You are not logged in.
China's figure of 3245 is just like a flu. There were 3433 deaths in the USA from the H1N1 pandemic flu in 2009.
The USA was not put into lockdown in 2009.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_flu_ … by_country
The experience in Italy does seem odd. You have one region with over 1600 deaths and one with no deaths at all. Lombardy is hugely affected.
You have to ask also why Italy has been hit so hard compared with other European countries. If this was a simple matter of jet airliner spread you'd probably expect the Netherlands, France and UK to be the hotspots. Also, is there something amiss with the treatment regime - I've seen photos from Italy of beds quite close together in group wards in temporary hospitals. Is that just a recipe for spreading viruses on the air from one patient to another? I don't know. Were the Chinese isolating individual patients more effectively?
Edited to add:
It Italy's death toll were translated into Chinese population figures, that would be a death toll of over 60,000. Of course that would still be quite small for country like China where probably something like 10 million people die every year.
Quaoar wrote:tahanson43206 wrote:For Quaoar re whether one person can make a difference ...
Avigan is just arrived in Italian hospitals. I hope it will work. Today we have lost 427 people, reaching 3405 death and surpassing China, whose death toll is 3245 (not exactly just like a flu, as many great minds still think).
For China is not just like a flu: 3245 is a limited toll compared to the overall population, but they reach it by completely locking down the entire country. If not they would have likely lost millions of people.
Lombardy is the Italian epicenter, now the virus is spreading to other regions, which fortunately were put in lock down before the arrive of the viral tsunami. In the next days we will see if this strategy works or not. If not we will see an outcome similar to Lombardy and it will be a complete disaster because southern regions has not a healthcare system as efficient as the lombard one.
Tomorrow the Army will patrol the street to enforce the lock down.
In Italy medical first aids are overcrowded even in good times, due to insufficient medical personal. So, when patient one (the man called Mattia whom I talked about in one of my previous post) went to the medical first aid of Codogno (near Milan) with a strong cough, he spent 36 hours waiting in a very crowded room, were he infected hundreds of other waiting patients, who in their turn infected other people.
That was the unfortunate series of events which made Lombardy the Italian epicenter.
Had Mattia tested immediately and isolated, this tragic outcome could've been avoided.
For Quaoar re whether one person can make a difference ...
Avigan has just arrived in Italian hospitals. I hope it will work. Today we have lost 427 people, reaching 3405 death and surpassing China, whose death toll is 3245 (not exactly just like a flu, as many great minds still think).
In the UK we have 676 new cases today and deaths have risen 33 to 137. To put that in context, in January, before any confirmed Covid19 cases, we had an excess mortality of over 2000 compared with January 2019. That's an excess mortality average of 64 deaths per day in January, compared to the 33 we had today. No one seemed at all troubled by that excess mortality in January. Remember that most of the "Covid19" deaths will be respitory failure and if you examine the patients' lungs, you'll find lost of other opportunistic viruses there. There is no particular reason to label all these deaths as being caused by Covid 19.
I don't even know if there is excess mortality this month - we will have to wait and see.
It's been a very wet winter in the UK, so the dampness, and people getting cold in the damp probably explains the excess mortality in January.
We are now going into a full lockdown creating a lot of anxiety everywhere as people lose jobs, income and become socially isolated. People will die as a result.
Ok. We'll talk again about it in ten days.
Today is my 11th day of "house arrest". I'm the one to go outside to buy food so, being potentially exposed, I keep myself separate from my family (fortunately my home is quite big). I'm confined in two rooms with Mr. Spock (my black cat) and every day is the same. I'm losing the track of time.
In Rome fortunately we have drinkable tap water, from ancient Roman aqueducts still working (our ancestors were great engineers). At the moment there is no food shortage. There are very long lines in front of supermarkets, but it takes little time to enter in little food stores, which are just a bit more expensive.
Yesterday I went to the butcher to buy some meat. We were allowed to enter one at time in the store, so I waited some time in front of it. There were only two people before me and we kept about five meters of distance. The street was deserted except a group of young joggers. An old lady reproached them. They laughed and ran away.
I felt sad they were unable to perceive the danger.
Then it was my turn and I entered the store. The scaffold was full of meet. I bought some beef stew for the goulash and some bread, then quickly went back home.
"plenty of young and (formerly) healthy people"
Really? Let's see the evidence. No underlying health conditions, known or hidden?
Many younger people damage their lungs through habitual marijuana smoking: "Smoking marijuana clearly damages the human lung. Research shows that smoking marijuana causes chronic bronchitis and marijuana smoke has been shown to injure the cell linings of the large airways, which could explain why smoking marijuana leads to symptoms such as chronic cough, phlegm production, wheeze and acute bronchitis."
https://www.lung.org/stop-smoking/smoki … ealth.html
However, they might not be aware of the damage they have done. But something like a new opportunistic virus might exploit their vulnerability in a few cases.
I'm not arguing people, especially those with pre-existing lung conditions, shouldn't take reasonable precautions (washing hands, not going to crowded places etc). But I am arguing we cannot destroy our economies, create huge personal misery, just to save a few people who are likely to die very soon in any case.
I exposed the facts.
I's a fatal misconception that covid-19 only kills people who are about to die for other reasons.
You are free to think the hundreds of young adults under mechanical ventilation are all drug-addicts and you are invulnerable, but as I'm writing this post, in cities like Bergamo the crematory ovens are saturated and columns of military trucks are bringing the bodies to ovens outside the region.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/articl … mated.html
Please, don't underestimate the enemy
I don't believe you read that report on Modern Slavery in Italy otherwise you would not have made the absurd claim that Italian nationals are working to the same conditions as the Chinese gang labourers: do Italian nationals really sleep in carboard cubicles on the factory premises - of course not. But you seem to be determined to deny, deny and deny - just like our mainstream media are denying any connection.
I believe in modern slavery in Italy, but now the modern slaves came mainly from Africa and Pakistan, and the gangs are not only Chinese but also Nigerian, Albanian, Romanian and (mainly) Italian.
As regard the Italian workers, they sleep at their home but they wake up at five o'clock and spend hours in very crowded buses to reach the factories, where they work overtime, side by side without masks (which are unavailable), and even if they have some fever or cough, they very often hide their illness fearing to lose the job. It's not enough?
I'm coming to the view that we may be in the middle of one of the great mass hysterias of all time.
I base this on the following:
1. This video, which explains in large part how this hysteria may have taken root:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p_AyuhbnPOI
Coronaviruses are not new and are always around in patients near death from respitory diseases - forming 5-15% of the virus load.
People don't die from "one" virus but from their inability (normally a result of age) to deal with the range of viruses infecting their lungs.
2. The extremely low death toll from Covid 19 in China. It has been implicated in 3300 deaths, the equivalent of about 170 in the UK or 850 in the USA. These are tiny numbers and you could probably attribute many of the deaths to other viruses just as well. About 600,000 people die in the UK every year. Even if 600 more died, that would just be a minor blip.
3. In China and South Korea the number of cases seem to levelled off after about a month.
Of course, it remains to be seen if this is indeed the end of the story and whether all countries follow this pattern, but if it is, then this will be one of the remarkable episodes of self-harm ever recorded, nation after nation destroying their economies...for what?
Louis, Italian hospitals are plenty of young and (formerly) healthy people under mechanical ventilation, many of them even in critical condition.
This may seem paradoxical, but old people fear the virus and lock themselves at home, while young and healthy adults think to be invulnerable and go jogging in groups in the parks, ignoring the rules.
I consider friends all the people of this forum, so I beg you, be careful. Covid-19 is not a piece of cake.
For SpaceNut re #116
Best wishes for resilience for your family at this time.
You've told us in previous posts about various difficulties your family has come through. Hopefully you and they will make it through this one as well.
For Quaoar re #115 ... You might be able to help with even so little as a Letter to the Editor, if your community has such a thing.
Glad to hear the Chinese have come over to help. That is an indication (to me at least) the government of Italy has tried to maintain a positive relationship with China.
(th)
Italy is in good term with China. I think this is not the right time for quarrels. We Humans have to find a solution all together.
I have been hearing that the Ebola drugs did not work and patients did not stay free of the virus coming back for a second time reinfecting the individual once more. I wonder if any one has thought about using a mist tent with air aerosols that are used to kill the virus such that the person with in the tent to breath the mists which would allow for the chemical to reach within the lung where the virus is doing its damage. Spray the bedding just before you go to sleep so that you are inhaling the fumes all night long.
I was dismissed today along with all other individuals which are over 60 years of age as a means to protect us from getting it. This is an admin leave but its not known as to how long we will be told not to go to work. Tomorrow they will start telling others to go home that have family members that fit into other categories that would be devistating to them if it were brought into the home.
The government still has not passed anything to pay individuals or to grant cash or anyother method to give aid so as to not have more people losing every thing.
I hope you and your family will be safe. My thoughts are with you.
But they don't have them. So this hazardous strategy may potentially cause 6 million of death, which is almost the same toll of the Holocaust...
Well, the Holocaust was 11 million, but yes, it's a pretty big death toll we're talking about. Though only ~5% need intubation - 15% 'just' need supplemental oxygen.
It depends on the severity of pneumonia: in interstitial pneumonia the alveolar membrane become thicker and less permeable to oxygen. So less oxygen pass from alveoli to the capillary vessels. In mild cases an oxygen tank is enough, but often there is also a failure of type 2 pneumocytes, a kind of pulmonary cells producing pulmonary surfactant. Without surfactant, pulmonary alveoli collapse due to the surface tension of the water membrane that cover them: this is called ARDS (acute respiratory distress syndrome). In this case the patient has to be intubated and ventilated under positive pressure, otherwise his/her lungs collapse causing death.
For Quaoar re #112
Citizens of the United States have the ridiculous idea they might be able to communicate with the country's leaders. In practice this does not work, because of the inevitable fact of hierarchy of any system of government.
Despite that obvious reality, citizens here keep trying.
Thus, I am hopeful that you may be able to influence a decision by the government of Italy to license manufacture of Avigan as soon as possible.
In our case, the process starts with a citizen contacting the offices of the local congressperson (best bet) and the offices of the two state Senators (almost always hopeless). I'd like to encourage you to give whatever the Italian equivalent process may be a try. You will surely fail, but please let us know the stages of the failure. I can only speak for myself (of course) but I will celebrate your tilt against the windmills of Italian bureaucracy!
(th)
I'm not able to do anything. But in these days, a medical team of Chinese expert arrived in Italy and they surely know about this drug and hopefully they will inform our politician about it.
For Quaoar re #110 and topic in general
Can "Avigan" be licensed for manufacture in Italy? Can a citizen such as yourself cause that to happen?
I am impressed to see by your reply that you were already aware of the benefits of this treatment. My understanding is it has already been approved for use in dealing with flu, so approval for an emergency such as the current one should (hopefully) flow more quickly.
Edit#1: Uh oh!
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-heal … SKBN215025
Edit#2:
As a follow up to an earlier post about use of electron microscopes to create images of the Corona Virus, I wrote to Hitachi. I don't expect a reply but will post any that might arrive.
By any chance can your electron microscopes by used to rapidly identify the Corona Virus? An article about the Corona Virus showed images from electron microscopes provided by a US government agency. As I understand the problem faced by the world today, tests using chemistry are in short supply, and they take hours to perform the reactions needed.
(th)
As I'm writing this post, Avigan has just been licensed to China and has just put in mass production, so I see no reason to not do the same in our country. Italy has many pharmaceutical company that under a good direction can produce and distribute this new drug.
The problem might be the Italian bureaucracy, which is awful and now works even very slow because most part of offices are closed. But the Premier, in emergency, has the power to bypass bureaucracy and issue a decree to authorize the use of this new drug.
For Quaoar re #108 and topic in general
I've been thinking of you and your countrymen as we follow blindly behind you and so many others.
Here is a ray of hope that might be worth considering for the part of your population not yet infected. The treatment described was approved for ordinary flu, and it is apparently effective with this new virus if given ** early ** enough.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/japanese-flu … 20934.html
(th)
I'm very sorry to see the same bad things starting in other countries. It's a disaster waiting to happen, so what's the problem for politicians to give a shelter at home order before the breaking out and not after?
Science and common sense suggest that it's easier to control an epidemic whit few cases than thousands.
I have red about favipiravir (commercial name Avigan). Even if it is not so effective in the most critical case, it helps to eradicate the virus more quickly, so it's a good weapon in this war. The problem will be the large scale availability and distribution of this drug.
As an update to my earlier post about Britain planning to try an unusual (do nothing) strategy for dealing with the virus, today's Yahoo feed contains an article reporting that Mr. Johnson has been persuaded to adopt what is now seen as the best strategy to slow the spread of the virus.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/uk-abandoned … 50623.html
Even if everyone in Britain adheres to the new policy, which seems possible due to the relatively disciplined nature of the population, the health care system is likely to be overwhelmed at the peak of the event.
Wise decision: statistics said that 81% of infected people has a mild disease, 14% develop a severe disease with interstitial pneumonia and need to be be intubated and mechanically ventilated to survive, 5% develop a critical disease with pneumonia and multiple organ failure.
So given GB has 66.7 million of people, if 50% of them will be infected and 19% of them will develop severe or critical disease, they will need 6.3 million of ICU beds with ventilator.
But they don't have them. So this hazardous strategy may potentially cause 6 million of death, which is almost the same toll of the Holocaust...
And as I explained to you, I was not referring to "illegal" migration. The Chinese labourers pass through airports openly. My claim is that the work conditions are of dubious legality and that will be a contributory factor in the spread of the disease. They work in gangs, they are not genuine employees.
To dispute your claims, I offer you this (from a report on Modern Slavery):
I know my country, so let me explain you how it really works:
What you claim for Chinese is the overall situation of all Italian workers. From 1980-2000 Italy was still a rich country, so Italian workers were fully protected by laws: They have the right of 2 month/year of paid sick-leave and if they became sick during summer vacation, they had even the right to get the lost vacation days (and many people took advantage of these laws to take three months of vacation each year).
From 2000 to now, Italy impoverished and unemployment rise dramatically.
Now the laws are almost the same, and Italian workers are still full protected, but only on the papers. The reality is very different: Italian workers perfectly know if they are fired it will take years to find a new job, so they work overtime, underpaid, in dire security situation, and even through illness. You don't need gangs to force people to do this: the fear to be fired is enough.
Thanks, very useful information.
During an aero-gravity assist, after an atmospheric entry at 18-17 km/s, if plasma wake become opaque and radiate on the waverider spaceship, I suppose that the quartz windows on the upper surface must be closed with some kind of reflective panel to avoid radiation inside the cockpit. Is it correct?
I think you're in denial. China's a big place. Not all Chinese tourists would be likely to have the virus. Hong Kong even now has a tiny number of deaths (6 I think).
However, a lot of the Chinese gang workers in Northern Italy came from the Wuhan region. They will by definition be mostly relatively young and would be able to work through any illness, because that would be what was expected of them under the gang system. There will have been hundreds of these "super-spreaders" in Northern Italy, working in crowded factories, on farms, in construction and so on. That is why you have had some an explosive outbreak in my view but only in Northern Italy, not Rome, despite it being a hot spot for tourism.
As I explained you previously, in the present time, illegal immigration in Italy came mostly from Africa, Pakistan and Iraq: and these are the people who are exploited by gangs and used as a cheep work force. China is richer than Italy and now a Chinese has no interest to illegally migrate in Italy because he/she can find better work opportunity at home.
From 1980 to 2000 there was a big immigration from Asia, mostly Chinese and Filipinos, but now they are almost all regularized and perfectly integrate. Chinese residents in Italy are quite wealthy and the most part of them behave as good citizens and have a very low criminal rate.
Even Italian regular workers, now, due to job scarce, are forced to work through illness in crowded regular factories, fearing to be fired, becoming potential super-spreaders. So why to point the finger on Chinese?
A Chinese who lives in Italy, even if he/she was born in Wuhan, have exactly the same probability to become infected and transmit the virus of any other person.
Well, the "right" answer to that is from a transient thermal-structural analysis. But probably "yes".
If the backside temperature of your PICA-X exceeds about 200 F, you can't use an organic-binder composite as your substrate. The limit is about 350 F with aluminum, 750 F with titanium, and 1200 F with stainless steel.
GW
Thanks GW,
Which is the temperature limit for reinforced carbon-carbon?
And how is fixed the PICA-X on the shell?
Restaraunts and bars are being ordered closed and while food stores are open they are quickly running out of many items in the histeria along with those trying to make a buck by buying up items for later resale with price gouging for those that are dispair for the items.
In Italy, hoarding food and commodities in time of calamity to resell at higher price is a very serious crime, for which one can be jailed for up to 21 years.
You are really claiming that people in Rome and the South of Italy don't practise the double kiss? lol
So why is the outbreak so concentrated in Northern Italy and, in particular, the Lombardy region? Hmmm....I wonder why...
You are desperate to find ways to ignore the Chinese connection, aren't you? I have to ask: "Why?". Migration has always been a (not the only, of course) source of disease transmission. Pretending it isn't is just stupid.
Milan, the capital city of Lombardy, is the main economic hub of Italy, like NY for the US. So, every day, before the lock-down, thousands and thousands of people from every part of the world arrived in it and departed from it. Milan has also many important monuments, like the Duomo, the Basilica of Saint Ambrose and the Sforza Castle and famous museum like the Brera Art Gallery, so it was also crowded of tourists (many of them were from China and we Italians were very happy that they spent their money in our country). The typical Italian tourist route, in fact, was Milan-Venice-Florence-Rome. So, in absence of data, how can you say that the epidemic has come from a Chinese resident or Chinese tourist or an European businessman/woman coming back from China, or an African illegal immigrant who has had a contact with an infected Chinese?
The first outbreak of this pandemic was Wuhan, we all know it, but we live in a globalized world, where is very easy for a virus to spread everywhere. We all enjoy mass tourism, fast and cheep travels and fast information flow, but the downside of the lifestyle of this epoch is even the fast spreading of diseases.
So, as I said before, I think it is childish to quarrel about who's guilty. By now, covid-19 our common enemy and we all have to cooperate to eradicate it.
Guys, does it matter? The virus is out.
I perfectly agree with you, pandemic like this may outbreak in every country, so I think it's completely useless to quarrel about who's to blame. The best we can do is to cooperate each other to contain the disease and find a vaccine.
I think you are employing "MSM Think", trying to find a 101 reasons why the Chinese migrant labour connection doesn't explain the outbreak in Lombardy . No one is accusing the Chinese population of being unsanitary and the problem is unlikely to lie with Chinese restaurant owners in your area who probably return to China infrequently. The problem lies with poorly regulated Chinese gang labourers who are being flown in and out of the region as required.
Look at the reality. Lombardy has one of the highest concentrations of Chinese migrant labour in Europe. Much of it is of a dubious legal status. The workers are working to a gang master. There is little incentive or indeed ability to seek medical attention when you fall ill. You will on average be in a young age group in any case and so able to ride out the coronavirus infection in all likelihood. These people are used to hardship and will just carry on working through their illness.
Another relevant factor re Lombardy is that a high proportion of the Chinese migrant labour force are actually from the Wuhan region.
Spain also has a high concentration of Chinese migrant labour and is now experiencing a huge increase in the number of cases.
Countries in Europe that don't rely on Chinese migrant labour so much have experienced far lower rates of infection.
This doesn't mean it won't spread everywhere - we have no immunity, so it will. But I think the Lombardy-China connection is no coincidence, it explains why the virus got such a big hold in the region, through multiple infection routes. As a consequence Italy now has the highest death rate per population in the whole world.
Chinese illegal immigration peaked 25 years ago, when China was very poor and Italy was still a rich country. There were Chinese gangs, as you correctly said, who treated Chinese immigrant as salves and forced them to hard work in their illegal factories. I have a friend in the Carabinieri Corp who arrested many of these gang members.
But now the landscape is different. In the last decades the situation has reversed: China became rich and Italy became poor. So a Chinese worker now has no interest to migrate in Italy, where jobs are scarce and salary are low, because he/she can find far better opportunity in his/her country.
Italy has not ICE, so Chinese who illegally migrate in the 1980-2000 years now are almost all regularized. The Chinese "migrants" of today are entrepreneurs, who cheaply acquire valuable but underfunded Italian companies. There are also many young Italian scientists and engineers, unable to find a job in Italy, who are hired by Chinese companies and migrate to China.
In these years immigration in Italy has come mostly from Africa by sea and from Pakistan and Iraq by land, and these are the people who are now exploited by the mobs.
Anyway, before the outbreak of the disease, the streets of the main Italian cities, like Milan, Rome, Florence and Venice were crowded of Chinese tourist, so there is no reason to point permanent Chinese residents.
Probably one of the reason of this viral explosion is the intense social life of us Italians and our habit of the double kiss salute: it may explain why we have more and more cases than countries like Japan where people salute by bowing, never touching each other.
Hi Quaoar,
A dystopic SF novel? A good description. Just like 9-11 was a badly scripted disaster movie, this is a badly scripted SF novel using that tired old plague theme! lol
Your pain is felt here. We have not yet entered lockdown in the UK but are watching developments on mainland Europe with gathering unease.
Is your media mentioning that the real reason for Italy being hit so bad is that you have so many Chinese migrant workers in the country, especially in North Italy, and that many of them came from the Wuhan district? I have seen the number given as about 100,000. Their status seems unclear and they work under the corrupt gang system. These facts are definitely being hidden in the UK media.
The first case were a couple of elderly Chinese tourists from Wuhan, who developed cough while in Rome on 21 January, but they were suddenly hospitalized, and all the people in their tour group were quarantined, so this virus lineage was contained (after a two-month-and-an-half battle, the two tourists survived and now they are OK).
The 3rd case was an Italian repatriated from Wuhan who was tested positive on 6 February and quarantined.
In Lombardy, the first case was a 38-year-old Italian man named Mattia, who went to a local first aid for a strong cough on 14 February. There, he spent many hours in the waiting room with many people before being dismissed without testing (at the time only people who had come from China had to be tested, according to the guideline). Then he developed a pneumonia and went again to the first aid. This time the doctor bent the protocol and tested him anyway. Mattia was found positive, hospitalized and put in a ICU, but in the meantime he had infected many people, who in turn spread the virus, causing the disaster. Mattia survived after being ventilated for almost a month, but it was not possible to find who infected him.
Lombardy, like every part of Italy, is full of Chinese-Italians and Chinese immigrant, but there is no evidence that the virus has come from them. Anyway a Chinese who lives in Italy has almost the same probability to get the virus and transmit it of every other Italian.
In my neighborhood there are many Chinese restaurant and shop-owners, who are very nice persons. During this ordeal, they showed a very strong self-discipline in obeying the orders of sanitary authority and very soon they locked themselves at home, better than many Italians, who though it's just like a flu.
In January, before the outbreak of the disease in Italy, I asked "Is it really so bad?" to the Chinese owner of a restaurant I used to eat before the lock down.
"You can not even imagine how bad it is" was her answer, and unfortunately she was right.
Hi Quaoar:
You kinda have to take what you can get. Carbon-carbon is pretty much black. I'm not familiar with any coatings that might work which would change its effective color. But any such would have to survive at the ablation temperature, which for carbon, is very high indeed.
You would only need carbon-carbon the ablative at stagnation zones. That's nosetips and aerosurface leading edges. The rest of the heat shield can be something else, such as PICA-X ablative tiles, which actually can be anywhere from near white to pretty-much-black in color.
I don't know enough about PICA-X to know if it can be used at stagnation zone conditions, but I suspect that it can. It was developed from the earlier version PICA, in turn developed for Mars free-return capability at 12-17 km/s entry speeds. If it can serve at stagnation zones like I suspect, then you don't need the carbon-carbon. Your speeds look about like high-end Mars return speeds.
I already know PICA-X works for the entire Dragon capsule heat shield, including its stagnation zone. That's well-tested and flyable multiple times through Earth orbit entries at 8 km/s. The "voice of rumor control" says it'll survive perhaps twice coming back from the moon at nearly 11 km/s. Supposedly, it'll survive a Mars entry at 7.5 km/s and one Mars free return at 12-17 km/s.
You end up using thicker tiles on the more windward surfaces, thickest at the stagnation zones. I do not know what they use to bond them down to the substrate. The tile does have some thermal gradient through it, but not nearly what the low density ceramic tiles did on the Space Shuttle.
I suspect the PICA-X bondline is rather hot, and the substrate cannot be composite or aluminum, and probably not titanium. My guess is around 1000-1200 F, based on what Spacex has been uncovering in its work. Spacex developed PICA-X as an easier-to-make version of NASA's PICA.
The bondline temperature you have to tolerate depends very critically upon the surface ablation temperature, the thermal conductivity through the ablative, and the thermal resistance of the path or paths for the heat conduction on into the interior structure. Thermal conductivity is inherently density-related: higher density materials have inherently higher thermal conductivity, and therefore tend to be very nearly isothermal, even at very high thermal fluxes through them.
Myself, I am more familiar with materials like the fiber-reinforced phenolic plastic. The very early heat shields on Mercury and Gemini were made of such. I used them differently, though. As rocket and ramjet nozzle materials. That's a completely-different problem, even though ablation is involved.
GW
Thank, GW
So I can use white PICA-X on a steel shell or on a 3D carbon-carbon shell.
It was my understanding from the various Musk presentations that the Starship tank design featured a set of "header tanks" nested within the main tanks. The main tanks would be essentially emptied by the launch burn or the Earth orbit departure burn. The much smaller volume inside the "header tanks" would be the landing burn allowance. There was no other propellant volume stored.
Doing this means the main tank wall need not be insulated for long term cryogenic storage, since the propellant need be stored only for a few hours (waiting to launch mostly). The outer main tank wall then does not have cold liquid in contact with it during the hot exposure of atmospheric entry. It does provide a solar shading effect that lowers evaporation rates from the insulated header tanks nested inside, which enhances storage life of the landing burn propellant.
OK, now the outer main tank wall (and the wall of the cargo and pressurized living spaces) must resist high angle-of-attack airloads during entry. Order of magnitude, the pressure that must be resisted by the curved surfaces is the vehicle weight times max gees divided by the exposed area. It has to resist those airload pressures while equilibriated hot enough for re-radiation to balance peak entry heating.
300 series stainless steels have ultimate tensile strengths in the neighborhood of only 5 ksi when soaked out to 1200 F. Hotter is far weaker. So about 1000-1200 F is all you can allow. 301 and 304L are going to form oxide scaling at 1200 F, 316L and 347 do not until about 1600 F. But all have about the same tensile strength, and it "falls off a cliff" hotter than 1200 F.
You have to coat or treat the surface to be dark if you expect to radiationally cool the structure. By that, I mean the emissivity (same as absorbtivity) must be high (above 0.80) at the wavelengths band associated with a material temperature in the 1000-1200 F range. This re-radiational heat flow is a large number at high emissivity, large enough that this method of cooling is much to be preferred over any other method.
What messes this up is plasma radiation from the boundary layer adjacent to the material. Once radiational heating is dominant above 10 km/s entry speeds, then the plasma layer gets more and more opaque to the thermal radiation coming from the skin. That opacity effectively "cuts off" the radiation cooling mode.
And THAT is why entry returning from the moon (10.9 km/s) or from deep space (12-17 km/s) is SO much more challenging than entry from low Earth orbit (8 km/s). Or from low Mars orbit (3.6 km/s).
You DO NOT want the "shiny metal space ship" for returning from Earth orbit. You want a dark or black surface, and you probably need a heat shield on your windward side. It'll last longer if its dark, because the heat input rate causing ablation will be lower.
Coming back from the moon or deep space, you do want the shiny metal skin to reflect plasma radiation away, but you have to cool it! And that's very heavy and energy-consumptive. Or else cover it with a whitish heat shield, like we did Apollo.
NO ONE is immune to these physics. They simply "are". Truth lies in the numbers, not the tweets, and not the press releases.
GW
So my interplanetary waverider heat shield, which ha to stand 17-18 km/s entries, has to be white, and even ablative. Which material do you suggest? May a reinforced carbon-carbon be white?
Thanks