New Mars Forums

Official discussion forum of The Mars Society and MarsNews.com

You are not logged in.

Announcement

Announcement: This forum is accepting new registrations via email. Please see Recruiting Topic for additional information. Write newmarsmember[at_symbol]gmail.com.

#176 Re: New Mars Articles » Last Chance To Download Mars Poster! - Free Mars Poster » 2005-05-06 20:24:07

Missing your input at the other threads here, Rik.
    Drop in more often!  smile

#177 Re: Unmanned probes » Cassini-Huygens - NASA/ESA Saturn orbiter & Titan lander » 2005-05-06 20:11:56

Cindy:-

Also looks like Victorian-style hair on a man, ..

    Yes, and it looks like he has a black eye, too. Perhaps he was just a little too 'forward' in pressing his attentions upon a demure young Victorian maiden .. and was given his just desserts!  big_smile

    And I see what you mean about the lack of clarity with those linear markings on Titan. It looks like a system of roads to me!  tongue

#178 Re: Unmanned probes » MPL "Landing" Site Identified?? » 2005-05-06 20:01:54

Very interesting stuff.
    I'm a little bit puzzled, though.
    If the rockets shut down some 40 metres above the surface, why is there such a distinct darkening of the soil around the probe, which has been attributed to rocket exhaust?
    It seems unlikely to me that the rocket exhaust could have affected the surface from 40 metres (130 feet) away. In such a thin atmosphere, the plume would surely have dissipated sideways within a very short distance of the rocket nozzle(?).
    Shouldn't the surface be undisturbed?
                                                       ???

#179 Re: Life support systems » Aerogel - don't build - your greenhouse w/o it » 2005-05-06 19:46:26

Interesting product.
    I note that it has countless small bubbles of air in it - in fact, it's 95% air and only 5% heat-conducting mass.
    I assume the air bubbles are at sea-level atmospheric pressure(?). If so, off-the-shelf Nanogel panelling probably wouldn't be suitable for greenhouses on the Moon or Mars, at least not in large sections, because the internal pressure would blow the polycarbonate external sheeting apart.

    It may well be possible, though, to manufacture the same product in 'Moon-rated' or 'Mars-rated' form. This would likely be achieved more easily in-situ, where the internal pressure of the panels would automatically match the external pressure.

#180 Re: Not So Free Chat » Political Potpourri IV - Continued from previous » 2005-05-06 19:22:34

My natural inclinations wouldn't be to vote for the British Labour Party anyhow.
    But Blair is one of the few nominal 'socialists' in world politics with the guts to do what's right. He's proved that in Iraq and you have to give him credit for it.
    It's only a pity that many among his natural constituency obviously lack his vision and testicular fortitude and have staged a backlash against him at the polls. Nevertheless, it's encouraging to see that he's been returned to power in spite of that.
   (Low percentage voting figures are normal for Britain, where voting isn't compulsory, by the way.)

    Moving on to less palatable news, Bulgaria is withdrawing its 460 troops from Iraq soon. They lost something like a half dozen soldiers to terrorist violence, and a few civilians as well unfortunately, and the resulting political pressure at home has forced the withdrawal.
    Like Spain before her, Bulgaria has succumbed to fear and weakness and is abandoning its Coalition allies and the Iraqi people at their time of need. Shame!

    It's also been announced that the Japanese military engineering contingent is to go home at Christmas. It is these same engineers that the additional 450 Australian troops were recently sent to Iraq to protect from terrorists. I was afraid the Japanese withdrawal might prompt Australia to pull out its extra troops too. But, happily, the Aussie government has declared that those soldiers will be assigned to other vital tasks and will complete their planned tour of duty.
    Refreshing determination and adherence to the job in hand .. well done, Australia! And well done John Howard.  smile

    Kudos to America, most of all though, for its magnificent performance in Iraq in the face of appalling behaviour by the mindless murderers they have had to contend with. I am constantly in awe of the courage and generosity of the American people who have done so much to help so many of us for so long. A perfect country? No way .. not by any means! But the world would be so much the worse without her.  :up:

    On an upbeat note, Al-Qa'ida's third-in-command has recently been arrested in Pakistan, I believe, and has 'spilled the beans' about much of Bin Laden's network. There's even been some optimistic talk about soon capturing Bin Laden himself. We can only hope.
                                                               smile

#181 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Heliopolis *2* - ...Sun, Solar Science Cont'd... » 2005-05-06 18:35:48

Cindy:-

:laugh:  That's another thing I love about Sol:  The unpredictability factor.

    Yeah, just as long as it doesn't give us any really big surprises we can't handle!  I kinda prefer old Sol to be nice and sedate and steady.  yikes [ big_smile  ]

#182 Re: Intelligent Alien Life » what do you think aliens would look like? - like what color, how tall.....etc. » 2005-05-06 18:27:31

Thanks for the warning, people. I'll look out for those programs.  :up:

    It's an interesting mental exercise to imagine what forms life might take in different environments. Being a Mars nut from way back, of course, I've often considered the plight of animals which might have evolved on Mars in the early days, when conditions were favourable, only to find themselves confined to ever-shrinking ecological niches as the climate worsened.
    If the conditions changed slowly enough, it's possible to imagine any such creatures adapting and changing their physiology to suit. But how tenacious can life be? Could macroscopic multicellular animal life adapt sufficiently to survive the freezing, near-vacuum, virtually oxygen-free environment we find on Mars today?

    Apparently, Dr. Carl Sagan was prepared to believe it possible. In the design stage of the Viking landers, it was seriously considered that the probes might detect the movement of some of the 'rocks' on the surface - the idea being that some animals could have developed rocky exoskeletons to shield themselves from the intense U.V. light and the low temperatures. Sagan even wanted lights fitted to the landers, so the cameras could pick up the activities of any nocturnal creatures!

    As it happened, of course, no Martian animals were detected. But I still wonder whether they might be there somewhere, in more sheltered regions than the open wind-swept plains the Vikings landed on.
    I imagine things like small arthropods, crab-like creatures living in the depths of Mariner Valley or Hellas Basin, perhaps relying on symbiotic cyano-bacteria for their oxygen and a hypersaline cellular medium to ward off freezing. They might hide in underground burrows most of the time, when it's cold, and appear on the surface only briefly, when the Sun warms the sand and transient thin films of liquid water are possible.

    Then again, maybe there are no such things!  tongue   :laugh:
    But it's entertaining to speculate.

#184 Re: Water on Mars » Marsis to probe for subsurface water » 2005-05-06 04:35:00

Hop:-

There's some evidence of Martian volcanic activity in the recent (geologically speaking) past. I believe it likely there is liquid water near the surface of Mars.

    Yes. I think Mars is more volcanically active than it's given credit for. And I wouldn't be surprised if liquid water still exists in large near-surface aquifers, too.
    I find it very exciting, m

#185 Re: Water on Mars » Salty -and- Fresh Water? » 2005-05-06 04:26:21

Without wishing to labour the point unnecessarily, I found a nice image of the Martian dendritic drainage formations I mentioned:-

    MARSDRAINAGE.GIF

    The text accompanying the image states:-

Mariner 9 and Viking Orbiter imagery, however, revealed networks of interconnecting dry river beds that exhibited dendritic (from the Greek, meaning "treelike") drainage patterns characteristic of water-carved channels. This is the strongest evidence that Mars was once a warmer and wetter place with sufficient atmospheric pressure to retain liquid water on or near the surface. [Scene is 160 kilometers across, Viking Orbiter image 606A56, centered at 42.5°S 92.6°W. Image processing by Brian Fessler (Lunar and Planetary Institute).]

    This text is somewhat conservative in that it doesn't mention the possibility of precipitation having been responsible for the drainage pattern. However, I have certainly seen this kind of Martian terrain associated with  rainfall by some authorities in other accounts.

    My own simple investigations reveal that the region pictured above lies on the South-South-Eastern border of the Tharsis Bulge, at an altitude of some 8 kms above Datum. In conjunction with the fact that the surface of Lake Ma'adim was some 2-3 kms above Datum, I think this altitude is significant.
    Both these facts indicate that liquid water could exist for prolonged periods at considerable altitudes above the Martian equivalent of sea-level. This implies the existence of a much more massive atmosphere and a warmer environment than we see today on Mars.
    And I think it implies there was once a great deal of fresh water on Mars as well as the salty water Opportunity has found solid evidence for.

    I can hardly wait for the deployment of the Mars Express Ground-Penetrating Radar ( let's hope it goes well ) because it may make a profound contribution to the revolution in knowledge about Mars already instigated by NASA's magnificent Rovers.
                                                       :up:   smile

#186 Re: Human missions » Artificial Gravity » 2005-05-06 01:34:55

RMB:-

If you have doubts about whether a spinning motion could simulate gravity ..

    No. I don't think any of us were in doubt.

#187 Re: Not So Free Chat » Fate and happiness » 2005-05-06 01:17:42

MadGrad:-

We all have the power to intimately affect our futures and find happiness.

    Someone said you don't have to find your happiness, you only have to declare it.
    Apparently it's a state of mind and it's all up to you.

    If Schrodinger's cat can be alive or dead just by the fact of our observing it, then it makes sense that we can surely be happy or sad just by the fact of our declaring it. It's simple quantum mechanics

#188 Re: Unmanned probes » MOC Continued » 2005-05-05 23:31:06

Excellent pictures!  :up:
    The Martian Analemma was fascinating. A spearhead Analemma, eh? Very suitable for the god of war.  :;):
    Loved the last dust storm picture. I can just imagine how much more dynamic the climate system will be on Mars when we start raising the atmospheric density.  smile

#189 Re: Human missions » Artificial Gravity » 2005-05-05 22:12:13

GCNR:-

Even with no more then excercise, Russian Cosmonauts have climbed and walked out of their Soyuz capsule after a zero-G length of stay almost as long as the entire time a Mars crew would be gone.

    I seem to remember cosmonauts being carried from their craft after 12 or 13 months in orbit (?). What if we add an 18 month interval at 0.38g into the middle of a similar period in zero-g, going to and from Mars?
    No. I think I'm just going to have to agree to disagree with you on this one.

    Incidentally, I'm still intrigued by your reference to this:-
   "As long as they have a little gravity, the body's "self destruct" isn't triggerd .. "
    Does this mean a prolonged stay on Mars, or even Luna, won't trigger bone loss? I'm genuinely interested in seeing any research articles about this that you may have come across.
    Thanks.  smile

#190 Re: Not So Free Chat » Apropos of Nothing *4* » 2005-05-05 21:48:25

MadGrad:-

So... am I officially crazy yet?

    Umm ... yep!  big_smile
    Or you may just be a cross-dresser and don't know it yet.

    Either way, the world is your oyster.   :laugh:

[Don't .. repeat .. Don't let this go to your head, but you're one smart 16 year-old. All intelligence is relevant (equally valuable) and relative, so beware of judging intelligence - it's just too difficult and I've rarely known it to achieve anything worthwhile anyway. But, having said that, as intelligence goes, I think you're very intelligent!  smile 
    Plus .. I think you should try and get out more.  big_smile ]

#191 Re: Not So Free Chat » Political Potpourri IV - Continued from previous » 2005-05-05 21:22:22

Cindy:-

Interesting that both he and Mr. Bush won re-election (if indeed Blair wins again) after such intense opposition to the Iraqi war and no WMD's found (yet).  I expected them both to be voted -out- of office by a rather wide margin.

    Yes, and Australia's John Howard, like George W. Bush in America, was returned with an increased majority, despite all the media hype about how unpopular the liberation of Iraq was supposed to be with the masses.

    Is it possible that what you hear in the media is more the voice of the media than the voice of the people? Spin it any way you like but three election victories by three 'warmongering political pariahs' .. it makes you wonder, doesn't it?
                                                      smile

#192 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Earth Atmospherics/Weather » 2005-05-05 20:52:15

Cindy:-

A few bands of high, thin clouds looked more silver than white.  The city was still, everything hushed.

    Ah yes.
    I've seen nights just like that. Fairy tale stuff that even Walt Disney can't match. It almost makes you ache to witness its surreal beauty - familiar things seen in an unfamiliar, seemingly alien, light. Another world indeed.
    Magic!   smile

#193 Re: Human missions » Artificial Gravity » 2005-05-05 17:57:02

GCNR:-

I think that they can probobly be just fine for the round trip without artifical gravity on either inbound or outbound leg. As long as they have a little gravity, the body's "self destruct" isn't triggerd and the skelaton shouldn't weaken, so then the concern is the muscular/cardiovascular systems, which can be maintained by excercize. Plus, if the crews are going to be working outside in heavy suits much of the time, then their effective weight won't be much different then Earth.

    Your comment about even "a little gravity" sufficing to prevent loss of skeletal strength is interesting. I didn't know that. This information will serve to allay many fears about the maintenance of healthy human physiology on the Moon and Mars. Excellent news!
     Can you direct me to a site which compares gravitational acceleration with bone loss over time?

    Despite this good news you've mentioned, I still have serious reservations about the cardiovascular systems of our astronauts. I'm no physician, by the way, but it worries me that the blood is so much easier to pump around the body if it's weightless, or is only 38% of its usual weight. Even if the astronauts spent all their time exercising vigorously, their hearts will be having an extended vacation from the stress of pumping 'heavy' blood around the body. And also, many of the muscles which are constantly in use in 1g, such as the neck muscles and various other postural muscles, will not be exercised (or not exercised sufficiently), despite your gym regime.
    It seems likely to me that any human in zero-g for 6 months, 0.38g for 18 months, then back in zero-g for another 6 months, will have grave difficulties adjusting to 1g at the end of it.

And, frankly, your suggestion sounds like another desperate try to save the fatally flawed MarsDirect ..

    I haven't entered into the fray regarding Mars Direct to any great extent because I don't feel comfortable arguing strongly about spacecraft masses and mission feasibility. I haven't the appropriate engineering background to make sensible comments - beyond the ones I've made above, which I notice you've rejected anyway. (I didn't find that surprising, by the way.) But I'd be interested to see Dr. Zubrin himself engage you in a debate regarding the figures you dispute.
    Nevertheless, I don't think you need either an engineering or medical degree to foresee serious health issues if we don't provide gravity for a Mars Direct based mission of the kind of duration we're talking about.

    My point is much more to emphasize what I see as the necessity of artificial gravity, and finding ways to provide it, than to defend Mars Direct, as such.
    I'm concerned that you seem, at least to me, to find any number of ways to decry plans to get humans to Mars. There are always many more problems than answers in your posts and I find that unhelpful. (Right or wrong, that's the feeling I get.)
    America got where it is today on quite a different premise; a 'can do' premise that a tired Old World found refreshing and invigorating. By all means, let's be realistic about the difficulties of manned Mars exploration and colonization, but do we have to be so damned pessimistic all the time?
                                                            ???   smile

#194 Re: Water on Mars » Salty -and- Fresh Water? » 2005-05-05 06:47:04

Cindy:-

I'm more interested in the possibility of -fresh- water having once been present on Mars.

    It's an interesting question.
    Of course, we've all known for some time now that salty water once flowed on Mars, so I won't insult your intelligence by dwelling too long on that aspect of it.
    (In passing, I imagine that one of the most important factors in the concentration of salts in water on Mars would be the length of time any oceans may have persisted and how long any rivers existed to wash eroded minerals into them.
    Another factor would be the concentration of minerals in certain bodies of water due to evaporation, of course; as discovered by Opportunity at Meridiani.)

    Something that's always fascinated me is that there are dendritic drainage networks all over the ancient cratered southern highlands of Mars. Although described by geologists as 'immature' networks, lacking the well-developed characteristics exhibited by similar networks here on Earth, it is widely suspected they may have been carved by the runoff of precipitation billions of years ago.
    Then you have to consider the existence of enormous lakes in the southern highlands, like Lake Ma'adim:

  press_lakest.jpg

    ... which is estimated to have held more than 5 times as much water as the present-day Great Lakes of North America. Calculations suggest the lake had a surface area of some 1.1 million square kilometres and a depth of 1100 metres!
    On a topical note, it was this lake which overflowed into Ma'adim Vallis and fed the Gusev Crater Lake, whose sediments NASA's Spirit Rover is investigating as we speak. (See the topmost blue-filled crater in the above picture.)

    It seems likely to me that Lake Ma'adim, whose distinct shoreline has been identified and mapped, was a freshwater lake, perhaps fed by precipitation during an early epoch or by freshwater aquifers in a later era.
    The northern wall of Gusev Crater was breached at some stage in the past, perhaps by water erosion, and it's not difficult to imagine the water streaming northward into the lowlands. There it may well have become part of a saltier longer-standing body of oceanic water(?)

    I can't prove Lake Ma'adim was filled with fresh water, of course. It's more of a hunch. But it may well be that Spirit's current analysis of a rocky outcrop dubbed 'Methuselah', in the Columbia Hills of Gusev Crater, will soon be giving us definitive information one way or the other.

    Isn't it just wonderful stuff?!!!   :up:   smile

::Edit::  I know I've waxed lyrical about Lake Ma'adim before. Apologies to those who have tired of my enthusiasm for it.  smile

#195 Re: Human missions » Some Corrective Lenses II - ...hmmm, another corrupt thread » 2005-05-05 06:00:32

Iron loses its magnetic properties if you heat it up beyond a certain temperature because the ordered arrangement of its atoms is broken down. I can't remember the exact temperature at which this occurs but I'm pretty sure molten iron isn't magnetic.

#196 Re: Human missions » Artificial Gravity » 2005-05-05 04:56:57

GCNR:-

...humans can handle a 5-6mo trip in zero-G all the way.

    Yes they certainly can handle a 6-month zero-g trip to Mars.
    The question is, can they handle 6 months in zero-g, 18 months in 0.38g, 6 more months in zero-g, and then a sudden return to 1g (after 2.5 years)?
    My guess is no, they can't.

The biggest problems I think are the damage that would be sustained from the sudden change in dynamics... for the ship or the crew... if the cable were to break.

    Sure. Big problem. But why should the cable break?
    Why not worry about a large meteor impact?
    What if you have a car crash ... what if your airbag doesn't deploy?
    What if you have a heart attack tomorrow?
    Why don't we just make a reasoned evaluation of the risks and understand that the rotation-cable breaking on the trip to Mars is an extremely low risk?

Thirdly, communication with Earth would be difficult, since you could not so easily align a high-gain directional antenna with Earth

    Have a small communications pod, with antennae, on the cable, at the centre of gravity. It would have no problem aiming toward Earth.

Fourthly, all parts of the vehicle must resist the 0.3G acceleration deployed. That means no light weight extendable radiators, solar pannels, or radio antennas. How are you going to get power when spinning? ...One of the many failings of MarsDirect that Bob glosses over I think.

    Put the solar panels on the centre-of-gravity pod, too. And, with the modules rotating once per minute, or faster, heat build-up should be controllable.

Fifthly, if you are using an NTR engine for upper stage & escape burn, like MarsDirect would need to have sensible mass margins ..

    If we have comfortable 1g living quarters for the trip, by utilizing centripetal force, do we need to use an NTR for a faster trip? Why not increase our margins by taking a month longer to get there?
    Admittedly, the less time in interplanetary space, the less the radiation dose. But I believe radiation is a far lesser danger to the crew and the mission than the deleterious  effects of bone and muscle wasting during 12 months in zero-g and 18 months in 0.38g. And then there's the PR disaster of astronauts being dragged off the ERV, incapacitated, on stretchers and life-support.

    Just a few thoughts to counter GCNR's regular doom-and-gloom scenarios.   big_smile   smile
[No offence GCNR, but your pessimism and tut-tutting can get depressing at times. No doubt you call it 'realism'.  big_smile  ]

#197 Re: Water on Mars » Salty -and- Fresh Water? » 2005-05-05 04:19:27

Yes, indeed, Robert.
    These are exciting times for Martian exploration as more and more fundamental questions are answered.  :up:
[ Welcome to New Mars by the way.  smile  ]

#198 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Earth Atmospherics/Weather » 2005-05-05 04:12:47

Cindy:-

Why the heck was this guy out at the god-awful hour of 2:00 a.m.??

     :laugh:  Might help explain why I've seen so few moonbows.

#199 Re: Terraformation » Provide the Moon with atmosphere - oxygen one » 2005-05-04 18:18:36

Hi Karov!
    I don't disagree in principle with your reasoning on planetary engineering. We differ only in terms of technological feasibility, time-frame, and maybe the desirability of the schemes you describe.
    You think big! You describe a time when investment in spa

#200 Re: Terraformation » Provide the Moon with atmosphere - oxygen one » 2005-05-04 17:32:59

A warm welcome to New Mars, Benlinliu.
    Don't worry about the language problem.
    I think your English is good and your meaning is clear enough.  smile

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB