New Mars Forums

Official discussion forum of The Mars Society plus New Mars Image Server

You are not logged in.

Announcement

Announcement: This forum is accepting new registrations via email. Please see Recruiting Topic for additional information. Write newmarsmember[at_symbol]gmail.com.
  1. Index
  2. » Search
  3. » Posts by Terraformer

#1 Re: Terraformation » Creating a (small) Lunar atmosphere » 2026-02-14 18:23:41

Such an atmosphere may also protect against micrometeorites, which would otherwise scuff up any lunar greenhouses we build. A useful tool for paraterraforming. Doable with a very thin atmosphere iirc. Like 0.1mb would do, or even less.

#2 Re: Life support systems » Phosphorus and Elements to Support Life » 2026-02-14 17:32:07

See also lunar KREEP. There's Potassium and Phosphate up there. Tbh I'd expect lunar rocks to have what we need, since it's made of the same stuff as Earth's crust and what would have boiled away. Iodine remains a potential difficulty; on Earth it is concentrated by various means. Mars and the ocean worlds might have it.

Worth considering that plants could accumulate elements that are at very low concentrations. Maybe we plant forests explicitly for this purpose.

#3 Re: Martian Politics and Economy » Creating the Cis-Lunar economy » 2026-02-13 12:57:24

Now that SpaceX is pivoting towards Luna first, and have proven rockets with more on the way, and a network of comm sats, and can launch humans into space and bring them back alive, this is a topic worth revisiting. How much *now* to set up a base? How much to start industrialising? What launch options for getting off Luna?

#4 Re: Human missions » space x going to the moon instead of mars » 2026-02-13 07:54:22

Mars may end up being the cheapest place to get elements such as copper and tin and silver for in space manufacturing. Ores only form on planets with hydrogeological processes that can concentrate them. That means Earth and maybe/likely Mars.

In the meantime, we'll have to haul them up from Earth, but fortunately Luna can provide nearly all the mass we need. Maybe even meteoric nickel-iron. And unlike Mars, it has a possible business case for mining, tourism, research, and orbital support services. Which are the reasons humans live in inhospitable Terran environments today. Though, given his haste, Musk may have a Fallen Angels scenario on his mind, where the bulk of humanity turn against space travel and there are only the people up there already to carry the flame to other worlds. A few thousand people should be viable genetically at least, especially given how highly selected they'd be. He may also have an Elysium scenario in mind too, given the talk of using orbital datacentres for the next great economic leap...

Once we have manufacturing on Luna we can start sending sollettas and iron nanorods to Mars, warm the place up somewhat before we get there.

#5 Re: Human missions » space x going to the moon instead of mars » 2026-02-10 09:55:21

Luna has a potential business case, with mining, tourism, research, support services and goods for orbit.  Mars, does not. Luna also has plentiful solar power without an atmosphere to interfere.

With lunar railguns and refining, we can construct hulls for the big ships from space resources, and fuel them up with lunar oxygen. Also have the possibility of tethers with lunar rock for counterweights, maybe made of lunar basalt.

Shackleton City should be laid out on a hexagonal plan. Tesselated domes.

#6 Re: Not So Free Chat » Politics » 2026-02-07 12:32:09

The private rape gang inquiry, organised and ran by Rupert Lowe MP (Great Yarmouth), is turning up and gathering quite a bit on the atrocities committed against native British girls - not just grooming and rape, trafficking also - by organised Pakistani community networks. It's... quite a lot. Not just the fact that so many in that community knew and facilitated it -- if we were to imprison or deport everyone who bears some responsibility, we'd almost certainly be accused of ethnic cleansing. But perhaps worse for the state is that it wasn't merely neglecting its duty to protect these girls, but actively assisting the rape networks and ensuring the girls could not be removed from their grasp. It's existential; the state is rapidly losing legitimacy and will have to rely solely on raw force if they don't pivot and root this rot out (they will not pivot and root this rot out).

#7 Re: Not So Free Chat » Cost-Effective Credible National Defense » 2026-02-04 06:02:17

Sounds like piston aircraft work for defense, turbines for attack from a distance (need the speed)?

Another area where piston aircraft should be viable is close air support / counter insurgency. Jet powered aircraft are used currently, but the speeds aren't above what you say piston engines can do.

#8 Re: Not So Free Chat » Copper, Silver, and other Metals » 2026-02-04 05:45:49

Maybe half of copper use can be substituted with aluminium. Cabling appears to be doable, motors and transformers not really. That still leaves a massive shortfall if the entirety of humanity is to be brought up to a western standard of living, quite apart from any additional electrification... there are resources, but the grade is really low, so I won't be surprised if it ends up overtaking nickel in value.

Silver has settled somewhat, or at least is creeping upwards *relatively* slowly compared to its spike; I expect it will end up around $2.80-3.00 per gram. Quite a bit more than the $0.8-0.9 I paid for 54g back in 2013 that I need to sort out my access to (BullionVault).

FWIW the copper prices mean the pre 92 british copper coins (actual copper) are worth 2.5-3x their face value. Of course, meddling with the coinage is illegal in Britain. Key part there being "in Britain".

#9 Re: Not So Free Chat » Peter Zeihan again: and also other thinkers: » 2026-02-01 12:52:40

Silver! The price still hasn't caught up to the end of the gold standard. Historical silver:gold price ratios were 10-15, until countries moved off silver and on to gold alone for their currency. Still a ways to go for it to correct back to such ratios, but I expect it will, particularly since it has useful industrial properties.

#10 Re: Not So Free Chat » Politics » 2026-01-31 17:16:23

Looking over at Iran, wondering when the panic buying starts. Filled up my tank just in case. There were people there with containers to fill, petrol not diesel, so you're capped at 30L unless you notify the fire service. Diesel has no such limits because a spark won't cause an inferno.

In domestic news, looking forward to the Manchester by-election. Not unlikely Reform take it, causing much wailing and gnashing of teeth. Fun times, though St George's Day could be funner. Depends on how many more girls get raped by dinghymen between now and then, perhaps.

#11 Not So Free Chat » Copper, Silver, and other Metals » 2026-01-30 13:14:57

Terraformer
Replies: 4

Easing off now, but copper price has spiked quite high.Pre 92 two/pennies are worth far more than their face value, like 2.5-3x. Silver peaked at $3.80 per gram -- https://goldtrack.io/silver. Copper hit $13.53/kg.

It's starting to sink in I think that electrifying everything requires metals, which requires mining, which requires ores high grade enough to be worth mining. Ores we uh don't have. Copper is useful enough I think that we'd still mine it if the only source cost $100/kg, but we couldn't use it liberally. Aluminum is going up too, naturally.

?u=https%3A%2F%2Fcarboncredits.com%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2024%2F12%2FCopper-inventory-and-price-chart.png&f=1&nofb=1&ipt=bf5a3cf863379711c4abff93987b65aab4a5e009bfa2228a5c2ab93eda1efe8b

#12 Re: Not So Free Chat » Politics » 2026-01-29 13:41:21

So any competant nation could build a workable car of good quality.  Just maybe without all of the superfluous electronics.

Britain, the country of the Henry Hoover and creator of The Best Plug In The World, should be all over this. Amongst other ruggedised simple equipment.

#14 Re: Exploration to Settlement Creation » Pedestrian Martian Cities » 2025-11-08 07:41:11

I have suggested before that hexagonal blocks would be a good design for a Lunar city. Can fit a circular pressure wall sandwiched between two layers of radiation shielding, and the blocks tesselate so the city can be expanded without creating expanses of empty space between blocks. Some blocks allocated as parks. Can be different heights -- imagine a central block being redeveloped with a tower.

#15 Re: Not So Free Chat » Zaanse Schaanes Windmill Museum, Holland. » 2025-11-08 07:30:42

Canals! They still use them in the Netherlands. In Britain we prefer to move rocks via the roads, in big heavy trucks that block the road.

#16 Re: Not So Free Chat » Chat » 2025-09-12 08:31:13

Finally have a loicense to drive my car. Yay! No more reliance on overpriced underreliable trains that get hit with the ocassional wildcat strike!

#17 Re: Not So Free Chat » Google BARD now Gemini AI competitor for ChatGPT » 2025-08-16 08:15:31

Can it draw a 12 of Hearts yet?

The thing with AI so far, that precludes it being AGI, is there's no integration. It's not an expert in multiple fields it's multiple experts in a trenchcoat. Grok can tell you what a 12 of Hearts card would look like, but if you ask it to draw one it puts 15 hearts on, or 14, or 11. It's not capable of combining e.g. language and visuals in the way a human can do intuitively. Or, for that matter, combining different fields of knowledge to generate insights. Still a stochastic parrot.

Which, you know, is still pretty powerful. A person with a good grounding in multiple fields now has experts on tap, so their ability to synthesise knowledge has massively improved. The human brings the intuition, the AI brings the knowledge.

#18 Re: Not So Free Chat » Oil, Peak Oil, etc. » 2025-08-15 09:28:40

Depends where you are. Cheapest is probably going to be solar (thermal) in deserts. Best for Britain, if not nuclear then wind, though possibly low temp solar thermal in summer for interseasonal storage.

There are a lot of energy intensive industries that could be located near deserts. Aluminum refining, for example. Glass making. Smelting with electrolysed hydrogen? Australia has a lot of the raw resources and a big desert for providing the power.

#19 Re: Not So Free Chat » Oil, Peak Oil, etc. » 2025-08-15 05:18:40

Well, in Spaniards example its more "suppose a farmer expends an average of 3000 calories to get 3300". Enough to survive, but he's living at subsistence level and survival is the only thing he can do.

#20 Re: Not So Free Chat » Oil, Peak Oil, etc. » 2025-08-14 04:25:14

Spaniard,

If energy use is roughly proportional to economic activity, having to use half your energy to rebuild your energy infrastructure means half your economic activity is dedicated to energy production. We haven't been in this situation since... the British Agricultural Revolution? If it's fully automated luxury gay space communism I guess that's manageable, since the robots are doing all the work. Though in the case of solar you're going to be taking up a lot of land if you need to devote most of it to making more solar panels.

Tbh, it doesn't seem unlikely that, with decent thermal storage and a focus on using power when it is generated, as well as a good wind power generation supply, biofuel would be enough to cover the small amount of mechanical/electrical power that needs to be generated on demand. A fair few energy intensive tasks can be made intermittent to run on wind, including I would expect grinding and crushing processes. Desalination, too. Britain has 5GW of nuclear still, and that would be enough for the domestic grid if we picked the low hanging fruit for intermittent power use (large tanks of hot water, including kettles; appliances that use the hot water supply instead of heating water with electricity; not running the tumble dryer if it's an expensive electricity day).

#21 Re: Not So Free Chat » Heatlth Extension/Life Extension, on Earth or for Space » 2025-08-08 09:38:45

Loss of bioavailable lithium implicated in Alzheimers Disease.

Tracks with high natural lithium water levels being associated with reduced dementia prevalance. Could be that we've almost all been deficient in it -- like the Swiss used to be with iodine (developed goiter as a consequence). Levels it has an effect at are far below therapeutic doses for bipolar. Probably a good idea tonstart supplementing.

#22 Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Invelox Wind Turbine » 2025-08-06 14:27:02

Terraformer
Replies: 4

Wind turbine that uses a shroud to catch wind and channel it to a ground level turbine.

Invelox website

t4.jpg

Safer for wildlife, and presumably not as top heavy. A potential contender for floating wind generation?

#23 Re: Science, Technology, and Astronomy » Carnot Heat Engine - Quantum Physics.- Related News » 2025-08-01 05:16:30

I think they're all right, in some universe or another wink


My understanding of it is that time is symmetrical -- its not (just) alternate futures forming the multiverse, but also alternate pasts, and when you don't observe a specific past they all happen and overlap with each other. So the electron went through the right slit AND the left slit, and the two universes where that is the sole difference are close enough to each other to interfere and generate an interference pattern. Whereas if you observe one, you collapse it down to a definite past, and the pattern disappears.

#24 Re: Not So Free Chat » Oil, Peak Oil, etc. » 2025-07-29 14:05:34

Void,

Colocating demand might reduce the necessary building out of the grid, but aside from the transformers the grid is built of steel and aluminum, both very abundant metals. You're still going to need a lot of copper.

#25 Re: Terraformation » Shell Worlds » 2025-07-22 15:49:27

The goal here would be to create marine environments that are comparable to earth, perhaps as nature preserves.

  1. Index
  2. » Search
  3. » Posts by Terraformer

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB