New Mars Forums

tahanson43206

Moderator

Registered: 2018-04-27

Posts: 18,452

White Paper - what it is - how to write one - Peer Review

This topic is offered for NewMars members and readers who may aspire to advanced positions in large organizations.

Post #3 will show ChatGPT4o's offer in explanation of the subject.

This topic is available for contributions that provide links to ** real ** White papers.

There may be repositories where White papers exist in great numbers.

Links to such repositories would be welcome.

(th)

tahanson43206

Moderator

Registered: 2018-04-27

Posts: 18,452

Re: White Paper - what it is - how to write one - Peer Review

This post is reserved for an index to posts that NewMars members may provide over time.

(th)

tahanson43206

Moderator

Registered: 2018-04-27

Posts: 18,452

Re: White Paper - what it is - how to write one - Peer Review

This is a response from ChatGPT4o to an inquiry about White Papers and Peer Review...

White Paper Definition and How to for NASA Job Applicants

White Paper Definition

White Paper:
A white paper is a comprehensive and authoritative report that often aims to inform and persuade its audience. For NASA, a white paper typically presents a well-researched analysis or proposal on a specific topic relevant to their missions and objectives. It usually includes:

• Title and Abstract: A brief summary of the paper's content and purpose.

• Introduction: Background information and the purpose of the white paper.

• Problem Statement: A clear definition of the problem or issue being addressed.

• Methodology: The methods used to gather and analyze data.

• Findings and Analysis: Detailed presentation of the research findings or the results of the analysis.

• Conclusion and Recommendations: Summarizing the key points and suggesting actionable steps or solutions.

• References: Citing all the sources and data used in the paper.

Peer Review

Peer Reviewed:
Peer review is a process where experts in the same field evaluate a document for its quality, validity, and relevance before it is published or accepted. For NASA, peer-reviewed work ensures that the research or analysis presented in the white paper meets high standards of scientific rigor and credibility. The peer review process typically involves:

• Submission: The author submits the white paper to a journal or conference.

• Reviewer Selection: The editor selects experts in the relevant field to review the paper.

• Review Process: Reviewers evaluate the paper, provide feedback, and suggest revisions.

• Revisions: The author makes necessary revisions based on the feedback.

• Final Decision: The paper is accepted, rejected, or requires further revision based on the reviewers’ assessments.

Qualifications for White Paper Submission

While PhD-level work is often considered the pinnacle of academic research, master’s degree holders can certainly participate in writing and submitting white papers, especially if they have relevant expertise and experience. NASA values contributions that demonstrate strong analytical skills, innovative thinking, and a deep understanding of the subject matter, regardless of the author's academic level.

In summary, a white paper for NASA should be a well-structured document that thoroughly explores a significant issue or proposal. Peer review adds an additional layer of credibility, ensuring that the work meets high standards of scientific accuracy and relevance. Both PhD and master’s degree holders can contribute valuable insights through white papers, provided they adhere to these rigorous standards.

(th)