New Mars Forums

Official discussion forum of The Mars Society and MarsNews.com

You are not logged in.

Announcement

Announcement: This forum is accepting new registrations by emailing newmarsmember * gmail.com become a registered member. Read the Recruiting expertise for NewMars Forum topic in Meta New Mars for other information for this process.

#1 Re: Not So Free Chat » Politics » 2024-11-10 17:08:43

How long after Hurricane Katrina in 2005 before a response from FEMA? The Canadian Navy sent several ships with helicopters, water desalination systems, emergency rations, etc. One ship had a hospital. For a long time the only emergency relief was from the Canadian Navy. Again, how long before FEMA showed up? What is the government paying FEMA for?

#2 Re: Not So Free Chat » Politics » 2024-11-09 00:31:48

Russia's President Putin has said many times the only way to end the war is capitulation. Putin not only demanded keeping all the land his army took by force, killing hundreds of thousands, he also demanded Ukraine surrender the remaining portions of the oblasts that Russia partially occupies. Putin is a bully and insane.

We saw with Chechnya what Putin will do. If Russia keeps any portion of Ukraine, Russia will just train more soldiers, build more weapons and ammunition, then attack again. That's not an end. Furthermore if Russia takes Ukraine they'll attack Poland and the Baltic states next. Russia has already said so. The only way to prevent World War 3 is to stop Russia in Ukraine.

Terms of ending the war:
- Russia gets all troops out of Ukraine. 1991 borders
- Russia returns all Ukrainian children they abducted
- Ukraine joins NATO as a full member
- Ukraine joins EU
- Russia will never be allowed navy bases in Crimea ever again
- only AFTER all this will Ukraine withdraw troops from Kursk

Points for negotiation:
- Russia pays for reconstruction in Ukraine
- Russian generals and officials responsible for this war surrender to Ukraine for prosecution
- releasing frozen bank accounts and frozen assets (interest has already been seized)
- lifting sanctions on Russia
- NATO agrees to never place any nuclear weapons in Ukraine (eg missiles with nuclear warheads aimed at Moscow)

#3 Re: Not So Free Chat » Politics » 2024-11-09 00:14:12

That's a one-sided and extreme opinion. Yes, the attack of October 7 was horrible. It doesn't justify genocide. Israel's reaction is disproportionate. Killing civilians in Gaza cannot be justified simply because some stupid extremists did something bad. Yes, very bad.

Never forget the video of a man speaking Russian leading Hamas terrorist through the fence on October 7. I believe that man was Wagner Group. Russia did this deliberately as a distraction from the war in Ukraine. How many people died for a distraction? And Israel further escalated by attacking Lebanon. Don't try to justify it, I won't listen. Israel's reaction has been eztreme!

The Gaza Strip was supposed to be the nation of Palestine a very long time ago. Israel has treated it as Israeli territory and occupied it for a very long time. This just perpetuates animosity.

#4 Re: Not So Free Chat » Politics » 2024-11-05 15:55:08

An interesting video by Peter Zeihan. Short version: he doesn't like any of the candidates for president. He has a detailed, scathing description of just how screwed America is no matter who wins. He ends the video by saying he has probably thoroughly pissed-off everyone, so realize by the time we see this video he's already out of the country for a couple days.
YouTube: America After the Election: Foreign Policy || Peter Zeihan

May I make a polite suggestion? I would like to see "None of the Above" added to the ballot. If "None of the Above" wins more votes than any candidate, then it requires a run-off election or by-election, and none of the candidates who's names were on the ballot are allowed to be on the ballot again. So all parties will have to find a new candidate. Keep doing this until someone wins. Once someone wins, it resets, so the candidates who lost before could run again. The ban isn't permanent. The reason for disallowing candidates to be on the by-election is voters already voted against them. Could I campaign for "none of the Above"?

Ps. Go Vote!!!
I may not like the candidates available in the US right now, failure to vote means you let someone else choose. And you may not like who they choose. If your candidate does lose, the fact you voted means you are justified to complain. If you don't vote, you can't complain.

#5 Re: Not So Free Chat » Politics » 2024-11-05 14:54:45

I have reposted videos from Jake Broe on an internet group with a number of Trump supporters. My concern is propaganda and disinformation from Russia about the war in Ukraine. Jake Broe posts a YouTube video about 3 times per week covering events of the war. I post a link and a "Cole's Notes" for those who don't want to watch. Two days ago I wrote this as part of my post...

Jake covers campaigns for the US presidential election. Jake is a one-issue channel, he supports Ukraine. I understand many on this channel support smaller government, less regulation, and believe Trump will deliver. I agree with smaller government and less regulation, but I don't live in the US so try to avoid partisan politics in the US. Jake is an American who lives in Las Vegas. But Jake played one speech from Trump: "In many cases our allies are worse than our so-called enemies." America's enemies are Russia, China, North Korea, Cuba, Venezuela. Is Trump saying France is worse for America than Russia? Germany is worse for America than China? Canada is worse for America than North Korea? This isn't how you maintain an alliance.

#6 Re: Interplanetary transportation » Launch Vehicles - Energia, Ares, Magnum etc. » 2024-11-03 06:09:23

Financial Times: British aerospace pioneer Reaction Engines collapses into administration October 31, 2024

British aerospace pioneer Reaction Engines has collapsed into administration after failing to secure new funding, ending ambitious hopes of revolutionising air travel by making hypersonic flight a reality.
...
A spokesperson for Mercedes F1 said the company was in “active dialogue with the administrators to ensure the necessary hardware supply for the 2025 season”.

Reaction’s technology is part of the cooling system in the engines used by Mercedes F1 and supplied to McLaren, Williams and Aston Martin to help optimise performance.

The company’s demise could also trigger a battle over the ownership of the intellectual property of its cutting-edge technology
...
The company’s collapse raises questions over a UK-led military project to pursue reusable hypersonic air vehicle technologies.

Along with Rolls-Royce, the Royal Air Force and the defence research agency Defence Science and Technology Laboratory, Reaction was part of the consortium behind the project, which had hoped to fly a demonstrator vehicle as early as the middle of this decade.

#7 Re: Not So Free Chat » Chat » 2024-10-15 06:31:13

The "turkey crown" proved to be the body cavity including rib cage. No wings, no legs (drum sticks). Breasts look like they were trimmed. Looked like a juvenile turkey that was whittled down so the stuffed turkey was 6 pounds. The two of us ate less than half, but did finish the stuffing. The cat got a chunk of fresh turkey, which he really liked. He gobbled the piece of turkey breast, but threw up on the carpet. Rather than throw it out, I cleaned up the mess and put it in a bowl. I notice the cat ate everything in the bowl. So he ate his own upchuck. Cats do that. It's still better than commercial cat food.

#8 Re: Not So Free Chat » Chat » 2024-10-14 14:11:26

Not drinking whisky this weekend. But the name has "royal" in it: Canadian rye whisky.
cr-delux.png

#9 Re: Not So Free Chat » Chat » 2024-10-14 14:00:45

Thawed. It's pieces held in string mesh. Looks like turkey parts, mostly a breast.
My girlfriend also got a whole rutabaga.

#10 Re: Not So Free Chat » Chat » 2024-10-14 12:32:31

Happy Thanksgiving. In Canada it's today. Leaves are yellow and falling. Went to the grocery store for a chicken yesterday. My girlfriend found a frozen stuffed turkey crown. I usually stuff the chicken myself, from scratch. Cut off the metal staple and put in microwave on defrost. Will see what a "turkey crown" is when it finishes defrosting and remove from the bag. Got baby potatoes and baby carrots to put in the roasting pan.

#11 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » A New Solution to the Fermi Paradox - A Universal Limit on Technology » 2024-10-12 03:59:11

The future will not be exactly "Star Trek". Predictions of the future are never perfect. For one thing, once a prediction is made, people will work to avoid problems identified by that prediction. So the prediction itself changes the future. There are also positive features: Motorola said the Star Trek TOS communicator inspired their StarTak flip phone. It was a radical improvement for its time. The original Star Trek pilot "The Cage" was criticized for using a normal metal clipboard, so starting with the second pilot "Where No Man Has Gone Before", the used an electronic clipboard. It was thick, and the prop was an "Etch A Sketch" toy in a fancy frame, but it inspired modern tablets. In Star Trek TNG they introduced thin tablets and smaller hand-held tablets. Personal Digital Assistant (PDA) was inspired by the hand-held version. PDA was merged with cell phones to become the modern smartphone.

Star Trek Enterprise is a disk with flat level floors. That is not how spacecraft are built today, and using rotation to produce artificial gravity makes the ship look radically different. In fact, if you want to study real life physics, gravity is not a force, it's an effect caused by a time dilation gradient and distorted dimensions of space. Those distortions of space-time are caused by the mass of a planet. Think of it this way: if an aircraft flies a level course, gravity is consistent. Speed is distance travelled divided by time: d/t. If you increase distance travelled per unit time, that increases speed. Most people think of it that way. But what happens if you reduce time? Time dilation reduces time as you fall deeper into the gravity well. Reducing time causes speed to increase. That causes you to accelerate as you fall down. So creating artificial gravity on a ship without using rotation, requires a time dilation gradient. The only way to cause a time dilation gradient is warp drive. So "gravity plating" described in Star Trek would have to be a special application of warp technology. That requires a hell of a lot of energy. You could reduce the volume of space the artifiacal gravity works over, and potentially reduce energy required. That means something in the ceiling, with strong support beams connecting the floor generator to the ceiling generator. So artifical gravity only works between them. That still requires a special application of warp technology. Frankly, I don't see it happening any time soon. Star Trek used "artificial gravity" because it meant the ship could be built in a recording studio in Hollywood.

However, I still argue for ever continuing advancements in technology. A couple advancements we need right now: reverse aging, and artificial womb. A medical treatment to make you young again would allow individuals to remain productive members of society, part of the workforce, for much longer. We have a birth rate crisis, this is one solution. Another solution is to make housing more affordable. Many couples will not have children unless they have a home with a yard. They feel they just can't raise a family in an efficiency apartment. Speculators have driven up prices of houses. We need to drive prices down so young couples can afford a home where they can raise a family.

#12 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » A New Solution to the Fermi Paradox - A Universal Limit on Technology » 2024-10-10 19:24:06

Be very careful. Society has collapsed many times. After ancient Rome, technology fell dramatically. The only reason we retain much of the knowledge from before the Roman collapse is Muslims retained scientific knowledge. Aristotle, Pythagoras, Heron of Alexandria, all were retained by Islam. Emperor Constantine ordered a single book of scientific knowledge to be written, summarizing an entire library into one book. His hope is that one book would survive the coming Dark Age.

That wasn't the first collapse, it was just the latest. The Bronze Age Collapse: Minoa had bronze made of copper, arsenic and antimony. The result was lighter than steel, although the same weight as solid bronze. As hard and strong as high carbon tempered steel. And it was stainless. Considering steel hadn't been invented yet, Minoan soldiers had a great advantage. All other nations of the Mediterranean used copper arsenic alloy, which was much softer. Furthermore Minoan swords were double cast: core copper with little arsenic and no antimony making it strong and tough, would not break, but soft. Skin of the sword had high arsenic and high antimony, giving it a razor sharp hard cutting edge. Minoa also had running water to every house using troughs built into cobblestone streets. And they had flush toilets: each toilet had a bucket used to flush. Not as advanced as a modern toilet, but more advanced than anything ancient Rome had 2,000 years later.

The Great Library of Alexandria was burnt on purpose. How much great literature and history was lost?

Fall of the Akkad empire in 2154 BC (4,177 years ago). The Akkad conquered the Sumerians and absorbed their writing system and culture.

We could go on. The belief that we hit the peak means fall back is inevitable. Civilization is not static, it either grows or collapses. Belief that our system has hit a limit is a self-fulfilling prophesy. Our population growth is slowing, will soon stop, but food production continues to improve. But more than half of agricultural land is marginal, would not support anything more than subsistence without industrial inputs. We have those inputs: nitrogen fertilizer is necessary for any crop of canola, on any land. Marginal land requires nitrogen and potash. It also requires tractors, combine harvesters, and trains to transport to a grain terminal that can dry it with either natural gas or propane. Fruit requires refrigeration to prevent spoilage. If our industrial economy collapses, all that industrial food production collapses with it.

Optimism isn't a luxury. It's necessary for life.

#13 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » A New Solution to the Fermi Paradox - A Universal Limit on Technology » 2024-10-09 13:08:34

Faster than light communication:
Quantum entanglement works by entangling a pair of subatomic particles or photons. Once entangled certain properties must be opposite. A pair of electrons will always have opposite spin. If you alter the spin of one, the other will change it's spin instantly. There is zero time delay. It's a mathematically exact number, exactly zero time. It doesn't matter the distance, propagation delay is always exactly zero time. Even over interstellar distance. In 1930 a paper published by Albert Einstein, Dr Podolsky, and Dr Rosen known as the EPR paper (their initio) tried to disprove quantum mechanics by saying this is absurd. But other have responded by saying this is brilliant! The EPR paper was based on the assumption of the principle of non-locallity. However that principle has been proven false so quantum mechanics is consistent. Good thing since quantum mechanics is required for modern electronics to work. So now it's an engineering design to develop an instantaneous communicator. Technically instantaneous is not faster than light. Speed is distance divided by time, real distance in zero time is a division by zero error. Quantum entanglement works without anything travelling across intervening distance.

Warp drive:
Nothing can move in space faster than the speed of light. But there's a loophole. Space itself can move at any speed. Warp drive works by contracting space in front of the ship, and stretching space behind it. This moves a bubble of space forward. The ship does not move relative to the bubble of space it is embedded within. Because the ship is not moving relative to the bubble, there is no time dilation.

Miguel Alcubierre wrote his doctoral thesis in 1994. It was amazing! He reverse calculated General Relativity. His initial paper required an object the size of Jupiter in front, and another object behind of equal mass but made of an exotic type of matter called negative matter that no one has been able to prove exists. This took warp drive from completely impossible to completely impractical. That was progress. Recently Dr Sonny White has published papers of how to energy optimize physicist Alcubierre Drive to be practical. His design would require a ship the size of Skylab, and no exotic matter. We launched Skylab so this sounds a lot better. He received funding from NASA and wrote two papers, linked below. Since he received funding from DARPA and built a laboratory experiment to make a static warp bubble. It worked. The bubble was microscopic, but it's a start. The warp bubble was confirmed by a laser. The catch is a ship would require so much power that only a nuclear fusion reactor could produce that much. A fission reactor would be too big and heavy. No one has developed a working fusion reactor, so more work is needed. Meanwhile Dr White is working on warp drive, powered by electrical power mains on land.

Warp Field Mechanics 101
Warp Field Mechanics 102:Energy Optimization

#14 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Fusion without vacuum » 2024-10-06 10:45:03

A fan is necessary to start the gas moving, then sustain movement with a RAM jet. Could be an interesting design. One side of the torus has the shock diamonds, creates fusion. But gas expansion only so far. Other side is a RAM jet, allowing gas expansion further through the RAM jet engine shape. After RAM jet gas expansion, the gas will have to be cooled. How much can electrodynamic dampening?

#15 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Fusion without vacuum » 2024-10-06 09:59:14

No, not "injecting". The torus recirculates gas because most gas does not fuse. The de Laval nozzle is the same as the throat and exhaust bell of a rocket nozzle, but acts as a jet engine in that gas recirculated gas goes through. You start with deuterium-tritium nuclear fusion because that's easiest to ignite, but energy of fusion causes recirculated gas to increase in temperature and speed. Once temperature of shock diamonds is hot enough, it will cause deuterium-deuterium fusion. That's harder to ignite and produces less energy but byproducts are tritium and Helium-3. So the fusion reactor makes its own tritium. And its own Helium-3. Shock diamonds will also cause deuterium-tritium and deuterium-helium3 fusion. The D-T and D-3He reactions will produce most of the energy.

A mass separator will remove helium-4. So waste is pure non-radioactive normal helium. As helium is removed, deuterium will be added. It doesn't need an injector, because shock diamonds are used to achieve fusion.

Gas will start as pure deuterium with a little tritium mixed in. No oxygen, no nitrogen, other gasses. As the reactor operates it will produce more tritium as well as helium-3 and helium-4. Remove helium-4 as it operates, but there will be some.

#16 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Fusion without vacuum » 2024-10-05 17:16:08

Nothing keeps atoms from the walls. It's a torus filled with gas. The nozzle accelerates has to supersonic speed, which is released into gas within the same torus. Gas surrounding the exhaust nozzle is moving subsonic. Supersonic exhaust into subsonic air produces the shock diamonds. Apex of the diamonds is what the diagram calls it a mach disk. Gas expansion cools gas so the subsonic gas is cooler than melting temperature of the chamber walls.

#17 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Fusion without vacuum » 2024-10-04 22:17:41

overexpansion.jpg
a4e67-d.jpg
Raptor shock diamonds:
images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTFjkqSRqaacYdm65qMbuzhwY0HXIYUrqPemPTYy7Jeiwf6LdBPKe8fcGMTpnC_M9Nz7Zw&usqp=CAU

Math:
If you double pressure absolute (pressure vs hard vacuum), then you double temperature in degrees Kelvin (degrees above absolute zero). One degree Kelvin equals one degree Celcius, but zero is moved to absolute zero. This means if we start with 300°K (26.85°C) then to achieve 15 million Kelvin requires increasing by 50,000 times. However, if we start with 1,000°K (726.85°C) then achieving the same result only requires increasing by 15,000 times. That means nozzle exit area to mach disk area must be a ratio of 15,000 to 1. Can we achieve this?

#18 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Fusion without vacuum » 2024-10-04 15:21:00

Yes, the contents of the chamber would be primarily Deuterium with a little Tritium. Initial fusion would be D-T because that has lowest ignition temperature and pressure. Use energy from that to increase temperature and pressure to ignite double Deuterium. Double-D reaction produces 1/10 the energy and is harder to ignite, but it's byproducts are what you need for the other reactions. So a bit of Tritium is used to "prime" the reaction, then it runs on Deuterium fuel. It produces all the Tritium and Helium-3 needed to sustain the reaction. 90% of energy produced by D-T and D-³He reactions.

But don't start with vacuum. Start with 1 atmosphere pressure. As it operates, heat will increase pressure further.

The idea is to operate with a dynamic gas flow that creates a very small but continuous volume of gas compression. Compress the gas at the shock diamond apex to achieve temperature and pressure necessary for fusion. Gas expands from there, and gas expansion causes cooling. So the only thing adjacent to fusing gas is more gas. Where gas touches chamber walls, gas temperature is cool enough that the chamber will not melt.

#19 Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Fusion without vacuum » 2024-10-04 12:24:17

RobertDyck
Replies: 14

Perhaps GW Johnson could help with this one. It involves fluid dynamics.

A torus aka donut shape. Hot gas deuterium with a little tritium flowing at high subsonic speed. A de Laval nozzle to convert flow to supersonic, and deliberately create shock diamonds. At the apex of the first diamond, ensure has is compressed to fusion ignition pressure and temperature. We're talking 15 million degrees Celsius. Since that's plasma, the shock diamonds could be contained in a magnetic field. But it's not a vacuum bottle. The Lawson Criteria also requires time. The shock diamond exhaust is then allowed to expand, causing thermodynamic gas expansion to cool. The gas would cool to a temperature where the chamber walls can contain it without melting. Only expect to achieve fusion temperature at the apex of the shock diamonds.

Fusion reactions:
²H + ³H → ⁴He + n
²H + ³He → ⁴He + p
²H + ²H → ³H + p (50%)
²H + ²H → ³He + n (50%)

So if apex temperature can get high enough for double deuterium reactions, other fuels are created. 90% of energy is generated by secondary reactions DT and D³He.

Could the torus use electromagnetic dampening to extract energy? And cool before directing gas back to the nozzle? Keep gas flowing fast by RAM jet effects? Extract a tiny bit of gas, use a mass separator to remove ⁴He. Recirculate everything else. Add deuterium as needed.

#20 Re: Not So Free Chat » Chat » 2024-09-30 10:46:30

There is a hospital. For major operations that cannot be handled here, they have air transport to Winnipeg. Jet aircraft from airport to airport.

They have a French immersion grade school, one school has 2 locations separated by 4 blocks. Another school. And an special school for aboriginal. Government has organized University College of the North, a remote campus of universities in Winnipeg. Not sure how it"s run, could be recorded lectures, simulcast lectures, local professors, or more likely a combination.

The city is connected to the province-wide power grid. Hydroelectric dams are up here and farther north. Long distance power lines deliver power to the south. Winnipeg Hydro built hydro dams in southeast Manitoba, but that was purchased by Manitoba Hydro. So there are some dams there too. Point is it was easy to connect this city.

They have water and sewage utilities, just don't know their details. They are connected to rail and highways. Thompson isn't remote enough to be the exception you're looking for.

Aboriginal reservations up north have no road, usually an airport with one crushed rock runway. The airport terminal building is the size of a double car garage. Construction materials delivered in winter by ice road. Do you know what an ice road is? They had telephone and satellite internet, but StarLink works much better.

#21 Re: Not So Free Chat » Chat » 2024-09-30 06:43:38

Yes, Thompson is a city. 3rd largest in this province, population 13,000. Yes, greater Winnipeg (city plus surrounding bedroom communities) has a population of 834,678 according to the 2021 census. One big city surrounded by farms and forest. The drive to Thompson is straight north at 100 km/h (62.1 mph). 8 hours by car but the bus stops every 2 hours for bathroom breaks, so 9 hours. Just north of Winnipeg are farms and small towns, but once into the Interlake (are between Lake Winnipeg and Lake Manitoba) it's forest. Two lane undivided highway, one lane each direction, with a gravel shoulder and ditch. Trees grow right up to the ditch so the highway is a cut through solid forest. First bathroom break is a town with paved roads. Second one is a gas station with restaurant and food store, surrounded by forest. Third stop is gravel with above ground fuel tanks and no building. If you have to take a leak, find a bush or something between you and the bus. But I'm in Thompson now, a mining city. Population has grown to 22,000 in the past when metal prices were high. This city does have an airport, small but does service jets and has a real terminal building. Walmart is just too cheap to fly me. It's summer, warm, but rainy today.

#22 Re: Not So Free Chat » Chat » 2024-09-30 06:25:49

Sorry, hadn't finished reading instructions. Just swap old scanner with new one. Old scanner has serial cable, new one is wireless and cradle is USB. I have to insert a battery. I don't think I can give you the technician's guide, but can give you the manufacturer manual.
PDF: DS8178 Digital Scanner Quick Start Guide

#23 Re: Not So Free Chat » Chat » 2024-09-29 19:37:00

Waiting for the bus again. Highway bus to Thompson MB. Overnight trip. Bus departs 9:30pm, arrives 6:30am. Work starts at Walmart 8:00am. Replacing the guts of hand scanners is not exactly rocket science. Pays the bills.

#24 Re: Terraformation » CO2 as a resource [associated with orbital assets] » 2024-09-28 11:38:42

Ps. Don't put servers in space. Put them on Earth with communication relay satellites in space. Again, maintenance is more practical.

#25 Re: Terraformation » CO2 as a resource [associated with orbital assets] » 2024-09-28 11:36:55

This discussion is about capturing CO2 and using it as a resource. The easiest way to do that is plants: trees, grass, food crops, algae in the sea, diatoms, etc. Trees can be harvested for lumber and paper. Hemp grows faster, has lots of uses.

The US Navy studied using Mars technology. The idea was use electric power from the nuclear reactor of an aircraft carrier. Capture CO2, split water in an electrolysis tank to form hydrogen and oxygen, then combine CO2 with hydrogen to form jet fuel. This would allow producing fuel for aircraft on the ship. Obviously fuel production would happen when the reactor is not needed to power the ship's propulsion.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB