Debug: Database connection successful Large Ship hull material (Page 4) / Large ships / New Mars Forums

Announcement

Announcement: This forum is accepting new registrations via email. Please see Recruiting Topic for additional information. Write newmarsmember[at_symbol]gmail.com.

#76 2026-11-09 15:02:07

RobertDyck
Moderator
From: Winnipeg, Canada
Registered: 2002-08-20
Posts: 8,638
Website

Re: Large Ship hull material

What is its fatigue profile? Realize what it will experience. Vacuum of space, temperature cycle between ±250°F (-157°C to +121°C). Hull will be covered in micrometeor shielding and thermal insulation, but still. Pressure of the air inside vs vacuum of space. And experience constant static strain caused by rotation creating 38% gravity. And people walking around inside, changing weight balance slightly. Significant acceleration during Earth orbit departure. Significant acceleration again in reverse direction during aerocapture into Mars orbit. Yea yea, we're still doing the math on that. But if aerocapture doesn't work, then we still need propulsive orbital insertion. During transit, slight maneouvres to ensure water tanks used for radiation shielding are oriented toward radiation from the Sun. Due to the Sun's magnetic field, that won't be perfectly aligned with sunlight. I have envisioned a diagonal support strut from the ring to the body of the spacecraft to provide support during acceleration. That strut basically will have zero load other than acceleration manoeuvres. It could be a different material.

This ship must be able to make at least 12 transits from Earth to Mars and back. With one transit each planetary conjunction, so every 26 months. That means 12*26 = 26 years of continuous operation. I could add test flights: move from one Earth orbit to another to test propulsion. Move into high Earth orbit then dive into atmosphere to skim for aerocapture test. Fly around the far side of the Moon, return to Earth and aerocapture to prove it works. To be truly cautious, an unmanned flight to Mars and back. Although aerocapture would have to be tested at Mars with a smaller unmanned vehicle first.

We're talking sea-going ship life span. Does this material have the durability to last?

Offline

Like button can go here

#77 2026-11-09 17:51:45

kbd512
Administrator
Registered: 2015-01-02
Posts: 8,590

Re: Large Ship hull material

RobertDyck,

Fe-Mn-Al-C is an Iron-based alloy used in structural applications for vehicles, armor plating, and pressure vessels.  It was specifically developed as an adjunct to stainless steels.  It's not a 1:1 replacement.  Two fundamentally different materials never are.  It has higher yield strength, hardness, creep resistance (below 500C), plus a near-identical stiffness and CTE to 316L stainless steel.  It's also non-magnetic, just like 300-series stainless steel.

I've already noted where 316L is superior.  If you intend to take the material to 650C, or store LOX, or anything colder than LOX, then use 316L.  If you intend to store something acidic, use 316L.  316L also withstands certain chemical attacks better, and some worse.  All that said, Fe-Mn-Al-C is a distinctly superior material in terms of yield strength (below 500C), availability of the alloying components, and therefore cost.  316L is so costly because it requires a lot of Nickel and Chromium.  Simply stating, "we'll get the Nickel and Chromium", without specifying how or where, is not much of an answer.  When your vehicle weighs thousands of tons, material costs really start to add up.  Nobody makes ocean-going ships from 316L stainless steel for that reason.  Nobody makes ships from Fe-Mn-Al-C because it still costs more than low-alloy Carbon steels.  Compromises are clearly required.  A paper-thin hull for an interplanetary ship carrying thousands of people is a very bad idea.

If you want absolute ductility, then TWIP steels like Fe-Mn (little to no Aluminum content) are superior to Fe-Mn-Al-C, which can experience brittle cleavages/fractures at moderate to deeply cryogenic temperatures.  Reducing or eliminating Aluminum content also makes the steel corrode like any plain Carbon steel.  However, it retains full ductility down to LH2 temperatures, and companies like POSCO have used it for that purpose with appropriate aerospace coatings.

The question probably on your mind is, "Can we increase 316L's yield strength?"

Yes, you absolutely can do that through a massive bulk material upset during cold working, but understand what you give up after you do.

You can increase 316L's room-temperature yield strength to 100ksi by cold-working the metal.  If you take a 2mm-thick sheet of 316L and smash it to 1mm-thick between a pair of rollers, you will get a much higher yield strength.  When you do that, ductility plummets to only 10-20% of its previously very high value.  If you attempt to deform it further after taking the steel to 100 ksi YS using a gross upset, it will simply crack/snap like a piece of 7075 Aluminum.

For example, you need a 100ksi C-channel, so you first cold-form the 316L into that shape and induce a large upset.  The requisite yield strength for the part has been met, but forming/shaping doesn't typically end there for a complex ship hull.  After you produce the C-channel stock, you need it to curve around the hull's exterior or interior to weld it into place as a structural hat-type stiffener as a bulkhead or hull reinforcement.  Therein lies the problem.  You cannot do that after the initial upset.  You would have to induce the upset and form it to the exact geometry you needed at the same time.  If the plans call for a 10mm thick curved plate with 100ksi yield strength, the upset (cold-forging using hammers and/or rollers) and "curved" workpiece shaping need to be one operation.  That's pretty hard to do.  It's not impossible, but you need reconfigurable rollers and/or dies for every curved workpiece the ship has.  The alternative is using a material with a higher baseline yield strength so cold-forming doesn't demand so large an upset, part geometry changes to better resist the forces applied to it, or some combination of all techniques.

The part I'm trying to point out to you, which you and others seem very reticent to acknowledge, is that BEFORE any cold-working takes place, Fe-Mn and Fe-Mn-Al-C alloys already have more than double the room-temperature yield strength of 316L stainless steel, AND near-identical ductility.  On top of that, they're fundamentally easier to make than 300-series stainless steels.  The only other caveat I would add is that 300-series respond well to laser, electron beam, and consumables-based welding methods, whereas Fe-Mn and Fe-Mn-Al-C respond much better to friction-stir welding (no consumables, no advanced welding equipment).

My adjunct is that if you're going to weld on the ground or in space, friction-stir welding doesn't produce MMOD or molten metal, which I find highly desirable for thicker plate steels.  In an orbital environment, I don't want globules of molten steel accidentally detaching from the weld pool and becoming a future hazard to deal with.  This isn't highly concerning for EBW, but for laser welding or consumables-based welding, it's absolutely a problem worth thinking about.  Beyond that, simply stating, "we'll just EBW everything" isn't much of an answer, either, because it ignores all the extant issues with EBW.

The vast majority of any ship's hull is plate and sheet.  You're not milling away blocks of metal or connecting pipes; you're fusing flat stock and using geometry to impart strength and stiffness.  NASA can shave off every last ounce of weight because production volumes are exceptionally low and the taxpayer is footing the bill for the materials, machines, and labor.  There's no firm production schedule to maintain.  If they miss a deadline, they don't lose their money.  NASA doesn't have to be efficient or cost-effective with small, one-off pieces of aerospace hardware.  There's no serial production of much of anything.  No shipyard in existence operates that way, because they do lose future business if deadlines aren't met.

If we're going to produce multi-thousand-ton ship hulls, and not as one-off, never-to-be-repeated vanity projects, we need materials and fabrication methods that deliver consistent quality, on time and on budget.  That implies mass production of materials, use of geometry over special material properties (forged metal over CFRP), and using robust designs that can tolerate some manufacturing imperfection.

Offline

Like button can go here

#78 2026-11-09 18:44:20

RobertDyck
Moderator
From: Winnipeg, Canada
Registered: 2002-08-20
Posts: 8,638
Website

Re: Large Ship hull material

Actually I'm thinking aluminum is a lot easier to harvest from Lunar regolith than chrome from that asteroid. This sounds great. Next, how much manganese will it require? Will also metal asteroid in near Earth space have enough? Regardless, we will need serious alloys. Any alloy will require things like manganese.

So you said it's for vehicles. Casting is addressed. Can it be cold rolled?

Offline

Like button can go here

#79 2026-11-09 19:58:14

kbd512
Administrator
Registered: 2015-01-02
Posts: 8,590

Re: Large Ship hull material

RobertDyck,

To the best of my knowledge, most Aluminum alloys (in annealed condition), Grade 1 and 2 (Commercially Pure/CP) Titanium, 300-series stainless steels, Fe-Mn, and Fe-Mn-Al-C austenitic alloys can all be cold-rolled to improve yield strength through massive upsets, such as taking any of the aforementioned alloys and smashing them between rollers to reduce their section thickness by ~50%.  For CP Titanium in particular, there's a maximum amount of "smash" you can achieve per pass through the rollers without risking cracking.

Standard practice for producing plate and sheet with an "automotive/aerospace quality" surface finish is cold rolling.  Automotive OEMs, in particular, are very sensitive to surface-finish imperfections.  Aerospace primes care far more about material properties verification testing, fatigue life, corrosion protection, and ultimate durability.  I think both are required, to varying degrees, over a rotating structure as large as a multi-thousand-ton interplanetary transport.  A bad surface finish would become its own kind of problem.

The moon has lots of Iron, Titanium, Aluminum, and Silicon, much like Earth.  There is Manganese in every scoop of regolith, but you'd need to process extra regolith to extract enough Manganese to make high-Manganese alloys.  Unfortunately, Nickel and Chromium are nowhere near as abundant, so making stainless steels requires dramatically more regolith processing.  If we can find suitably large chunks of meteoroids on the surface, we can probably get enough Nickel, but Chromium doesn't have any as-yet-identified abundant source, even on Earth.

If we were going to fabricate the hull from Aluminum, we either must have Copper or serious cold-working of 1100-O into 1100-H18 (and still accept a massive weight increase).  2219 and 2024 alloys get their excellent ductility from Copper.  Commercially pure 1100-O/1100-H18 can be cold-forged/cold-rolled to improve yield strength and specific strength (kN⋅m/kg).

Specific Strength Comparison (kN⋅m/kg)
1100-O: 12.9
1100-H18: 55.4
2219-T87: 137.3
316L Stainless: 25.0
Grade 1 Titanium: 37.7
Grade 2 Titanium: 61.0
Fe-Mn (Hadfield steel): 44.9
Fe-Mn-Al-C (aged austenitic): 113.6

Offline

Like button can go here

#80 2026-11-09 21:41:40

kbd512
Administrator
Registered: 2015-01-02
Posts: 8,590

Re: Large Ship hull material

RobertDyck,

If material cost, availability, and structural weight are irrelevant, then yes, I would choose 316L stainless steel for many applications because of its excellent combination of mechanical properties.  Unfortunately, availability and structural weight become challenging obstacles, irrespective of cost, when we start talking about doubling to quadrupling the dry mass of the ship's hull, even when you have fusion reactors to provide brute-force propulsive power.  If we had a working in-space propulsion system that doesn't require propellant, then the extra weight of 316L starts looking more like a cost of doing business and less like an Iron Albatross wrapped around the neck of our large ship.  To truly live and work in deep space indefinitely, we need steel structures or Aluminum sections so thick and stiff that only very minor deflection occurs during operation.

As much waste heat as humans and life support systems generate, you'd think we would want a waste heat distribution system literally built into the ship's hull to ensure it never "freezes", even in deep space.  Beyond reducing radiator surface area for inefficient, low-temperature radiative heat transfer, we no longer need to rely exclusively on austenitic alloys.  A system that maintains hull temperature also improves fatigue life because it eliminates severe temperature swings or differentials between parts of the pressure hull in sunlight or shadow.

Offline

Like button can go here

#81 2026-11-09 22:01:44

RobertDyck
Moderator
From: Winnipeg, Canada
Registered: 2002-08-20
Posts: 8,638
Website

Re: Large Ship hull material

I'm not arguing for one particular alloy. I'm trying to figure out how to do this. Transporting that much from Earth would cost too much. That's why I looked for in-situ materials.

Frankly, I've worried more about the war in Ukraine. It's bad. It could get a lot worse. But I don't want this thread to get contaminated with other issues. Yes, returning to address the Large Ship would be useful. I also gave some advice to politicians. To my surprise, some points of my requests have been implemented. Tiny points. Screwed up. They took all credit, no mention of me or any other voter. And looks like their efforts will fail. But one question is how to get government funding to get my company started. Raise funds to start building the Large Ship.

Offline

Like button can go here

#82 2026-11-09 22:46:36

kbd512
Administrator
Registered: 2015-01-02
Posts: 8,590

Re: Large Ship hull material

RobertDyck,

I'm reasonably sure that I've spent significantly more time identifying the specific material properties and fabrication methods of suitable hull materials than most other people here.  I have a list of things I look for, and trades I consider worthwhile.  In situ materials aren't how the first ship will be built, so that's a topic for later.  You actually have to prioritize which problems you're solving when designing and building any specific thing, because there are an infinite number of rabbit holes you can go down that won't lead to anything getting built.

I've quite literally never seen any serious attempt at something amounting to an honest engineering proposal for an interplanetary ship.  It's all estimates and graphics, with little hard data or analysis to back them up.  NASA has come closest, but the moment they produce any kind of design approaching engineering viability (something someone could actually build if they put their designer hat down long enough to cut metal), they immediately refocus on another design or idea, often unrelated to their prior work.  People's focus and attention these days are everywhere and nowhere.

If you don't want this thread contaminated with other issues, stop yourself from contaminating it.  This thread has absolutely nothing to do with politics, wars, or politicians.  You brought it up here instead of in the politics thread because that's where your headspace is at, and that's why you've accomplished nothing worthy of your own efforts.  If you can't put your political fixations aside long enough to get things done, then nothing will get done.  It's as simple as that.

Offline

Like button can go here

#83 2026-11-12 23:18:49

RobertDyck
Moderator
From: Winnipeg, Canada
Registered: 2002-08-20
Posts: 8,638
Website

Re: Large Ship hull material

I have hesitated because I'm not sure how to respond. I did not want to start another argument. I explained why I haven't spend a lot of time on this recently. Your work is significant, and appreciated.

Offline

Like button can go here

#84 2026-11-13 05:47:17

kbd512
Administrator
Registered: 2015-01-02
Posts: 8,590

Re: Large Ship hull material

RobertDyck,

I'm not attempting to be argumentative.  I'm telling you what the engineering data and testing show will or won't work well for a specific application.

I've spent most of my recent efforts on metals for life support systems, specifically Supercritical Water Oxidation systems, which do a fantastic job of rapidly breaking down human waste into useful component chemicals, but it's so aggressive as a solvent that it will leach the alloying metals out of most stainless steels and Inconels.

So far, I've come up with using 347H stainless steel (it's alloyed with Niobium) in conjunction with a multi-step electroplating and polishing process involving a Platinum-Iridium coating, finished with Hot Isostatic Pressing.  Sacrificial grafoil gaskets combined with close tolerances for sensors or feed/exit penetrations appear to be the "best compromise" for sealing purposes.

NTRS: Supercritical Water Oxidation (SCWO) Trade Study and 2021 Final Report

To feed the chemicals into bio-reactors to produce the sugars/starches, proteins, and lipids for crew consumption, a multi-step oxidation process is required that first separates ammonia and salts for downstream reuse.

Strictly speaking, 347H is not suitable as a bulk hull material due to cost, but for higher temperature hull components, particularly high-temperature radiator panels or engine parts, it withstands continuous operation near 650C without creep-related failures.  Certain high-performance turbochargers use this metal in their exhaust impeller wheels, for example.

As much as I continue my attempts to find good applications for Titanium and Titanium alloys, anywhere it's exposed to high temperatures, high pressure Oxygen, or LOX, it remains a severe auto-ignition fire risk.  I still feel it could be a good material for internal decks and pressure bulkheads with appropriate surface passivation coatings.

Offline

Like button can go here

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB