New Mars Forums

Official discussion forum of The Mars Society and MarsNews.com

You are not logged in.

Announcement

Announcement: This forum is accepting new registrations via email. Please see Recruiting Topic for additional information. Write newmarsmember[at_symbol]gmail.com.

#201 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Freedom?????? - Are People really Free? » 2002-10-25 15:35:15

The mind is what the brain does.

Prove it. You have your theories, others have theirs. The issue is not so open and closed as you are suggesting.

Clark:

Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (F-MRI) scans of peoples' brains are revealing more and more details about how our brains work.  Researchers give people different mental tasks to perform during the scans and researchers are thereby able to determine which brain regions are involved in processing those tasks.  This research is leaving less and less room for the proposition that the human mind is a supernatural or metaphysical entity.  Eventually, the proposition that "the mind is what the brain does" will seem like something that has always been an accepted truth, and the concept of the soul be regarded as a historical curiosity.

And science marches on...  And sometimes science steps on people's toes and cherished beliefs.  Sorry.

Scott

#202 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Freedom?????? - Are People really Free? » 2002-10-24 19:08:14

You are completely discounting the documented influence of the mind over physiology...

Clark:

The mind is what the brain does.

Scott

#203 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Freedom?????? - Are People really Free? » 2002-10-24 15:30:53

Clark, you wrote, "I think I might actually stop here becuase I see what you are getting at, but it is theoritcal bullsh*t that can't be proved and even if it could, the results are meanigless since we're powerless to change it."

The proposition that the behavior of a complex organism (e.g., a horse, dolphin, chimpanzee, or human) is determined by the organism's physiology, history of reinforcement and punishment, and current environment, is a scientific theory.  People can and do use techniques that are based on that theory in order to shape the behaviors of various species of organisms, including humans.  We could apply those techniques to the task of creating a human sociocultural system that can maintain and replicate itself on Mars.  Or we could teach people to believe that they have supernatural souls and free will and then we could use those theological doctrines to justify rewarding and punishing them in order to shape them into Martian settlers.

Science or Religion; take your pick!

#204 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Freedom?????? - Are People really Free? » 2002-10-24 13:29:51

Clark, you asked, "So a slave who wants to be a slave is actually free?"

No. A slave who wants to be a slave is nevertheless, under law, a slave.  Let's not confuse the legal concepts of freeman and slave with the feeling of freedom (an emotional state).

Clark, you asked, "So a slave is someone who is experiencing a lesser degree of freedom?"  Not necessarily.  A slave whose master makes few demands on him may feel more freedom than the master's daughter, especially if the master refuses to allow the daughter to marry a man whom she dearly loves.  The daughter may feel highly oppressed while the slave feels a high degree of freedom.

Clark, you asked, "Ought to do? Who determines what they ought to do?"  In the near term, what people ought to do is determined by, for example, the king ("The law is in my mouth," said King James), the Parliament, the Congress, the Legislature, the Port Zubrin Community Council.  In the long term, what people ought to do is determined by natural selection; some sociocultural systems survive and others don't.

Clark, you asked, "So we don't have free-will then?"  Free will is a theological concept, not a scientific theory.  Scientists do not theorize that each human is inhabited by a supernatural entity that controls human behavior.

Clark, you requested that I "describe the 'feeling' of freedom as an emotional state."  Several hundred people are being held at gun-point in a Moscow theater.  They are most likely feeling an emotion called fear.  In contrast, Mr. Multi-billionaire Warren Buffet, who has enough money to do almost anything that he can think of, probably feels quite free.

Scott

#205 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Freedom?????? - Are People really Free? » 2002-10-24 11:25:41

Degrees of freedom?

Clark:

People experience the feeling of freedom when they can do almost anything that they want to do.  When they want to do many things that they cannot do then they experience a lesser degree of freedom.

A society has a very effective system of socialization and social control if its members want to do what they ought to do.  The members of a society can experience high degrees of freedom even though their behavior is determined by their (1) physiology, (2) history of reinforcement and punishment, and (3) current environment.

Freedom is best understood as an emotional state.  Using freedom as a theory of behavior (e.g., "People do what they do because they are free.") does not explain anything.

Scott

#206 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Martian Gold Standard - Will Martian money be as good as gold? » 2002-10-23 19:40:24

In order for gold ores to form the has to be oceans, erosin, and technochechs.

Mr. Earthfirst:

You may be correct in asserting that placer deposits of gold may be few and far between on Mars.  However, Mars may have plentiful lode deposits of gold and other valuable minerals.

Scott MarsNext  wink

#207 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Sociocracy and Martian Settlement - Scientific Government On Mars? » 2002-10-23 19:25:06

In a previous message, I suggested that Martian settlements might be organized like the Ecovillage of Ithaca, which is located in the state of New York.  I have discovered that the EcoVillage of Loudoun County, Virginia, has a governance system called "sociocracy."  That village's website presents the following description of sociocracy.

"EcoVillage of Loudoun County, VA uses a decision-making system called sociocracy to set policies and rules efficiently while respecting each other. Sociocracy originated in The Netherlands. Originally envisioned in 1945 by Kees Boeke, a Dutch educator and pacifist, as a way to adapt Quaker egalitarian principles to secular organizations, sociocracy allows us to give and receive effective leadership while remaining peers.

"Gerard Endenburg, a pupil of Kees Boeke, developed Boeke's vision into a body of well-tested procedures and practical principles. After World War II, Gerard Endenburg's parents (socialists before the war), set up their own (successful) company to try out their advanced ideas. Gerard trained as an electrical engineer, gained expertise in cybernetics (the new science of steering and control), and worked briefly for Phillips Electronics, designing a flat speaker that is still used in small electronic equipment today. Then his father challenged him to manage a small, failing business he had purchased. In less than a year Gerard had made the business profitable and merged it with his father's company. In the late 1960?s, Gerard's father retired, and Gerard became manager of Endenburg Electrotechniek with the mandate to run it both as a profitable business and as a real time laboratory for testing innovative management ideas. Sociocracy is a product of that experience.

"Today, Gerard has retired from day-to-day management of Endenburg Electrotechniek to devote his time to running the Sociocratisch Centrum, a consulting business that assists a wide variety of companies and organizations (including cohousing communities) to implement sociocratic structures. Gerard is also a professor at the Economic Science and Industry Department of the University of Maastricht where sociocracy is part of the curriculum and academic practice."

Continued at (click here and then on "Governance")

Webster's Third New International Dictionary defines sociocracy as "(1) a theoretical form of government in which society as a whole has sovereign rights, (2) the application of scientifically determined principles promoting the interests of society as a whole."

Should Martian governance systems be based on "scientifically determined principles"?

Scott

#208 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Freedom?????? - Are People really Free? » 2002-10-23 00:05:04

Dear Mr. Earthfirst:

You asked, "Are People really Free?"

This question was addressed by Edward O. Wilson in a book titled "On Human Nature."  Wilson wrote, "The great paradox of determinism and free will, which has held the attention of the wisest of philosophers and psychologists for generations, can be phrased in more biological terms as follows: if our genes are inherited and our environment is a train of physical events set in motion before we were born, how can there be a truly independent agent within the brain?  The agent itself is created by the interaction of the genes and the environment.  It would appear that our freedom is only a self-delusion."

In other words, people are not really free.

You have asserted that, "Mars will proble be a despotism or some other sort of dickator run planet."  I respectfully disagree.  The people of Mars will be extremely careful not to oppress each other.  They will all be living in fragile, pressurized containers and will avoid doing anything that gives anyone a reason to sabotage those fragile containers.  Martians will be very polite and very generous.

Sincerely, Scott G. Beach

#209 Re: Mars Society International » Very Cunning Amendments - Prototype Settlements Preempted » 2002-10-22 15:18:46

A corporation named "Mars Society, Inc." was organized under Colorado law on September 11, 1997 by Declan J. O'Donnell.  That corporation was dissolved on March 1, 2002 by the Colorado Secretary of State and then reinstated on August 23, 2002. 

The Articles of Incorporation of Mars Society, Inc. provide that Robert Zubrin, Margaret Zubrin, and Declan J. O'Donnell will be the original members of the Society's Board of Directors. The Articles of Incorporation were amended on April 20, 1998 to provide that Richard Wagner is also an original member of the Society's Board of Directors.  That amendment was filed with the Colorado Secretary of State on May 27, 1998.  That amendment also eliminated the sentence, "The specific purpose and objective of the Corporation shall be to further the exploration and settlement of Mars." 

On December 11, 1999, the Board of Directors of Mars Society, Inc. adopted bylaws which provide that, "The purpose of the Mars Society is to further the exploration and settlement of the planet Mars through; 1. Broad public outreach to instill the vision of pioneering the Red Planet, 2. Mobilizing support for ever more aggressive government funded Mars exploration programs around the world, and 3. Conducting Mars exploration on a private basis."

In accordance with this purpose statement, Mars Society, Inc. can mobilize support for and conduct Mars exploration activities.  And it can build prototype Martian stations in order to conduct simulated Mars exploration activities.  And it can instill the vision of settlers pioneering Mars.  But Mars Society, Inc. cannot build a prototype Martian settlement.  The Articles of Incorporation and bylaws were cleverly amended in order to exclude this activity.  That is why, when Steering Committee member Bruce Mackenzie "presented a new project idea: The Analog Settlement to publicly demonstrate the feasibility of living beyond the Earth and its advantages to everyone," Mr. Mackenzie's project idea was simply ignored.  He had unwittingly proposed an activity that is beyond the scope of the Society's cunningly amended purpose.

Sorry Bruce; you have been preempted.   wink

#210 Re: Other space advocacy organizations » The Mars Institute - For Mars Exploration, NOT Settlement » 2002-10-19 23:41:49

I wasn't aware that the Mars Society founded the Mars Institute.  So if your a MS member, are you automatically an MI member or do they have different membership models?  Will the two share funds or will they be treated as two completely different organizations?  I like the move to a more science oriented organization that doesn't concern itself with politics.  I agree that your far more likely to get people to work on projects if they know they won't automatically be associated with X political movement.

Phobos: According to the Mars Institute's first press release, "The Mars Institute's founding Board of Directors includes Dr. Pascal Lee of the SETI Institute, Dr. Charles Cockell of the British Antarctic Survey, and Mr. Marc Boucher of SpaceRef Interactive, Inc."  Dr. Lee and Mr. Boucher are key members of the Mars Society.

From a legal perspective, the Mars Society and the Mars Institute are "two completely different organizations".  However, given their overlapping leadership, these two organizations will be able to closely coordinate their operations.

You wrote, "I like the move to a more science oriented organization that doesn't concern itself with politics".  The Mars Institute will facilitate cooperation between physical scientists. The Mars Institute is for geologists, astronomers, and physicists and it is not likely to include political scientists, anthropologists, sociologists, and other social scientists.

The Mars Institute is a logical response to the fact that physical scientists do not want to have their scientific explorations distorted by political wrangling.  These scientists remember that, prior to the adoption of Antarctic treaties, they were ordered not to discover commercial-grade mineral deposits in Antarctica. 

In general, physical scientists try to avoid the kind of political wrangling that would certainly accompany efforts to design Martian settlements.  They will gladly limit their concerns to planning exploration missions.  By ignoring the task of planning Martian settlements, they are able to avoid thorny issues like marriage, divorce, alimony, child custody, and whether high schools biology textbooks shall include alternative "theories" such as creationism.  While anthropologists find these issues salient, geologists tend to puke at the thought.   tongue

#211 Re: Other space advocacy organizations » The Mars Institute - For Mars Exploration, NOT Settlement » 2002-10-19 02:36:18

Phobos:

The founding of the Mars Institute has ramifications that go beyond its stated mission of furthering "the scientific study, exploration, and public understanding of Mars."  The existence of the Mars Institute will allow the Board of Directors of the Mars Society to amend the bylaws of the Mars Society to provide that the Society's Directors shall be elected by the Society's members. 

The "activists" of a democratically controlled Mars Society will then be able to focus on the settlement of Mars while the "scientists" of the Mars Institute focus on the exploration of Mars.  This division of labor between activists and scientists will encourage more scientists to become involved in Mars research and exploration programs.  The Mars Institute gives scientists the option of participating in worldwide Mars research and exploration programs without taking the risk of being directly associated with people who advocate the settlement of Mars.

Scott

#212 Re: Other space advocacy organizations » The Mars Institute - For Mars Exploration, NOT Settlement » 2002-10-15 17:41:02

The Mars Institute was incorporated under California law on September 18, 2002.  This new organization will "further the scientific study, exploration, and public understanding of Mars."  The Mars Institute will not deal with the settlement of Mars because settlement plans and projects necessarily involve political complexities that scientists prefer to avoid.

**********************************
PRESS RELEASE

October 15 - 2002 The Mars Institute: A New Resource for a New Century of Mars Exploration

Houston, Texas - Members of the founding Board of Directors of the Mars Institute formally unveiled the new organization today at the World Space Congress.

The Mars Institute is a California-based nonprofit corporation whose stated purpose is to further the scientific study, exploration, and public understanding of Mars. The Institute intends to:

develop, implement and support high quality peer-reviewed scientific research about the planet Mars, its present nature, and its climatic, geologic and possibly biologic evolution, including through investigations of similarities and differences between the Earth, Mars and other planets;

analyze, develop and implement concepts, technologies and strategies for the exploration of Mars, by robotic systems and humans;

inform the public on the results, progress, and benefits to humankind of Mars exploration through the development and implementation of educational and public outreach activities.

Continued at http://www.marsinstitute.info

#213 Re: Exploration to Settlement Creation » Naming Martian Settlements - What would you suggest? » 2002-10-11 16:00:57

Reuters news service has reported the discovery of a marble plaque that bears the ancient name of the city of London. According to the report, "The Italian marble plaque, found in the Southwark area of London at the junction of three key Roman roads, is dedicated to the Roman emperors and the god Mars..."

Londinium is a good name for a Martian settlement.

Scott

#214 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2002-10-10 20:02:16

And do you suppose the people of California owe their calender to the state government?

Mr. Armitage:

I am not sure what you mean by "owe."  The California statues form a legal foundation for state actions.  For example, a person can obtain a motor vehicle drivers' license at 16 years of age, and this age is calculated pursuant to state law.  The terms of insurance contracts, which provide coverage from a beginning time and date to an ending time and date, are usually based on the statutes for calculating time.  However, a particular contract could specify that a different way of calculating time shall be used for the purposes of the contract. 

Scott

#215 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2002-10-10 13:20:04

Each Martian settlement would probably have ordinances that are structurally similar to the following example.

Scott
****************

CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE SECTIONS 6800-6807

6800.  The time in which any act provided by law is to be done is computed by excluding the first day, and including the last, unless the last day is a holiday, and then it is also excluded.

6801.  Time is computed according to the Gregorian or new style; and January 1st, in every year, after 1752 is reckoned as the first day of the year.

6802.  The years 1900, 2100, 2200, 2300, or any other future
hundredth year, of which the year 2000 is the first, except only
every fourth hundredth year, are not leap years, but common years of 365 days.  The years 2000, 2400, 2800, and every other fourthhundredth year after 2000 and every fourth year, except as provided in this section, which, by usage in this State is considered a leap year, is a leap year consisting of 366 days.

6803.  "Year" means a period of 365 days; "half year," 182 days; "quarter of a year," 91 days.  The added day of a leap year, and the day immediately preceding, if they occur in any such period, shall be reckoned together as one day.

6804.  "Month" means a calendar month, unless otherwise expressed.

6805.  A week consists of seven consecutive days.

6806.  A day is the period of time between any midnight and the midnight following.

6807.  "Daytime" is the period of time between sunrise and sunset.  "Nighttime" is the period of time between sunset and sunrise.

#216 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2002-10-09 02:59:13

I hold a new calander should be designed based on accurate measurements of Mars's position in its orbit with new lengths of time for familiar units (hours minutes, so forth), and angle measurements for moments like New Year and Solstices.

Matt:

The Goddard Institute for Space Studies has a very nice "Time on Mars" applet (click here).

Scott

#217 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2002-10-08 16:49:49

Can we start a pool?

Clark:

You are a genius.  A pool is exactly what we need.  However, it should have a fence around it and the gate in the fence should have a child-proof latch.  Otherwise, Cindy might fall in and get as mad as a wet hen.  And then she might even become hostile! big_smile

Scott

#218 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2002-10-08 14:02:56

Apparently your immaturity demands that everyone either agree with you or be guilt induced into being quiet and not criticize you.

Cindy:

You have injected yet another dose of venom into this discussion of Martian Calendar and Timekeeping systems.  I predict that you will do that at least four more times.  One, two, and counting...

#219 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2002-10-08 04:22:47

Cindy:

You have succeeded in injecting another dose of venom into this discussion of  Martian Calendar and Timekeeping systems.  You should be proud of your efforts.  People who visit this forum for the first time will see your posts and be inspired to leave immediately and never return.

#220 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2002-10-07 12:01:48

You know, those renders, though nice, aren't very practical. How are they building the brick structures? Many of them are very high, and I don't see any scaffolding of sorts. Are they using some sort of robot, or what?

Josh:

The renderings produced by Richard Mallon-Day are based on the ideas of Bruce Mackenzie, who is a graduate of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.  Mr. Mackenzie is thinking about the process of building such structures.  The construction processes would probably include automated excavating machinery for digging foundations and machines that turn excavated regolith into building blocks.  You are correct in supposing that scaffolding would be necessary in the construction of the arches.  These and many thousands of other details will have to be included in a plan to construct a Martian settlement.

Scott

#221 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2002-10-07 11:49:33

Thank you Scott. I'm sure the Martians will love not having a calender until they've built their vaults, and they'll love using a fricking sundial even more. Now all they need are copulation rituals centering on the sundial, and they'll be in nirvana.

Come on, mention Communidad de los Fruitcakes. You know you want to.

Mr. Armitage:

The malicious and hostile tone of your previous message is not going to prevent me from participating in the discussions in this forum.  However, you will make other people afraid to participate.  They will not post their ideas because they fear that you will launch inane attacks on them.

Stop and think about what you are doing.  Or is it your intent to sabotage the discussions in this forum?

Scott G. Beach

#222 Re: Civilization and Culture » The Martian Calender and Timekeeping » 2002-10-06 17:03:03

Richard Mallon-Day has composed renderings (click here) of structures that might be built on Mars.  One structure consists of a square courtyard covered by a glass dome and surrounded by two-story structures that might house several dozen families.  The first Martian settlement might look like this.

I have proposed that a Provisional Government of Mars be authorized to issue Settlement Charters (click here) to groups of people who want to emigrate to Mars to establish settlements.  The settlers would be authorized to construct a "Center Monument" and adopt ordinances for the governance of an area 10 kilometers in radius around the Center Monument.
                           
If settlers went to Mars and erected a Center Monument in the form of an obelisk about 3 meters high, and if the Center Monument were located in the central square of a structure similar to the one rendered by Mr. Mallon-Day, then the settlers might base their time and calendar system on that monument.  The monument could be used as a sundial.  The position of its shadow during a day would indicate the time and the length of the shadow would indicate the season.

#223 Re: Civilization and Culture » A Moral Compass for Martians » 2002-10-02 19:35:57

Scotty-boy;

Do you really want Martians to spend all their time diddling their psychology?

No.  But I do want Martians to be aware of the power that their cultures have to shape their behavior.  Martians should be taught how to control of the evolution of their cultures.

Scott

#224 Re: Civilization and Culture » A Moral Compass for Martians » 2002-10-02 17:40:00

Clark:

Here is an example of a cultural practice might be included in a SDP.  Under the topic of "Marital Relations," there might be a specification for improving a person's relationship with his or her spouse.

For example, if a woman felt that her relationship with her husband was "strained and in need of improvement" then she could use the following procedures.  First, she would, from day to day, record and chart (1) the number of positive verbal contacts (PVCs) that she initiates with her husband, (2) the number of negative verbal contacts (NVCs) that she initiates with him, (3) the number of PVCs that he initiates with her, and (4) the number of NVCs that he initiates with her.  After recording and charting these "baseline" measurements, she undertakes to increase the number of PVCs that she initiates and to decrease the number of NVCs that she initiates.  She records her efforts and she continues to record the number of PVCs and NVCs that her husband initiates.  As the number of PVCs that she initiates go up, and as the number of NVCs that she initiates go down, she will probably start to see a corresponding change in her husband's behavior.  And then they will live happily ever after.

This is an example of a behavior modification program that is actually used at Comunidad de los Horcones.  The members of the community all expect to be involved in these kinds of programs.  Conducting these sorts of behavior modification programs is an integral part of their culture.  However, a visiting anthropologist can find this a bit unnerving at first.

Scott

P.S.  The Los Horconans use up lots of chart paper.   wink

#225 Re: Civilization and Culture » A Moral Compass for Martians » 2002-10-02 14:53:11

Hmmm. . .

Interesting idea. Do you think Salt Lake City could raise $100 billion dollars for a colony?

Bill:

The Mormons have lots of money.  And their polygamous tendencies would produce lots of Martians in record time. big_smile

Scott

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB