favor the use of aerobraking to arrive at Mars. It could be done, with each piece, perhaps gathering in the web structure to a protection, but I favor ballistic capture when possible.
The trip may take longer, but then again with several booster methods perhaps it will not.
In the case of the drawing on the right, the habitation sections may be surrounded by cargo and extra water tanks, so lots of radiation protection.
Perhaps only a small amount of artificial gravity will be utilized for the habitation sections if the trip times can be relatively short.
Ending
Last edited by Void (2026-11-13 10:53:59)
Be careful what you wish for.
Offline
Like button can go here
As supplemental to the just previous post, ideally, it could incorporate Starships.
Those could be as much as possible filled entirely with water, both Cargo and Propellant tanks. The particular type of Starship might be tuned for Mars operations.
The Starships would sequentially be drained of water to satisfy the need for Nuclear>Thermal>Water propulsion.
The propellant tanks entirely drained of water and the cargo section mostly or entirely drained of water, then during the transit between planets, the walls of the tanks can be purged of any entrained water. (It is hoped).
For the Cargo section that is not necessary.
Of course the thrust mechanisms such as engines have to be protected from water entirly.
After the Starships have been emptied of water, then they can be brought to the Crew/Habitation section and used as additional habitation space. At least the crew section could. Maybe the tanks could also be used for such but then a very good cleaning process is needed in order to put the ships into transit operations from Low Orbit to Surface and back again.
In this scheme Starships would transit interplanetary space as tankage and cargo of the Nuclear propulsed web collection.
The Starships put into service for Mars would never need a top-level heat shield that they would need to airbrake from interplanetary space.
But they would be expected to make many transits from the surface of Mars carrying water to refill the Web Ship and themselves even.
Probably less humans will transit back to Earth than to Mars so less Starships filled with water will be needed for the return trip.
Probably at least 10 times as much cargo will go to Mars as might come back from Mars. Maybe actually 100 to 1 I am guessing.
Radiation exposure may be more on the return trip than the outbound trip as cargo can be used as radiation shielding, and extra Starships could be shielding as well.
This system might be able to refill and Mars and go to Ceres perhaps and refill there and come back.
While we might say that Nuclear>Thermal>Water is not nearly as much thrust as Nuclear>Thermal>Hydrogen, it is better than chemical perhaps as if you have a lot of water your energy supply does not fade very fast. If you have Starships filled with water, then you can have a whole lot of water.
Ending
.
Last edited by Void (2026-11-13 14:31:40)
Be careful what you wish for.
Offline
Like button can go here
The query: "Nuclear Thermal Rocket that uses Water as Propellant?"
https://www.bing.com/search?q=Nuclear+T … pc=EDGEXST
Some interesting stuff:
From Dr. Zubrin:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_salt-water_rocket
Quote:
The nuclear salt-water rocket (NSWR) is a theoretical type of nuclear thermal rocket designed by Robert Zubrin.
This one is also very interesting:
https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2014/08/a … -that.html
Quote:
Aquarius a nuclear thermal rocket that uses water heated to over 3000 degrees celsius to solve many human interplanetary transportation issues
August 31, 2014 by Brian Wang
Quote:
Advancing in-space nuclear thermal propulsion (NTP) technology to the point where fission reactor core temperatures exceeding 3000° C can be achieved during major translational maneuvers (burns). Under these conditions, water molecules pumped into the core will disassociate into hydrogen and oxygen atoms, and specific impulse ISP near 1000 s could be achieved. This level of efficiency, twice that attainable with chemical propulsion, dramatically reduces total mass for an interplanetary transport of specified payload mass.
So, twice the efficiency of chemical propulsion, is much more than I expected.
Now if you had a Starship almost entirely filled with water, not only would you have the water in the propellant tanks, but also the cargo section mostly filled with water. If a nuclear propulsion device were associated with it, then an ISP almost 1000 x.
I am presuming that the propellant tanks can be emptied soon enough that for the duration of the flight to Mars, the traces of water can be purged from the propellant tanks to make it ready for service as a shuttle for Mars.
As for the cargo section, once the water is used, it can be converted to other uses such as human habitation. The gear to put inside the cargo compartment would have been stored outside of the ship and then brough in after the water is used up in the cargo compartment.
So, at the start of the mission from Earth the crew/passengers may be in cramped conditions but soon after the main thrusting, habitat space could be expanded.
In flight, the ship can be made ready to use by hooking up and testing engines and associated hardware.
In this situation it might be presumed that a robotic expedition had set up a water process on Mars including a minimum amount of Methane and Oxygen production.
The Starships might bring things up to orbit like water, Ammonia, and CO2. This would be to refill for the return trip and I hope to start establishing orbital structures in part from the moons of Mars.
Ending
Last edited by Void (2026-11-14 08:11:01)
Be careful what you wish for.
Offline
Like button can go here
Adding on to the last post: 
1-8 are presumed to be "Starships".
4 & 5 have been emptied of water and have been migrated to provide more habitation space.
The web is presumed to rotate a little bit to keep it inflated.
I don't think the nuclear engines have to be that large. For leaving the Earth to LEO of course your thrust is in minutes, but these might thrust for hours or days.
Radiation from the reactors is handled by having water in between and also the cargo sections. In addition using tethers allows the reactors be at a distance to also reduce the radiation threat.
Additional reactors that generate electricity might also be included as well as Nuclear>Electric>Plasma drives.
Having Nuclear>Thermal>Hydrogen boosters might be nice to give an initial push from the Earth/Moon towards Mars perhaps.
Ending
Last edited by Void (2026-11-14 09:51:37)
Be careful what you wish for.
Offline
Like button can go here
In response to (th): https://newmars.com/forums/viewtopic.ph … 09#p242809
Quote:
A nuclear thermal rocket appears a lot safer, although it is certainly dangerous.
I sure hope someone solves the fusion problem. Fission appears to be a technology that will never be free of significant risk.
(th)
I am very eager to see fusion emerge. But these machines are very complex. And it is not certain that they can heat water to plasma in bulk.
A Nuclear>Thermal>Water device is relatively simple, (But not easy peasy).
I was very surprised about the performance that "Aquarius" is supposed to produce.
I thought it was 1 to 1 as compared to chemical propulsion, but it is almost 2 to 1!
https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2014/08/a … -that.html
Quote:
Aquarius a nuclear thermal rocket that uses water heated to over 3000 degrees celsius to solve many human interplanetary transportation issues
August 31, 2014 by Brian Wang
Quote:
Advancing in-space nuclear thermal propulsion (NTP) technology to the point where fission reactor core temperatures exceeding 3000° C can be achieved during major translational maneuvers (burns). Under these conditions, water molecules pumped into the core will disassociate into hydrogen and oxygen atoms, and specific impulse ISP near 1000 s could be achieved. This level of efficiency, twice that attainable with chemical propulsion, dramatically reduces total mass for an interplanetary transport of specified payload mass.
From Mars to the Kuiper Belt water is available on most worlds. Exceptions are the Gas and Ice Giants which have ice moons anyway, and Io which has three sibling moons that have ice.
Too far out and ice might be smothered by other substances, but even Pluto has ice mountains and icy Charon.
Fusion and Fission look good for Titan which is important. Fusion may be more important for power on the surface and in the atmosphere of Titan. Fission may be better for transportation.
I am hoping that the dunes of Titan are in part Comet dust.
Query: "Titans dunes are comet dust?"
Quote:
Copilot Search Branding
Like
Dislike
Are Titan’s Dunes Made of Comet Dust?
Recent research suggests Titan’s dunes may indeed be made from material delivered by comets, but this is still a proposed theory — not a confirmed fact.The new comet theory
Scientists from the University of Colorado and other researchers have suggested that Titan’s massive dune fields could be composed of micrometeoroid and comet debris that struck the moon billions of years ago
astrobrief.com
astrobrief.com
+1
. Comets are mixtures of silicate dust, frozen water, and organic compounds, and when they collide with a planet or moon, they can break apart into fine particles.According to this model, early Solar System dynamics — such as gravitational perturbations from the giant planets — could have destabilized the Kuiper Belt, sending comets and small moonlets into collisions with Titan
Smithsonian Magazine
Smithsonian Magazine
. These impacts would have ground the material into sand‑sized grains, which Titan’s winds then transported and shaped into dunes.How this differs from older ideas
For decades, the prevailing view was that Titan’s dunes were locally produced:Ice grains eroded by methane rain from water‑ice bedrock
astrobrief.com
astrobrief.com
+1Tholins (complex organic molecules) formed in Titan’s atmosphere and condensed into particles
astrobrief.com
astrobrief.comAtmospheric dust falling from the moon’s haze and piling up on the surface
Smithsonian Magazine
Smithsonian MagazineThese processes could explain the dunes’ composition, but they don’t account for the scale and uniformity of the dune fields as well as the comet‑impact model might.
Evidence and challenges
The comet theory is supported by simulations showing that early collisions could have produced enough fine debris to cover Titan’s dune fields
Smithsonian Magazine
Smithsonian Magazine
. However, there is no direct observational proof yet — Cassini’s radar and Huygens lander data show the dunes’ size, shape, and composition, but not their origin.Future missions or improved modeling could test this by:
Measuring the chemical makeup of dune particles
Studying isotopic ratios that might trace cometary sources
Modeling collision rates in Titan’s early history
In short: Titan’s dunes are not confirmed to be comet dust, but a new hypothesis proposes that cometary impacts in the early Solar System could have supplied the material. This is an exciting open question in planetary science, with more evidence likely to come from upcoming research
https://www.universetoday.com/articles/ … comet-dust
Of course, after the emergence of that idea dogma kicked in and you only hear that they are made of Tholen's or ice.
This happens when shallow thinkers who only understand things at a shallow verbal level insist on old text as the only source of truth.
It is likely that Titan has at least received cosmic dust.
Query: "How much cosmic dust does Earth receive each year?"
Quote:
Copilot Search Branding
Like
Dislike
Annual Cosmic Dust Influx to Earth
Earth receives roughly 40,000 metric tons of cosmic dust each year, but only about 5,200 tons of it actually reaches the surface as micrometeorites
Astronomy Magazine
Astronomy Magazine
+2
.Two key estimates
Total entering Earth’s atmosphere
Space agencies and astronomers estimate that ~40,000 metric tons of interplanetary dust and meteoroids enter Earth’s atmosphere annually
Astronomy Magazine
Astronomy Magazine
+1
. This includes particles that burn up, remain suspended, or settle as micrometeorites. Most of this material is microscopic and invisible to the naked eye.Material reaching the ground
A 2021 international study, based on 20 years of micrometeorite collections at Antarctica’s Dome C, found that about 5,200 tons of micrometeorites (12–700µm particles) land on Earth each year
동아사이언스
동아사이언스
+2
. This is the portion that survives atmospheric entry without vaporizing.Sources of cosmic dust
Comets: ~80% of the micrometeorite flux, shedding dust and ice as they approach the Sun
동아사이언스
동아사이언스
.Asteroids: Collisions in the asteroid belt and other bodies produce fragments that drift into the inner solar system
Astronomy Magazine
Astronomy Magazine
+1
.Context
Daily rate: ~100 metric tons/day entering the atmosphere
Astronomy Magazine
Astronomy Magazine
+1
.Surface impact: Spread evenly, this is a negligible fraction of Earth’s mass, so it has no measurable effect on gravity
Astronomy Magazine
Astronomy Magazine
.Micrometeorites: These tiny particles are the main source of extraterrestrial material on Earth, far exceeding the mass from larger meteorites (less than 10t/year)
동아사이언스
동아사이언스
.In short: Earth is bombarded by tens of thousands of tons of cosmic dust each year, but only a few thousand tons of it actually lands on the ground as micrometeorites.
So, if Titan has similar, and if the crust has been stable then 4.5 billion years of cosmic dust, and comet dust, and also perhaps salts.
Cryovolcanic actions may have flowed salty water onto the surface where it will have frozen.
So, the crust of Titan may have useful minerals available to build Fusion and Fission machines with.
Titan is looking rather good.
Ending
Last edited by Void (2026-11-15 09:49:38)
Be careful what you wish for.
Offline
Like button can go here
A youtube video describing NASAs proposed plasma drive.
https://youtu.be/Tw0iDOQEXqg
This is a fission powered propulsion system. Low enriched uranium slugs are fired through a beryllium tube. The moderation and reflection provided by the tube allows the slug to reach criticality. This heats it to ~100,000K. This occurs as the slug is exiting the tube into a magnetic nozzle, which focuses the plasma into a directed thrust vector.
This propulsion system is expected to develop 10,000kg-f of thrust at an ISP of 5000s. It therefore meets the requirements of the large ship. The propulsion system can be scaled up, by increasing the size of the slugs and including a fusion stage at the heart of each slug. The fast neutrons released by fusion will boost the number of uranium atoms undergoing fission.
The weakness of the plasma drive is that, much like the old Project Orion, it releases fission products in it's exhaust. If used in Earth orbit, a proportion of these isotopes would end up in Earth's atmosphere. It would be much better if we could park the large ship in high orbit and use a different vehicle to ship people to it from low Earth orbit. Maybe a cycler on a permanent elliptical orbit?
Last edited by Calliban (Yesterday 04:52:53)
"Plan and prepare for every possibility, and you will never act. It is nobler to have courage as we stumble into half the things we fear than to analyse every possible obstacle and begin nothing. Great things are achieved by embracing great dangers."
Offline
Like button can go here